Kate’s Review: “Queer As All Get Out”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Queer As All Get Out: 10 People Who’ve Inspired Me” by Shelby Criswell

Publishing Info: Street Noise Books, October 2021

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eBook from the publisher

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: This graphic novel paints a picture of the lives of 10 specific LGBTQIA people from history, framed by the personal struggles of the author to find acceptance and to carve out a meaningful life as a genderqueer person. Each chapter focuses on a different relatively little-known historical character, presented within the context of the author’s own life. Shelby Criswell’s art is fun and engaging and brings a comic book feel to this enlightening and important subject matter.

Review: Thank you to Street Noise Books for sending me an eBook of this graphic novel!

In honor of Street Noise Books’s 5th Anniversary in publishing, they were kind enough to ask if I would like to help celebrate this achievement with them by highlighting one of their titles from the past five years. I was absolutely into this idea, as I really enjoyed the other works they’ve sent me and because I love the focus on political and social conscious themes. So today I bring you the graphic novel memoir/history book “Queer As All Get Out: 10 People Who’ve Inspired Me” by Shelby Criswell, a book about important queer people in history who have kind of been lost or forgotten to mainstream history as time has gone on. I was very eager to dive into this book, and I was very, very impressed by it.

As a history based graphic novel, this is a great read. While I had heard of a few of the people that Criswell highlights, there were so many that I had absolutely no clue existed even though their contributions and achievements are impressive and impactful. They stories are separated into different sections interspersed with Criswell’s own perspectives of being an out queer person (more on that in a bit), and you can tell that there was a lot of research and a lot of care put into telling these peoples stories correctly and respectfully. From people like Magnus Hirshfeld to Nancy Cárdenas to We’wha and more, the contributions range from the arts, medicine, politics, music, science, and it’s so comprehensive without feeling overwhelming or overstuffed. Criswell clearly did their homework and provides great overviews of these important figures in queer/LGBTQIA+ history, but goes even a step further and has an extensive bibliography for readers to do even more delving if they so choose. I learned so much and it was always very accessible and never felt overwhelming with information.

But I also I really enjoyed how Criswell managed to tie their own story as a queer person living in San Antonio into a really well done exploration of queer people in history who have been overlooked for so many years. Representation is so important for people to be able to see themselves in stories and history, and for far too long many marginalized groups didn’t get as many examples of people like them to be able to see and resonate with. Not only do we get these great minibiographies, we also get the story of a queer person who is trying to figure out their own self, and how these people who have been largely ignored or forgotten are being remembered and being inspirational in their journey of self-discovery. It’s a great way to show the importance of representation in a personal way that the reader can see first hand, and I thought it never detracted from the history bits, which was really great to see.

“Queer As All Get Out” is a great history book, and I mean that not only for LGBTQIA+ history, but also just history in general. The research is there, the facts are accessible, and the point is clear. I definitely recommend it.

Rating 9: An illuminating history of queer and trans people who have contributed to culture and society but have been lost to history, “Queer As All Get Out” is a great history book, LGBTQIA+ or otherwise.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Queer As All Get Out” is included on the Goodreads lists “Reading Rainbow – Queer Graphic Novels”, and “Books for Baby Queers”.

Serena’s Review: “A Forgery of Fate”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Forgery of Fate” by Elizabeth Lim

Publishing Info: Knopf Books for Young Readers, June 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: Netgalley!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Truyan Saigas didn’t choose to become a con artist, but after her father is lost at sea, it’s up to her to support her mother and two younger sisters. A gifted art forger, Tru has the unique ability to paint the future, but even such magic is not enough to put her family back together again, or stave off the gangsters demanding payment in blood for her mother’s gambling debts.

Left with few options, Tru agrees to a marriage contract with a mysterious dragon lord. He offers a fresh start for her mother and sisters and elusive answers about her father’s disappearance, but in exchange, she must join him in his desolate undersea palace. And she must assist him in a plot to infiltrate the tyrannical Dragon King’s inner circle, painting a future so treasonous, it could upend both the mortal and immortal realms..

Review: Obviously, I’m probably going to read almost anything that bills itself as a new version of “Beauty and the Beast.” And, while I didn’t fully connect with previous books I’ve read by this author, I still think she has a strong, compelling style to her writing that, at the very least, will be good reading on its own. So reading this book was an odd mixture of expected points of interest and strange disconnects.

First of all, I very much enjoyed the main character. Not only was she an engaging lead, full of spunk, smarts, and a refreshing streak of pragmatism, but her magical abilities tied to painting and prophesy were incredibly interesting. The author wisely crafted this magic system to be just useful enough, often giving Tru (and the reader) glimpses of a future that may end up presenting itself in a completely different manner than how one might at first interpret it.

Beyond Tru’s abilities, I really liked the magic and world-building of this story. Much of these fantasy elements were of the whimsical sort, such that if you perhaps spent too much time trying to picture how any of this worked, it could be frustrating. But if simply accepted and viewed through a lens of wonder, much of it was fantastical and beautiful. Yes, I did get caught up with movement in the underwater scenes more times than I want to admit, but that might just be a “me” issue. Obviously, I also really liked the dragon lore and the way this was tied up in the classic “Beauty and the Beast” tale.

As for characters, I also enjoyed many of the side characters and Tru’s intimate family. Tru’s relationship with her family is strained by the circumstances they find themselves in, but I enjoyed the layers this added to their dynamics, particularly between Tru and her mother. And, of course, I loved Tru’s devotion to her sisters. I was sad when they disappeared for large chunks of the middle of the book, though that’s probably to be expected in a retelling of “Beauty and the Beast.” I also really liked many of the inhabitants of the “castle” that Tru meets and befriends.

Unfortunately, the one real sticking point for me was the romance itself. It started off strong, with a spark-filled first scene, but then things seemed to peter out completely as the story continued. For one thing, they simply didn’t seem to spend enough time together to justify any growing interest, at least on Tru’s part. There was a lot of action, but much of it was spent apart, which then made Tru’s growing interest feel disconnected from anything we’d seen on the page. Even as I was told that the attraction was growing, I never felt it. Beyond this, there was a “twist” that was introduced late in the story that I think only complicated this relationship, and not in a good way.

Overall, I think this was a successful fantasy adventure story, and Tru was a great main character on her own. However, as a “Beauty and the Beast” re-imaging, I think it struggled with a lackluster romance. Fans of this author, however, should definitely still give it a go and I’m still committed to checking out new books by her in the future, as I think her storytelling is only improving over time!

Rating 8: A whimsical, fantasy adventure, though a bit lacking in the love story itself.

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Forgery of Fate” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Chinese, Japanese, and Korean Fantasy and Favorite Retellings.

Kate’s Review: “The Long Walk”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Long Walk” by Stephen King (writing as Richard Bachman)

Publishing Info: Signet Books, July 1979

Where Did I Get This Book: I own it.

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: Against the wishes of his mother, sixteen-year-old Ray Garraty is about to compete in the annual grueling match of stamina and wits known as The Long Walk. One hundred boys must keep a steady pace of four miles per hour without ever stopping… with the winner being awarded “The Prize”—anything he wants for the rest of his life. But, as part of this national tournament that sweeps through a dystopian America year after year, there are some harsh rules that Garraty and ninety-nine others must adhere to in order to beat out the rest. There is no finish line—the winner is the last man standing. Contestants cannot receive any outside aid whatsoever. Slow down under the speed limit and you’re given a warning. Three warnings and you’re out of the game—permanently…

Review: I first read “The Long Walk”, one of Stephen King’s ‘Bachman Books’, in 2015, just a couple of months before we started the blog. So about ten years ago! It had be recommended to me by one of my very closest coworkers at the library I was working at at the time, and I was absolutely enthralled with it. It instantly skyrocketed up to my top 3 Stephen King books (with “The Stand” and “Carrie” along with it). When I saw that they were going to make a movie based on this book I was excited, but nervous. Then I saw the trailer, and was like “I NEEEEEED TO SEEEEEE IT!!!” Serena and I are actually planning on going at some point, and I have plans to see it with other people too. And the time is almost upon us, as the movie comes out this Friday. So I thought that it would be the perfect time for a reread and to finally review it on this blog, since it JUST missed out. And wow. It hit even harder this time around.

Actual footage of me reeling on the couch while reading as the kittens come to see what’s happening…. (source)

I’ve always said that when King was writing as Bachman he felt no need to be hopeful or optimistic. Most of King’s books have some kind of hints at hope even in all the darkness (there ARE exceptions; “Pet Sematary”, “Cujo”, “Carrie” all come to mind), but when he wrote as Bachman he was just fine being a huge bummer. “The Long Walk” basically keeps up with that pattern, as a group of teenage boys participate in an unending walk in hopes of being the last man standing to receive a prize to make their lives better. After all, in “The Long Walk” America has been taken over by cruel authoritarian fascists who value control and violence to maintain it (ughhhhh), and the televised Long Walk competition is entertainment built from children being killed if they stop walking at the speeds they are supposed to be at. Our protagonist is Ray Garraty, who joined like all others thinking that walking at 5 miles per hour is easy and that the money will be his, but as the walk keeps going he and his companions start to break down as they are all picked off one by one (and let me tell you, when I was originally reading this I tried to walk as long as I could at 5mph while on a treadmill at the gym. It was NOT EASY). Garraty and other contestants, like the steadfast and snarky McVries, the antagonistic and crude Barkovitch, and the mysterious Stebbins, enter in and out of each other’s orbits as their companions are killed, they become physically exhausted, and their mental faculties start to break down. It’s tense, it’s awful, and it is relentless. I know that King has said he originally wrote this book when he was in college, when boys he knew were being drafted and sent to Vietnam, and the hopelessness and bleakness definitely harkens to the idea of young men and boys being sent into a meat grinder for a country’s own devices. But as someone who now has a kid of her own this book hit THAT MUCH HARDER, with these children sobbing, screaming, or in some cases dying slowly and painfully before actually being shot for losing (one character contracts pneumonia while walking, and my God it was harrowing as he slips further and further into illness with no ways to rest and heal). There was one moment with a character screaming about his feet for prolonged moments where I couldn’t go any further for a bit. I just had to put it down. It’s an effective and dark dystopian nightmare.

BUT. There are also moments of intimacy and camaraderie between some of the characters, specifically Garraty and McVries, that show that even in the darkest and most terrible times and experiences, if you can find someone, or a community, to hold onto, there will always be bits of hope. The relationship between Garraty and McVries was so, so lovely, as while it has its ups and downs as the contest goes on and their stress, exhaustion, and fear kick in, you can tell that they both have a connection that keeps each other going. There has long been queer subtext speculated about these characters, which is definitely a fair way to interpret it, but what I loved about their friendship is that it’s another example of one of my favorite relationship portrayals: when two people connect to each other and get each other on a level that transcends platonic and romantic and is a whole other thing that isn’t quite definable. It makes them that much more touching and intimate, and that much more tragic as the story goes on. This book isn’t optimistic or hopeful as a whole, but these bits as these boys keep each other going DO have small bright spots in a sea of despair. And it’s a reminder of how important that can be.

“The Long Walk” is still one of my favorite Stephen King novels. It’ll wreck you if you let it. But it’s so, so good.

Rating 10: This is still one of my favorite Stephen King books. Devastating, tense, and bleak, but so incredibly emotional with glimmers of intimacy and camaraderie.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Long Walk” is included on the Goodreads lists “Dystopia!”, and “Games of Death”.

Book Club Review: “Redshirts”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. Re-visiting some of our past themes, we’re once again pulling genres from a hatch and matching them together in one book. For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club!

Book: “Redshirts” by John Scalzi

Publishing Info: Tor Books, June 2012

Where Did We Get This Book: Kate owns it;

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Mix-and-Match Genres: Science Fiction and Humor

Book Description: Ensign Andrew Dahl has just been assigned to the Universal Union Capital Ship Intrepid, flagship of the Universal Union since the year 2456. It’s a prestige posting, and Andrew is thrilled all the more to be assigned to the ship’s Xenobiology laboratory.

Life couldn’t be better…until Andrew begins to pick up on the fact that:
(1) every Away Mission involves some kind of lethal confrontation with alien forces
(2) the ship’s captain, its chief science officer, and the handsome Lieutenant Kerensky always survive these confrontations
(3) at least one low-ranked crew member is, sadly, always killed.

Not surprisingly, a great deal of energy below decks is expended on avoiding, at all costs, being assigned to an Away Mission. Then Andrew stumbles on information that completely transforms his and his colleagues’ understanding of what the starship Intrepid really is…and offers them a crazy, high-risk chance to save their own lives.

Kate’s Thoughts

I’m the one who pulled the two genres for this book, and while my immediate reaction was ‘oh no Science Fiction?!’, my second reaction was ‘oh that’s easy, I’ll pick “Redshirts”!’ When thinking of these two genres combined it was an easy conclusion, as it’s been touted as one of the funniest Sci-Fi novels of the past couple of decades. While I hadn’t read it, my husband has a copy (signed by John Scalzi, no less, with a very hilarious inscription), so it just seemed like a good excuse to pick up the book he had been so keen on ten years ago. Plus, I love “Star Trek”. It seemed like a no brainer.

And for the most part I enjoyed it! It is definitely very funny with its tongue planted firmly in cheek, and it was so fun seeing the references and winks about not only “Star Trek” but also cruddy cable or syndicated Sci-Fi shows that tried to desperately to be it. I enjoyed the hilarious ways that Dahl and the other more ‘expendable’ crew members would be put in ludicrous situations with ludicrous outcomes, and enjoyed the parodying of the more ‘important’ crew members and how absolutely insufferable they are with their plot armor. But what I really enjoyed about this book was when our ‘space crew’ came to the real world to confront their makers, as not only did it feel like a cute reference to “Star Trek 4: The Voyage Home” (my very FAVORITE “Trek” film), but it also turns into an interesting rumination on the way that characters can feel like they come to life and go their own way beyond their creators controls. And I also really liked the three separate codas at the end, each representing the first, second, and third person perspectives, and how they managed to add to the story but didn’t feel superfluous in spite of the fact they were kind of tangental.

“Redshirts” was fun!! I’m glad that I finally picked it up.

Serena’s Thoughts

I was super excited when Kate picked this book! It’s been on my TBR list for forever, but for whatever reason, I’d never gotten around to it. And I really have no excuse; not only do I enjoy science fiction in general, but I also really love “Star Trek.” And boy did this book not disappoint!

While I think many of the sci-fi tropes being touched on would be easily recognizable to most general fans, this is definitely one of those parodies that is better appreciated the more knowledge of “Star Trek” you have. On top of the titular commentary of the “redshirts” who were only ever there to die terribly while the main cast sailed through the plot, there were also so many fun little references scattered throughout. And, like Kate referenced, it was particularly fun having the main plot call back to “Voyage Home,” one of the most popular of the films.

The humor and parody is central to the plot, and this was both a good thing and a bad thing. It was laugh-out-loud funny consistently throughout, but if you go in looking for much of the deeper commentary or more layered dynamics often found in science fiction, you won’t really find that here. I enjoyed the characters and the story itself, but, other than the comedy itself, nothing was particularly memorable. But I think for a book like this, that works fine! This is a fairly straight-forward story focused on sending up a beloved science fiction franchise, with all the love and ridicule it can muster!

Kate’s Rating 8: A fun and funny send up and love letter to “Star Trek” and campy Sci-Fi TV, as well as an interesting exploration of art and creation.

Serena’s Rating 8: A rollicking good time that will be especially gratifying for all of the “Ster Trek” fans out there!

Book Club Questions

  1. This book has been referred to as post-modern Science Fiction as well as meta fiction Science Fiction. Have you read any meta books before, Sci-Fi or otherwise?
  2. This book takes a lot of inspiration (and is a lovely send up of) “Star Trek”. If you have watched “Star Trek” did you enjoy this book? If not, did it still work for you even without the frame of reference?
  3. The original title of this book was “Redshirts: A Book With Three Codas”. Which of the three codas was your favorite?
  4. What do you think this book was saying about fate and free will?
  5. What do you think that John Scalzi as a writer was trying to convey about writing as an art form?
  6. One of the biggest praises of this book is the humor. What moment stood out as funniest to you?

Reader’s Advisory

“Redshirts” is included on the Goodreads lists “Best Comedic Science Fiction Books”, and “Humorous Space Opera”.

Next Book Club Pick: “Someplace Generous: An Inclusive Romance Anthology” by Elaina Ellis (Ed.) & Amber Flame (Ed.)

Serena’s Review: “It Happened on a Sunday”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “It Happened on a Sunday” by Tracy Wolff

Publishing Info: Entangled: Amara, September 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: They call her the Black Widow. A pop star. A tabloid tragedy. A girl who set the world on fire—and got burned in return.

But Sloane Walker doesn’t care what they say. Not anymore. The headlines, the hashtags, the rumors that never die? Let them come. She’s survived worse—like the ex who tried to kill her and the fans who blamed her for surviving. These days, she’s armor and eyeliner, singing songs that hurt and pretending they don’t.

She’s halfway through a sold-out tour and dangerously close to unraveling when a meet-and-greet throws her into the path of Mateo Sylvester—a rising star quarterback with a devastating smile and a grandmother who’s Sloane’s biggest fan. He’s got stadiums at his feet and the press eating from his hand. She’s got a flask full of sweet tea, a voice full of ghosts, and no patience for golden boys with good intentions.

She tells herself it’s just a photo op. Just another handshake. Just another charming fan with perfect cheekbones and no idea what it means to bleed for your art.But Mateo sees more than the stage persona. He sees the cracks in her smile. The songs she’s too scared to write. The girl underneath the glitter, still fighting to stay.They weren’t supposed to fall. Not in the spotlight. Not when the world is watching. And definitely not when the people closest to them would do anything to keep them apart.

This isn’t a fairy tale. It’s a slow-motion car crash. And if they’re not careful, it might just cost them everything.

Review: As I’ve ventured further into romantasy and fantasy romance fiction, I’ve also started dipping my toes back into other subgenres of romance. I’ve most regularly enjoyed historical romance novels (Sherry Thomas, one of my favorite authors, has written several!), though I’ve been known to read a few contemporary romances sprinkled throughout. I’ll be honest, these are the hardest sell for me, most of the time. But I’ve also read a few recently that I’ve enjoyed (after loving “Shield of Sparrows,” I’ve gone back and read a few of Devney Perry’s contemporary books and really enjoyed them, though I haven’t reviewed those here on the blog.) All of this to say, I was happy to jump on board when I was given the opportunity to review an early copy of this title!

So, this one both worked really well for me in some areas, but also was a struggle in others. First off, there’s no escaping the obvious and intentional parallels to Taylor Swift and and Travis Kelce (the book leans into this, in fact, with several references to Swift’s songs). I don’t particularly enjoy Taylor Swift, but that’s more due to the fact that her style of music isn’t my preferred style, and less to do with anything to do with her particular songs. Further, I’m by no means caught up on all of the celebrity gossip and drama to be found there. That said, there’s no avoiding the basic points, so it was easy to see the lines being drawn within the book.

However, I think the author did a very good job of distancing this story enough from these real life individuals. While there are similarities to be found, the core of the story revolves around an almost “thriller-like” plot line involving the mysterious deaths of Sloane’s previous boyfriends and the present danger of an increasingly threatening stalker. And, of course, this gives the book plenty of opportunities to place our romantic hero in a protective role as the couple tries to cope with these increasingly dire circumstances. All of this gives the book a lot of action, as well as fully centers the story around unique characters who aren’t simply carbon cut-outs of their real-life counterparts.

I will say, there were quite a few moments that push the limits of credibility with the way many things played out, particularly with the stalker plot-line. However, this is a romance novel first and foremost, so I didn’t go in with expectations of a hard-nosed thriller/mystery. That being the case, it was easy enough to sit back and enjoy this plot line for what it was. And by far, this mystery and built up sense of danger was my favorite part of the book.

Unfortunately, while I liked the the thriller aspects of the story, I struggled more with the romance itself. For one thing, there was exactly zero build up or progression of feelings. Instead, by date number two, love is being expressed and devotion committed. While I expect romance novels to move a bit more quickly than my slow-burning heart desires, this one was fast even by comparative standards. There was no tension, no push and pull, just instant gratification. It was all too much and too fast for me to ever feel fully invested in their relationship.

Further, some of the writing was a bit off-putting to me at times. While most of the book is written in a very casual style, there would be random moments where the author would throw in obscure, lesser-used terms. These moments always stood out to me, almost as if a second editor had went through and used a thesaurus sporadically to “smarten up” the text. It just read as off. Similarly, some of the spicey scenes also included phrases and descriptions that felt oddly clinical or even eerie at times, leaving me feeling as if perhaps there was some deeper mystery being built up between the two. But nope, in the end, it seems like it was just odd writing choices.

Overall, this was an ok read. I enjoyed the stalker plot line and the tension that was built up as this threat intensified. However, the love story itself didn’t quite land for me. That said, I do think this book will work well for a lot of contemporary romance fans, particularly those who have enjoyed following Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s love story!

Rating 7: I enjoyed the stalker plot line quite a bit, but the romance took off too quickly and never quite struck the right chord (chord…get it??) with me.

Reader’s Advisory:

“It Happened on a Sunday” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Musicians Romances and September 2025 Sports Romance Release.

Serena’s Review: “A Land So Wide”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Land So Wide” by Erin A. Craig

Publishing Info: Pantheon, September 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: Edelweiss+

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Like everyone else in the settlement of Mistaken, Greer Mackenzie is trapped. Founded by an ambitious Scottish lumber merchant, the tiny town on the edge of the American continent is blessed with rich natural resources that have made its people prosperous—but at a cost. The same woods that have lined the townsfolks’ pockets harbor dangerous beasts: wolves, bears, and the Bright-Eyeds—monsters beyond description who have rained utter destruction down on nearby settlements. But Mistaken’s founders made a deal with the mysterious Benevolence: the Warding Stones that surround the town will keep the Bright-Eyeds out—and the town’s citizens in. Anyone who spends a night within Mistaken’s borders belongs to it forever.

Greer, a mapmaker and eccentric dreamer, has always ached to explore the world outside, even though she knows she and her longtime love, Ellis Beaufort, will never see it. Until, on the day she and Ellis are meant to finally begin their lives together, Greer watches in horror as her beloved disappears beyond the Warding Stones, pursued by a monstrous creature. Swiftly realizing that the stories she was raised on might be more myth than fact, Greer figures out a way to escape Mistaken for the very first time. Determined to rescue Ellis, she begins a trek through the cold and pitiless wilderness. But Greer is being hunted, not only by the ruthless Bright-Eyeds but by the secret truths behind Mistaken’s founding, as well as her own origins.

Playfully drawing from Scottish folklore, Erin A. Craig’s adult debut is both a deeply atmospheric and profoundly romantic exploration of freedom versus security: a stunning celebration of one woman’s relentless bravery on a quest to reclaim her lost love—and claim her own future.

Review: I haven’t read many books by this author, but the one I did read I absolutely loved (“The Thirteenth Child”). While that book was particularly up my alley with its original fairytale feeling, the writing throughout was incredibly strong and I loved the romantic subplot. This all being the case, I was super excited to check out the latest book by Craig coming out this fall, especially since it was her adult debut!

Unfortunately, this one wasn’t for me. Which is pretty surprising, because looking at the book description, this one definitely should be for me! However, there were some important factors not included in the book description that really played with my expectations vs. reality. Let’s start with some positives though! Overall, I still found the quality of the writing itself very good. The prologue was fire and perfectly set up this creepy woods and the claustrophobia of the village and its people now trapped within it, essentially. As the story expanded, I enjoyed a lot of what we learned about this world itself and the beings who inhabited it. Some of these twists were definitely not of the sort that I expected (the types of magical beings, especially), but I was happy enough to go along with it, as I thought the interpretation here was interesting.

However, I really struggled with both the romance and the main character. Like I said, the prologue was excellent, and after that strong start, I went in to the main plot of the story with high expectations. The prologue was mature, dark, and epic, setting up what I thought would be an excellent adult fantasy novel. However, the very next chapter when we meet the main character and are introduced to the current time and cast of characters, I immediately had concerns.

Gone was that adult voice. Instead, while I was told that Greer was in her late 20s, she immediately read as a teenager. Her thoughts, actions, and dialogue all read as incredibly immature, and I really struggled to take her seriously as an adult woman. I get that part of her arc is that she is rather naive to start with, but this felt like more than naivety and really just like she was a teenager instead. Perhaps if I had been primed for a YA fantasy story, this might have bothered me less. But I can’t even say that for sure, as much of what Greer was saying and thinking would have been fairly immature and annoying even in a teen book. I know this is Craig’s debut with an adult book, but I’m struggling to see what changes were made to this text to age it up from her typical YA books.

The pacing was also fairly slow. On one hand, I don’t mind slower books, but, like I said, there was a mismatch between the book description and reality. In that, the book summary emphasizes Ellis’s disappearance into the forest and Greer’s subsequent quest to find him. It makes it sounds like these events happen early, with the main focus of the text centering around Greer’s time looking for him. Instead, this event doesn’t even take place until nearly halfway through the book! Again, this isn’t necessarily a bad thing on its own, but some readers may find themselves frustrated, having picked up a book marketed as one woman’s quest only to find that that story is only the last half of this entire book.

Lastly, there was a love triangle introduced out of nowhere. And man, did I hate it. Obviously, it’s well-document that I don’t enjoy love triangles. But this one felt egregious, in that I felt like the entire romantic rug was pulled out from under me. Again, the story is set up to be Greer’s quest to find and save the man she loves! And much of the first half of the book is devoted to the foundations of this relationship. And then, randomly, this second love interest is introduced, completely undercutting the romance and love story of the first relationship, the one that is meant to serve as the core of the book plot that was advertised to me in the first place. Beyond that, there were some weird dynamics in this second relationship that I didn’t particularly enjoy. In the end, by the time I got to the end, I was less invested in the love story than I had been at the start. And that’s never what you want.

So, yeah. Unfortunately, this one was a pretty big whiff for me. I know that Craig is a talented author, so I’m not quite sure what happened here. Part of me wants to blame this on her shift to adult fantasy, that perhaps she took the wrong lessons to heart when trying to make this jump. Adding a love triangle and minor amounts of spice isn’t what’s important to adult fantasy. Instead, your characters have to…you know…read like adults. Fans of this author may still want to check this one out, especially if you enjoy love triangles. But I don’t think this one quite hit the target it was aiming for.

Rating 6: An unfortunate love triangle and a main character who read as much younger than her years really tanked this one for me.

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Land So Wide” can be found on this Goodreads list: Can’t Wait Sci-Fi/Fantasy of 2025.

Kate’s Review: “In Deadly Company”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “In Deadly Company” by L.S. Stratton

Publishing Info: Union Square & Co, September 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publicist

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: A year after the blowout birthday celebration she organized accidentally ended in the death of her nightmare, one-percenter boss, Xander Chambers, Nicole Underwood thought she was setting the public record straight by agreeing to consult on a feature film based on her story. But on the set in LA, she watches in frustration as her experiences are persistently sidelined by inappropriate casting and frequent, bizarre script changes.
 
Nicole is haunted by the events of that fateful house party and visions of her now deceased boss. Xander had been unfit to lead the company his mother—famed entrepreneur Bridget Chambers—had founded and built to Fortune 500 status until her untimely death in a car accident several months prior. After being Bridget’s favorite assistant, Nicole had honored her mentor by staying on to keep Xander organized and on task despite his relentless partying. When he wanted her to plan his wild bash, Nicole saw a chance to probe the people closest to the Chambers family and learn if Bridget’s crash was truly a simple tragedy. But Nicole, who just wanted to be the best assistant possible, could not have foreseen the terrible consequences of her actions.

Review: Thank you to Sparkpoint Studio for sending me an ARC of this novel!

If a book comes at me and promises to have a “White Lotus” vibe to it I am probably going to be interested regardless, as that show is such a (not so) guilty pleasure for me. There’s something tantalizing for me about nasty wealthy people being shown as nasty with fun bits of dark humor AND the perspectives of the less wealthy having to deal with their bullshit. So it’s probably not shocking that when I was offered “In Deadly Company” by L. S. Stratton, which centers on an assistant of a notoriously awful billionaire reeling from a weekend that ends in multiple deaths, I was like ‘oh yes please’.

The plot is straightforward and very twisty, with two different perspective times and multiple perspective characters (though some are more prominent than others). Our main character is Nicole (or Nikki), the former assistant to famous billionaire Xander Chambers. She had been the assistant to his mother Bridget, but when Bridget died in a car accident she was kept on my Xander, who was far more crass and far less outwardly magnanimous. We have a first person POV in the present day, where she’s acting as a consultant on a film about a deadly weekend during Xander’s birthday celebration that happened a year prior. We also have third person POVs back to the weekend of the birthday bash, with Nicole and a couple other characters serving as the perspectives. I liked the way that Stratton used these two timelines, as it gives us a way to look at some very personal fallout for Nicole in the present day while also giving us hints beyond her scope during the birthday weekend. Nicole is a VERY enjoyably protagonist, as not only is she one of the few likable people in the book, she is also funny and sardonic and very easy to root for, whether that’s because of the crappy behavior of her employer and his terrible friends that she has to run damage control for, or the saccharine and very inauthentic movie production that she has been roped into in hopes of setting the record straight (while having to deal with colorism, misogynoir, and the general misrepresentation in the pursuit of a narrative that Hollywood is known for).

As a mystery, it had a lot of pretty well set up twists and turns. I could call a few of them here and there, but there were a couple that generally blew me away. Stratton has a dubious (in a good way) list of suspects, all of whom are believable to be killers or at least malevolent BECAUSE they are all such shifty and careless people, and if that doesn’t sum up the billionaire class I don’t know what does. Nicole’s interactions with them elicit both dark satire as well as ugly realities. I will say that I didn’t buy into the romance between Nicole and Jeremiah as much, but that’s not because of either of the characters. Like I said above I really liked Nicole, and Jeremiah was a solid ‘outsider’ perspective to give us more clues that Nicole wouldn’t necessarily be privy to when he did have his perspective points. But I thought that the romance between them could have had a bit more exploration and depth as opposed to the re-introduced whirlwind with so many other things happening in such a short period of time. But again, that’s a minor quibble in a story I generally enjoyed!

Ultimately I enjoyed “In Deadly Company” as it points out the greed and sociopathy of billionaires (both in the corporate and entertainment world) all wrapped up in a fast paced whodunnit. Definitely an enjoyable thriller!

Rating 8: A fun murder mystery with under-appreciated workers and conniving elites, “In Deadly Company” was a fast read that had me surprised consistently.

Reader’s Advisory:

“In Deadly Company” isn’t on any Goodreads lists as of now, but it would fit in on “Damn These Rich People!”.

Serena’s Review: “The Second Death of Locke”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Second Death of Locke” by V. L. Bovalino

Publishing Info: Orbit, September 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: Netgalley!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Grey Flynn has dedicated her life to her mage, Kier.

She will be his blade on the battlefield, his healer and protector. The deep well of raw power inside her is Kier’s to use. Grey would do anything for Kier – be anything for him – if he would only ask.

When a quest to protect the child of an enemy kingdom pulls them into the dangerous heart of their nation’s war, Grey and Kier will need to decide what they are willing to sacrifice to protect their secret.

For Grey is no ordinary magical well, but heir to the lost island of Locke – the root of all power. If she dies, all magic dies with her.

Review: I’ve always had an inkling that I’m probably not the typical romantasy reader. Not only do I not often enjoy the most popular titles in the genre, but, especially as I’ve gotten older, my preference for romantic tropes has shifted greatly. Mostly, I have a limited tolerance for the exhaustingly popular “enemies-to-lovers” trope. It can work (see “The Jasad Heir”), but it takes incredible restraint and dedicated character-building to properly pull it off, in my opinion. Something that you rarely see. Usually, the characters are called “enemies” because they have a minor disagreement or have been put on opposing sides of an incredibly simplistic conflict only to immediately fall head over heels for the first person they’ve talked to from the opposition. Instead, I’m coming to understand that I strongly prefer “second chance” or “friends to lovers” love stories. Alas, we see so few of these in the fantasy/romantasy genres. But, all of this long preamble aside, I present you with pretty much the perfect version of the “friends to lovers” trope all wrapped up in an excellent fantasy novel to boot!

Before I start raving about the romance, let’s talk a bit about other aspects of the book. While this is a character-driven story, the world-building and magic system we get were incredibly interesting. I’ve read other fantasy books that include a magic system somewhat similar to this, where it essentially takes two people to channel and direct magic. But this one was fairly unique in the dynamics this created between Well and Mage. What’s more interesting, the rather straight-forward dynamics that are set up in the beginning are challenged throughout the book. By the end, we see much of this flipped, particularly with Grey and her abilities as a Well.

I also really enjoyed piecing together the history of this world. The author just throws the reader into the middle of the action and the political strife. Only slowly does information come out about what exactly happened in the past and how things ended up where they did. Not only do these revelations explore the political past between nations, but we slowly learn more about Grey’s own previous life.

The plot was also fairly action-packed, especially, again, considering how much of this is a character-focused story. I closed the book feeling like I had really spent a lot of time with Grey, understood her fully and had read an excellent book about her coming into her own. But when I stopped to actually go over it all, I discovered numerous actions scenes peppered throughout, many throwing massive swerve balls into the plot and changing the entire direction of the story. The action ranges from one-on-one conflict all the way up to massive scenes of warfare.

But man, the characters and the love story, this is where it truly shines! This book should be held up as an example to all authors looking to write stories with mutual pining at the heart. And it’s not like you have to wait long to get to the good stuff (and by “good stuff” I don’t mean the spicy scenes; I mean, good ole longing and affection). Almost from the very start, it’s completely obvious that Kier and Grey are head-over-heels for one another and each are too oblivious to say anything about it. But instead of being annoying, this just leads to the reader getting to linger in all of the sweetness that is constantly touched on between them. Every little scene, we see constant affection from Kier towards Grey. And Grey, silly that she is, writes it all off. Now, this could have been tiresome, but instead I felt like I was in on the joke most of the time and was able to shake my head at her all while enjoying what we got in the meantime. Further, the author knew when to give up the ghost and allow the romance to actually move forward.

But what made this romance so successful was the fact that the progression didn’t end the moment confessions happened between them. Instead, through their romance, the story spends a lot of time exploring themes of sacrifice and what that means for those we love. This was particularly interesting as self-sacrifice in the name of love is something we see all the time in romance plot lines, but it’s rarely discussed in any meaningful way. Here, the story takes the time to dive into the nuances of sacrifice, specifically the way it can add an unhealthy dynamic to relationship development.

So, probably not a surprise by this point, but I absolutely loved this book. Grey was a fantastic, complex main character. Kier was pretty much the perfect romantic hero for a friends-to-lovers romance. And the fantasy aspects surprised and impressed at every turn. If you enjoy romantasy but are looking for something unique from the million-and-one generic enemies-to-lovers books coming out right now, definitely give this one a go! I’d also say that this is a great pick for general fantasy fans who enjoy romantic subplots, as I think there’s a strong enough fantasy adventure at its heart beyond the love story.

Rating 10: A perfect rebuttal to the idea that “enemies to lovers” is the peak romance trope. This, this is what I’ve been looking for in romantasy fiction!

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Second Death of Locke” can be found on this Goodreads list: Year of the Lady Knight 2025

Kate’s Review: “LOONEY!”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “LOONEY!” by Stephen Kozeniewski & Gavin Dillinger

Publishing Info: French Press Publishing, April 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ebook from the publisher

Where You Can Get This Book: Amazon

Book Description: When beloved cartoon characters come crawling out of her TV, army recruiter Gabriella Harman expects a zany romp instead of the hellish nightmare that follows.

One night, haunted by her memories of Iraq, Gabriella downs a stomachful of pills and booze. When her favorite cartoon characters, the Kooky Toons, start crawling out of the TV, she assumes she is hallucinating.

But soon Gabriella finds herself locked in a battle of wits and wills with Herman Hyrax, the world-famous, wise-cracking mascot of the Kooky Korporation. Herman is more than just a stinker, though. He may be a monster, a demon, a god, or something entirely more unwholesome.

Is Gabriella’s descent into a world of cartoonish violence and psychological torment real? Or has she simply gone…

LOONEY!?

Review: Thank you to French Press Publishing for sending me a copy of this book!

When I was a kid I loved the movie “Who Framed Roger Rabbit?”. I remember watching it for the first time when I was in early grade school at a friend’s house, and thinking it was very funny (mind you I missed a GOOD majority of the jokes, especially the sexual ones), but also TERRIFYING as Judge Doom melted a toon shoe in a big ol’ barrel of Dip. And then revealed himself as a murderous toon and went fully HAM on Bob Hoskins. It was the first time I had thought about the absurd over the top violence of the old ‘Looney Tunes” cartoons and how in real life that kind of violence would be horrifying. I kept thinking about “Roger Rabbit” while reading “LOONEY!” by Stephen Kozeniewski and Gavin Dillinger, where a beloved Bugs Bunny-esque cartoon icon is revealed to actually be an otherworldly deity that craves violence and chaos, and has used cartoon fame to spread his word, and can only be stopped by a traumatized war veteran.

It’s a little different from a traumatized P.I., but it hits the same (also, this is a safe space, as an elder millennial all grown up I find myself oddly attracted to Eddie Valiant?) (source).

“LOONEY!” is written like a chaotic and tripped up love letter to “Looney Tunes” and old school Disney shorts soaked in a bit of blood and dark fantasy, and it’s so creative it generally works. Our primary antagonist is Herman Hyrax, a violent and maniacal entity that manipulated a cartoonist promising him fame and fortune, but then used his fame to try and create a cult following of fans to implement his bloodthirsty needs. Enter Gabriella, a war veteran with PTSD who finds herself face to face with Herman Hyrax and other characters from the “Kooky Toons” shows, but in real life, sowing discord while other thought to be cartoons try to stop him. As I said, it feels like “Roger Rabbit” if it was far more violent and gory. It’s such a creative idea, and I genuinely love the concept of a Bugs Bunny kind of icon actually being something malevolent and dangerous, hiding behind a charismatic persona of a cartoon character. I will say that some of it dragged on a bit, and there may have been a few too many side characters that were also deities masquerading as cartoons, but in terms of fun and over the top horror moments it hit the mark pretty well.

I also appreciated how the book kind of acknowledges that these old time cartoons, while filled with lots of warm and fuzzy nostalgia, had some pretty problematic elements to them just based on the time frame in which it was taking inspiration from. I remember having old Bugs Bunny cartoons on a VHS tape that my grandmother gave me (it was almost assuredly a bootleg of some sort) that had some WILDLY racist bits in it, which my parents were sure to shut down when they saw just what it was I was watching, and there are similar moments in the lore of Herman Hyrax and his other ‘kooky’ compatriots. And even a reference to WWII propaganda shorts much like the ones so many cartoon companies were making at the time. I felt like the book did a good honest job of capturing the vibes of the cartoons of this era, damaging bits and all (I also really enjoyed having the bits of screenplays from some of the episodes and seeing Herman become more and more unhinged with studio notes written in).

Overall, “LOONEY!” is a creative horror story that I found entertaining. If you like kind of weird and somewhat meta horror, this could be a good fit.

Rating 7: Very creative and like a demonic iteration of “Who Framed Roger Rabbit?”, “LOONEY!” has some wild horror bits and a nostalgia for old time cartoons (while acknowledging the baggage that came with them).

Reader’s Advisory:

“LOONEY!” isn’t on any Goodreads lists yet, but it did make me want to re-watch “Roger Rabbit”.

Highlights: September 2025

School has at last started, though that has also highlighted once again all of the activities and scheduled events that also entails! But at least the weather has been beautiful recently, making State Fair trips a much more pleasant experience than they have been other years! Of course, we still must always make time for new books and here are a few we’re looking forward to this month!

Serena’s Picks

Book: “A Land So Wide” by Erin A. Craig

Publication Date: Sept. 2, 2025

Why I’m Interested: I loved “The Thirteenth Child” when I read it last year! I know that Craig has also written a number of other young adult fantasy novels, though I haven’t gotten around to them yet. That said, I’ve found myself clicking more with adult fantasy recently, so I was thrilled to see she was coming out with her debut adult title this fall! The story follows a young woman who must venture far into a dangerous woods to save the man she loves. One sentence, but pretty much everything I like, right there!

Book: “The Summer War” by Naomi Novik

Publication Date: September 16, 2025

Why I’m Interested: While I’m impatiently waiting for Novik’s next full-length novel, I have been enjoying the other books we’ve gotten from her in the meantime. I really liked the collection of short stories she put out last year, which included a shortened version of “Spinning Silver.” It was really interesting noting the differences between the shorten version and the novel itself. But seeing those big differences, I was curious to see how Novik would handle writing a novella, a book with a length somewhere between short story and novel. There’s room to do more, but still not tons of space, meaning every page and scene must be utilized to its fullest! However, this author has never let me down, so I fully expect to love this one!

Book: “Wild Reverence” by Rebecca Ross

Publication Date: September 2, 2025

Why I’m Interested: Here’s another “must read” author, so it’s really no surprise to find her latest book on this list. That said, while I enjoyed the “Divine Rivals” duology, it wasn’t my favorite of Ross’s books. Yes, she broke out onto the scene with those, but I think a lot of readers are sleeping on her earlier adult fantasy novels, which I loved even more! So this book sounds like a perfect fit for me! Set in the world of “Divine Rivals” (good) but an adult, stand-alone fantasy novel (great!).

Kate’s Pick

Book: “Fiend” by Alma Katsu

Publication Date: September 16

Why I’m Interested: I feel like it’s been awhile since we’ve had an Alma Katsu novel so I am VERY excited to see that she has a new one coming out! And not only that, it sounds like it’s going to be a story that pulls from the real life inspirations of the dreadful Sackler family and a family curse that until now has been working to their advantage. It sounds a bit like Mike Flanagan’s “Fall of the House of Usher”, which has me amped because I loved that mini series. I’m also interested to see what she does with a more modern setting!

Book: “Play Nice” by Rachel Harrison

Publication Date: September 9, 2025

Why I’m Interested: This sounds a bit like influencer gilded secrecy mixed with “The Amityville Horror”, and both of those things REALLY call to me. I have loved all of Rachel Harrison’s books as they do some really cool horror things while also bringing us complicated female protagonists, and now that she’s finally tackling a haunted house (I guess we got a haunted hotel from her before) AND the traumas of a childhood that spends some time there I am just chomping at the bit. This will probably be saved for Horrorpalooza, as it sounds like it will fit in perfectly.

Book: “Road Trip with a Vampire” by Jenna Levine

Publication Date: September 23, 2025

Why I’m Interested: YAY!! Another supernatural romance novel from Jenna Levine!! And not only that, it’s following the witch that she teased in her previous book! I so thoroughly enjoyed the two previous books in the series, and I love the fact that this time we are going to be following a witch named Zelda on a road trip with a new vampire love interest. I enjoy the humor that Levine brings to these rom coms involving blood suckers, and the fact that we now have a witch thrown into the mix makes it all the more tantalizing.

What books are you looking forward to this month? Let us know in the comments!