Book Club Review: “The Unicorn Hunters”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club! This season’s theme is books with specific colored covers where we all drew a color and matched it with a book.

Book: “The Unicorn Hunters” by Katherine Arden

Publishing Info: Del Rey, June 2026

Where Did We Get This Book: ARCs from ALA!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Prompt Color: Yellow

Book Description: Anne of Brittany was a child when France invaded and drove her royal father to his death. Now she is a young woman, sovereign duchess of an occupied realm, and France means to crown their conquest by marrying her to their king. Such an alliance would put her title, her lands, and her body forever in the hands of her enemies.

But Anne refuses to be the last duchess of Brittany.

Her only hope of resisting conquest is another alliance sealed with marriage, so Anne arranges a daring last gambit: a secret betrothal to Charles of France’s greatest rival. But secrets are hard to keep in a world where rival courts spy on each other with diviners.

The forest of Brocéliande was once the haunt of Merlin the Enchanter and the long-lost faerie queen. But magic is long gone from Broceliande, except for the occasional sight of a unicorn and one critical quirk: This ancient forest is completely hostile to divination.

While pretending compliance with France, Anne plans a unicorn hunt in Brocéliande. A bit of pointless pageantry. A diversion so she can wed in secret.

Or so she thinks.

In this rich and epic novel, the author of the acclaimed Winternight trilogy turns the real history of a remarkable woman into an unforgettable tale of mystery, enchantment, and the price of power.

Kate’s Thoughts

So about ten years ago (maybe not quite but almost) “RuPaul’s Drag Race” was having a close to end of season Ball where the queens had to create runway outfits based on the theme “Gayest Ball Ever”. They had to do a rainbow outfit, a Village People based outfit, and a unicorn outfit. The eventual winner of the season, Sasha Velour, based her unicorn look on the unicorn aesthetics of the Unicorn Tapestries, as she said that ‘that is what she thinks of’ when she thinks of unicorns. Which made me guffaw because how on brand for Sasha Velour. This was something I kept thinking about when I read “The Unicorn Hunters” by Katherine Arden, which takes the very real Anne of Brittany and the French conquest and sets it against a more fantasy based backdrop, where unicorns and magic are real as Anne tries to fight a marriage that would put her home in the hands of those who may wish to do her harm in the name of power. It’s a really cool concept, and it worked out well in what it set out to do.

While fantasy still isn’t really my genre (once Anne found herself dealing with the fae in their realm I was a little less invested), I definitely appreciated the way that Arden seamlessly blended fantastical elements (magic, faeries, unicorns) into a very grounded in history Brittany, bringing Anne’s historical story into a tale that has believable magical elements. It never felt too twee or shoe horned in awkwardly, and I found myself enjoying the threads that were being pulled together to create a historical fiction tale with fantasy beats. Anne herself was an enjoyable protagonist, who has to use cunning and wits to try out outmaneuver adversaries while also staying true to what her expectation and place would be within her position. She is clever and cunning but never felt like a stereotypical ‘girl boss’ that wouldn’t ring true for her time and place. Which may sound a LITTLE strange given that this is a book with unicorns and magic, so why NOT girl boss her up a bit, but it worked well for me showing that power doesn’t have to look one way for women. And given that it came up in book club that Anne had a pretty difficult and sad life when all was said and done, I did appreciate how Arden wanted to give a bit of a ‘what if?’ alternate reality for her. I also really enjoyed the writing style, I found that it flowed well and I really could picture what she was conveying.

So while it’s not totally within my genre wheelhouse, I appreciated “The Unicorn Hunters” and how it blended historical fiction and fantasy to create something unique.

Serena’s Thoughts:

I won’t go through my entire thoughts again on this one but will link my review below. Suffice to say, I still loved this book, even reading it a second time in fairly quick succession. If anything, I was even more impressed by the masterful style of writing that Arden utilizes here. It’s so subtle and yet so crucial to truly capturing the feeling of the medieval setting and the characters who would people this time and place. For all of its fantastical elements, I think these smaller flourishes, the court politics, the interactions between the siblings, and the understated courtly love story are what truly provide the backbone of this book. And the very particular, almost stylized prose is really what holds it all together.

I still highly recommend this one to pretty much all fantasy fans, but especially those who enjoy historical fiction as well. And for a more detailed review from me, here is what I posted back in June when I reviewed it originally: “The Unicorn Hunters.”

Kate’s Rating 7: While some of the more blatant fantasy beats didn’t hold my attention, the way that Arden cobbles history with fantasy to create a shared tale was well done.

Serena’s Rating 10: To repeat what I said before: Absolutely brilliant! Arden’s beautiful, lyrical writing captures the deep peace of the unicorn, the terrifying shadows of the dark forest, and the endless well of strength found in one woman who sets out to change her fate.

Book Club Questions

  1. This book is a mixture of fantasy and historical fiction. How well do you think it blends these two genres and their conventions? Was one genre stronger than the other?
  2. For the historical side of things, what did you know about Anne of Brittany before? How did you feel about this interpretation of hre story and her as a woman in history?
  3. The unicorn and the mythology around it plays a central role in the story. Did the author bring any unique twist to her version of the unicorn myth or the themes often explored alongside unicorns?
  4. The book grapples with themes of women and power and the limited choices they faced. We see both Anne and Marguerite approach their limited avenues to power in very different ways. What did you think about what the book did with these themes?
  5. There are fantastical and “real life” threats that Anne faces throughout the story. Did any of these plot points stand as more compelling?
  6. What did you make of teh end of the book and the final resolution?

Reader’s Advisory

“The Unicorn Hunters” is included on these Goodreads lists: Most Anticipated Adult Fantasy & Sci-fi of 2026 (Standalones & New Series) and Unicorn Books.

Next Book Club Pick: “Will My Cat Eat My Eyeballs? And Other Questions about Dead Bodies” by Caitlin Doughty

Serena’s Review: “The Thief and the Traitor Bride”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Thief and the Traitor Bride” by V. L. Bovalino

Publishing Info: Forever, September 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Nore Gordon is a woman of many talents: she can speak a variety of languages, disguise herself in plain sight, and has made a name for herself as a successful wine merchant. But unbeknownst to those closest to her, it is all a front for Nore’s true role as the favoured spy of the Lindle crown.

Tasked with infiltrating enemy lands in search of a powerful relic, Nore is forced to engage the services of a great thief. Unfortunately, the only person for the job is her estranged husband Caspian. Both Nore and Caspian bear the scars of the disastrous end of their marriage, but if they are to survive their deadly new assignment, they must pose as a happily married couple to avoid detection.

As danger closes in, Nore finds herself tangled in a web of lies and deceit-and though Caspian is at the centre of it all, she may not hate him as much as she once did. But Caspian has betrayed her before, and trust can be far more deadly than deception.

Previously Reviewed: “The Second Death of Locke”

Review: This is a tough review to write, because some of my experience of this book is affected by my absolute adoration for the first in this series. I was blown away by “The Second Death of Locke,” and to spoil my own review, the best parts of this book also just happened to feature the main couple from that book. That being the case, while starting to think about what to say about this book, I found it all coming out rather…ranty. Which isn’t fair! Because this is by no means a bad book; in fact, in many ways, it is an incredibly well-written fantasy romance that doesn’t shirk on the challenges of representing a character who is by no means reliable and who has been actively manipulated her entire life. But…it also wasn’t “Locke,” and I guess that’s what I wanted.

So let’s start with the good things, because really, there are many. Even my later criticisms should be taken with a grain of salt, because comparison is the killer of objective reviews. For the good, this author continues to prove that one doesn’t need to dumb down one’s writing when working within the romantasy or fantasy romance genres. This seems like it should go without saying, and yet. The prose was tight, lyrical, and suitably adult for the heavy topics the story was covering.

I will say, however, that the magic system, while very interesting, is still very confusing. I’m not always a big fan of glossaries or additional information included at the end, but a more laid-out explanation that could be referenced would have been helpful here, especially since the author introduced even more to an already complicated system. And, while I appreciated the map in the beginning of the book, it was notably leaving out some very important locations that are pretty central to the story, so I wish that had been expanded upon as well.

Beyond that, I appreciated the careful work the author put into her main character. Nore’s arc is not an easy one to write. She’s a woman who has been manipulated her entire life and is very much gaslit about her role in the world and her relationship with her mentor. This is fairly obvious to the reader right from the start. So it can be frustrating to watch Nore behave in some fairly unlikable ways due to this brainwashing. However, the book wouldn’t have the emotional climax it does or hit nearly as hard had Nore somehow been more aware of her circumstances. Indeed, her naivety is essential to demonstrate the challenges that those in abusive, manipulative relationships like this face, as well as those who hope to extract them from them. The author does a great job of carefully building up Nore’s history through a series of flashbacks that neatly illustrate how she’s come to where she is. From there, the book moves through her slow awakening to the reality around her.

But, like I said, this doesn’t make her a particularly fun character to read about. For a character who is meant to be a master spy, I wish we had seen more competence from her in the few moments that she is given to operate independently (though this restriction is also part of the manipulation, so I’m not sure how well it would work). So it’s easy enough to set aside some of the frustrations with her naivety in this area.

However, the romance was incredibly frustrating. I enjoy second-chance romances, but they are hard to write. And here we had a good example of where it can go wrong. The story plays out skipping between the present, where Nore and Caspien have been forced to work together after years apart following some terrible betrayal in the past that has left them both hating one another. This hatred seems to go both ways, though we see more from Nore, of course, as we’re reading the story from her perspective. Interspersed with this are flashbacks to their past in which they fall in love and eventually marry. So, we don’t get to the actual betrayal until nearly the 50% marker in the book. This leaves a lot of time to really build up this betrayal as fairly massive. And when we get to it…man, it really fell with a thump. Both characters, but mostly Nore, react so instantaneously and so poorly that I was immediately frustrated and annoyed. For characters who have been in love for years and happily married for a good chunk of that, the switch to immediate hatred with no room for explanations just read as ridiculous at best, and unlikable at worst. Nore, in particular, comes across as incredibly hypocritical in this scenario.

Now, once the romance starts building back up in the present timeline, I did enjoy these two together. Nore was at her best in the scenes with Caspien. And while he wasn’t my favorite love interest ever, I was fully on board with Caspien pretty much from the start. Between this book and the first (where the emotional stakes at least were much more known by both characters, even if they didn’t admit them to each other), I think it’s fair to say that this author has an incredible way with writing romances between two characters who are in love already to some extent. This is a pretty rare talent, as there’s often a reason that romance authors just end the book once the characters have acknowledged their feelings, usually at the very end of the story. However, I don’t think the enemies-to-lovers bit worked as well here, unfortunately.

We do get to see more of Locke and Kier and man, I was so happy when they showed up. Unfortunately, Locke’s presence did expose more of my frustrations with Nore, as even the small bits we get from Locke were so much more compelling than much of Nore had been for much of the story. Kier was also wonderful, and the little snippets of their love story were so sweet.

On a final note, I think the pacing of this one was also a bit off. The first book was also on the slower side, but this one really dragged in the middle. Part of this was the frustration in having to wait so long for the reveal of what went wrong in the past (and then the disappointment when it came). But there were also a lot of slower travel scenes and bits that felt drawn out past their usefulness. I think a decent amount of paring down in this middle section would have made the entire book a tighter, more enjoyable read.

That said, this was still incredibly well written, and, while frustrating at times, I appreciated the unique arc that Nore traveled. The romance was at its best in the second half of the story, and I was happy to get to spend more time with Locke and Kier. While this didn’t quite live up to the high that was the first book, I still enjoyed it and am excited to see what comes next!

Rating 8: While this didn’t quite live up to the high that was “The Second Death of Locke,” this was still an incredibly well-written fantasy romance with a lovely second-chance romance at its heart (though you do have to wait a bit for it!)

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Thief and the Traitor Bride” can be found on this Goodreads list: Gothic Fantasy (not sure I would put it here, but oh well!)

Kate’s Review: “The Hanged Man”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Hanged Man” by Jane Brookwood

Publishing Info: Brookwood Publishing, July 2026

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ePub from the publicist

Where You Can Get This Book: Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: Gilmore Girls meets Ghost Whisperer in this cozy metaphysical mystery.

Fiona Miller runs a metaphysical gift shop in Pineridge Hollow. She reads tarot, sells crystals, mixes tea and generally minds her own business. Until she can’t.

When the son of her long-lost best friend Maggie turns up dead, Fiona has decided she’s getting to the bottom of it before she’s even aware of the decision. What stops her cold is the timing — moments before the call, she pulls The Hanged Man tarot card on the heels of a monster zoomie rampage by her cat and familiar Rosie.

Maggie’s son, found hanging in an eerie echo of the boy on the card. Accident? Suicide? Murder? The town has already decided. Fiona’s tarot deck isn’t so sure.

In her little corner of nowhere, with only her tarot to guide her through the stickier situations, Fiona is making her way blindly with little or no technology to guide her. The cat though…

Rosie brings some much-needed intuitive skills along with the Chief, who brings something else. With her Pineridge Hollow crew and Rosie at her side, Fiona follows the cards into buried grudges, old money, and secrets the town spent decades hiding.

On top of everything, The Hanged Man keeps making himself known. Flip it on its head, he whispers. Look…really look, and then, be prepared to wait. You just might be surprised…

Review: Thank you to Books Forward for sending me an ePub of this novel!

I love that we are in the Ber months, finally. For those who don’t know, the “Ber” Months are the last four months of the year, September, October, November, and December. It’s my favorite time of year, as we transition from Summer to Autumn and then ease into Winter, and when September hits I start to shift into two distinct moods: spooky, because of course, and cozy, because Autumn is SO cozy to me. And when I started reading “The Hanged Man” by Jane Brookwood, the start to a new cozy mystery series that has TAROT and ESOTERIC STUFF and QUIRKY CHARACTERS and a CAT, I felt it was the perfect transition read into my favorite time of year. And as someone who likes to collect tarot decks, it was all the more of a hook to me. I’m a huge sucker for this stuff.

The vibes in this are very much aligned with my own personal interests. Not only do we have Fiona who owns her own metaphysical shop filled with tarot, tea, and other esoteric goodies, we also have a story that is just brimming with the kind of cozy energy that just feels like it wraps the reader up with a blanket. The small town is filled with quirky characters, Fiona is likable and relatable, she has an ADORABLE cat, and I loved the tarot themes. It hits all of the best things about a cozy mystery to me, with an interesting hook and a charming setting with enjoyable characters. And my GOSH I really want to go to The Raven to get my cards read, or just to chill out with some tea, a book, and Rosie the cat. One of the greatest traits I look for in a cozy mystery is the vibes, and this one definitely has them.

The mystery itself is pretty good too. I feel like we kind of got thrown into the deep end with Fiona and her community of Pineridge Hollow and their backstories, but I caught up pretty well and by the time the mystery of what happened to Henry Jr, the son of her deceased friend Maggie, who perhaps killed himself by hanging (hence the Hanged Man card that keeps popping up), but perhaps had some enemies in town who would have wanted him dead. Fiona is the kind of amateur detective that I enjoy, intrepid and loyal and perhaps a LITTLE impetuous, but who is likable and easy to root for as well. As she gathers clues and butts heads with local authorities a bit we get some good build up, a nice cast of suspects, and the ever present tarot predictions helping drive the investigation. I kind of figured it out pretty early, but the journey was enjoyable and it didn’t really matter that I called the ending.

“The Hanged Man” is a promising start to a new cozy mystery series that will be perfect Fall reading. Get out your tarot deck, a cup of tea, and a blanket, and then just settle in.

Rating 7: A cozy mystery with a unique premise and the exact right vibes for the upcoming Autumn season!

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Hanged Man” is included on the Goodreads list “Halloween and Autumn Cozy Mysteries”.

Serena’s Review: “A Snake Among Swans”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Snake Among Swans” by Hannah Kaner

Publishing Info: Harper Voyager, September 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Tilde has always heard the whispers of the kithwood, the voices of her ancestors speaking through the mysterious forest of her homeland. But now both the kithwood and her kingdom are in danger.

For Tilde is the only surviving heir of a conquered land. To unite the people and finally stop the bloodshed, she marries the aging warlord, King Liran. Her duty is to bind their nations and bear him a son.

But the swan king’s court is dangerous. Tilde is a threat to the claim of Liran’s older sons, who will do whatever it takes to remove her, to the princess Elise who has only ever known loyalty to her family, and to the priests who own them all.

Yet none of them know that Tilde is a snake in their midst, with allies on her side and dark, forbidden power of her own. She wants her kingdom back, and she will sacrifice everything to claim it.

For the queen to rise, the swans must fall.

Review: Overall, I enjoyed this read. I had a bit of an up-and-down experience with her previous trilogy, so while some of those struggles showed up again here, this book also served as a strong reminder of why I’ve enjoyed this author so much in the past.

In many ways, this is a very familiar high fantasy tale. The world-building isn’t incredibly unique, and the character archetypes are familiar. Many of the themes are also what you’d expect from this sort of novel: feminine rage and the weights of duty and power in the face of desire. All of this can sound like negatives when listed out like this, but I think it’s books like this that also remind us why we’ve seen these stories before, and that’s because they can be truly excellent if done well!

Kaner’s lyrical, poignant style of writing elevates familiar themes and raises them to levels that feel powerful and lasting. This was especially true of Tilde, a character who knew what she wanted and was willing to make difficult decisions to accomplish her goals. While her story unfolds, there were several lines that I stopped to reread, as they so perfectly encapsulated the struggles of women in these sorts of medieval worlds that are loosely based on European history. Kaner perfectly hones in on just how infuriating this situation is: the lack of power and choice, the relegating of one’s personhood down to only the ability to produce an heir. It’s enraging. But the ability of the author to draw out such strong feelings is a testament to her skill.

I will say that pacing was a problem in some of the other books I read by this author, and I had similar struggles here. I was immediately drawn into the story, but somewhere around the middle, things really began to lag. It was at this point that I started becoming tempted to skim a bit. Luckily, as the story got into the back third, things began to pick up again, and I was roped back into the story.

It’s hard to say this was an enjoyable read when so many of the emotions are focused on rage and injustice. Perhaps a better description would be saying it was a powerful read. The pacing and plotting weren’t perfect, but I was able to get through the lull to the conclusion. I’m definitely curious to see where the story goes from here, and I would recommend this to readers looking for a classic medieval fantasy with a sapphic love story at its heart.

Rating 8: Powerful themes of feminine rage permeate this read. But there’s also a lovely sapphic romance to get you through some of the parts that will infuriate you!

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Snake Among Swans” can be found on this Goodreads list: Reactor’s 30 More SFF Titles to Look Forward to in 2026.

Kate’s Review: “Kiss Slay Replay”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Kiss Slay Replay” by Rachel Harrison

Publishing Info: Berkley, September 2026

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publisher at ALAAC2026

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: Every wedding guest’s worst nightmare is on repeat in this wild and twisty new horror novel from the New York Times bestselling author of So Thirsty and Play Nice.

It’s the picture-perfect wedding The venue is dreamy, the weather is beautiful, love is in the air—and Willa Sullivan is having a bad time. She’s excited to celebrate her best friends finally having the big wedding they’ve always wanted, but this is the first time she’s seen her ex-fiancé in months, and he brought a date. Everything feels off, like she stumbled into an alternate universe. But things start to look up when Willa meets Danny, the groom’s charming and single childhood best friend. When they sneak off together, their rendezvous is interrupted by a masked killer terrorizing the reception. Willa and Danny fight to save the ones they love and survive the night, but the killer is unrelenting. A final girl, Willa is not.

Or is she? She wakes up and it’s the morning of the wedding. She just had the most intense nightmare of her life. Only as the day unfolds, there are some uncanny coincidences that make her question whether it was really a dream, déjà vu, or something more sinister. After a horrifying turn of events, Willa comes to understand that she’s stuck in a loop of carnage and terror that she must learn how to escape or else suffer a fate worse than death—being an eternal wedding guest.

Review: Thank you to Berkley for giving me an ARC of this novel at ALAAC26!

I am usually not super anxious when I go to ALA every year and I am on the hunt for ARCs. For one, Serena and I have basically perfected the ARC hunt strategy, figuring out where the publisher’s booths are ahead of time, getting there early to get in line for the exhibits hall, and knowing that in all likelihood we will get the books that we want. I had Rachel Harrison’s newest horror novel “Kiss Slay Replay” on my ‘seek out’ list, and on one of the mornings at opening I determinedly but politely and NOT obnoxiously made my way towards the publisher tables in hopes I’d see it. And lo and behold it was there!…. And people were SWARMING for it. I was lucky enough to get a copy, because my inherent need to not be a dick about ARCs meant I was one of the last people to get one before they were gone. It’s admittedly great seeing horror get such an enthusiastic response. And I was very excited to see what Harrison was going to do with it.

And it definitely lived up to what I was expecting, and kind of went a few steps further. The premise is definitely one we’ve seen before, at the very least in films like “Happy Death Day” and “Groundhog Day”, but Harrison takes it a step further and makes it even more fun by altering the threats of the time loop wedding massacre for each time Willa has to go through it. It could be a masked murderer at one loop, but then it could be zombies at another loop, with each scenario being campy and out there but still being grotesque and very horror centric, even with the humor and outlandishness. And while I don’t really like the film “Cabin in the Woods”, I kept thinking about it as I read this and it was in a positive way. Harrison has her tongue planted firmly in cheek in this story and while it sometimes had me squirming, it was a true hoot and felt like a fun horror movie that kept me interested. So much so I read it in one afternoon!

But there is also an undercurrent of pathos and melancholy in this book as we follow Willa during a particularly hard moment in her life. She is still reeling from a recent breakup of a long term relationship/engagement, and is now going to the wedding of a friend in their circle, and having to face her friends for the first time in a group setting after years apart after this huge change. It fits for a time loop story, as Willa is not only literally trapped in a loop that won’t go forward on her friend’s wedding day, but even before this she feels stagnant and lost, unable to move forward after her monumental break up and wallowing a bit in the aftermath. Much like the aforementioned film “Happy Death Day”, Willa is stuck in grief which has altered her life and relationships, and perhaps to actually be able to move forward literally she will need to start to move forward emotionally. It’s well worn territory, but Harrison makes it feel fresh and it is effective and bittersweet seeing her have to process all of this. I really enjoyed that aspect, and it was very on brand for Harrison’s horror stories that have some pretty relatable womens experiences at their heart.

“Kiss Slay Replay” is another fun and lighter (not light, but lighter) horror story from Rachel Harrison! If you like time loop stories, check this one out!

Rating 8: A fun and heartfelt Sci-Fi horror tale that feels like “Happy Death Day”, “Groundhog Day”, and “Cabin in the Woods” all rolled into one, with some melancholy undercurrents. Quite enjoyable!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Kiss Slay Replay” is included on the Goodreads list “Time Loops”.

Highlights: September 2026

Do you feel that in the air? The slight change of temperature and the way that the sun is starting to set earlier? Yep, Fall has begun. Well, at least theoretically, as it’s still a bit warm here in Minnesota. But school has started for our kids, Serena is planning a trip abroad, and Kate’s favorite season is on our doorstep. We also have a list of books we are looking forward to this month!

Serena’s Picks


Book: “The Thief and the Traitor Bride” by V. L. Bovalino

Publication Date: September 26, 2026

Why I’m Interested: I absolutely loved the first book in this series of stand alone romantic fantasies. “The Second Death of Locked” blew me away not only with its unique magic system and complicated political world building, but also with the lovely slow burn romance that leaned hard into all the yearning. So this has been down as a must read for quite some time. I’m definitely excited, but I will say that while I love second chance romance when done right, it’s also one of the harder romantic tropes to pull off well. Too often these love stories rely on miscommunication or some other nonsense to justify the original break. But as the first book was done so well, I have high hopes that the author can pull it off again here! If anything, I’m holding out hope for a few more glimpses of Locke and Keir here in this second book!

Book: “The Wretched Divine” by Adalyn Grace

Publication Date: September 26, 2026

Why I’m Interested: I had a bit of a messy break up with Grace’s last YA trilogy. I absolutely loved “Belladonna,” but from there the series took a steady nose dive culminating in what felt like a bit of a dumpster fire with the last book (especially because that third book started with such great potential!). But hope lives eternal, and I know that this author can definitely procure books that hit just right for me. This one does have a steep hill to climb as it is clearly telegraphing some of love triangle right from the start, but hey, that was one of the main perks of “Belladonna,” that the author had managed to write a love triangle that I didn’t hate! On the other hand, this triangle consists of what sounds like a blonde angel and a dark-haired demon. Hmm, wonder which one she’ll end up with?? But like I said, maybe she’ll surprise me! This is also a switch to an adult romantasy series, so I’m excited to see how Grace adjust her storytelling for an older audience. Definitely both nervous and excited for this one!

Book: “Scion” by James Islington

Publication Date: September 1, 2026

Why I’m Interested: I missed the initial hype train for this author. While I fully intended to get to “The Will of the Many” one of these days, I’m definitely behind the curve here. That being the case, I was excited to see that the author was releasing a new sci-fi/cyberpunk novel this month. What’s more, it’s a bit on the shorter side, so a great entry point to get a taste of what this author has in store! Based on the book description, this definitely has “Murderbot” vibes with the story following a quick witted, rather snarky body guard as he trails around behind expensive clientele. It’s looks like one of those cases where the style and tone of the writing will really be the make or break factor for reader enjoyment. However, I’ve really been living “Murderbot,” so if this manages to capture the same magic, sign me up!

Kate’s Picks

Book: “Something Followed Us Home: Tales of Latiné Horror” by Cynthia Pelayo (Ed.)

Publication Date: September 29, 2026

Why I’m Interested: This one has been on my list pretty much all year, and I was not only lucky enough to get a copy at ALAAC26, I also got to meet Cynthia Pelayo and tell her how excited I was to read it. This new horror collection showcases horror short stories by various authors from the Latiné diaspora, with many authors from all kinds of backgrounds and perspectives being centered. Some I’m familar with, others I’m not, and I’m very excited to take this one on!

Book: “Kiss, Slay, Replay” by Rachel Harrison

Publication Date: September 1, 2026

Why I’m Interested: Rachel Harrison is still a favorite horror author of mine, and one I love to recommend to people who want something spooky, but perhaps not super scary. And her newest book “Kiss, Slay, Replay” sounds like it’s a wedding based time travel tale that has vibes of “Happy Death Day” and “Groundhog Day”. Willa is excited to be involved in her best friend’s wedding. But the night of the ceremony, a killer wreaks havoc, Willa being one of the victims… But then she wakes up after being killed, and finds it is once again the morning of the wedding. This keeps happening, and Willa needs to figure out how to get out of the loop. It sounds like a lot of fun.

Book: “Mazywood” by Tananarive Due

Publication Date: September 22, 2026

Why I’m Interested: After loving “The Reformatory” and diving back into some older titles (and enjoying them as well), Tananarive Due’s newest book “Mazywood” is a top priority for me this month. A man goes to his family cabin in the California wilds, hoping to get material for a documentary about his grandmother, a famous Black actress in mid 20th Century Hollywood. But as he stays there, he encounters not only her anger and backstory (also told through flashbacks to her time), but also something lurking in the woods. Hollywood, racism, monsters, and a mystery, super compelling and I can’t wait to pick it up.

Serena’s Review: “Daughter of the Dark”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Daughter of the Dark” by R.J. Vallderperas

Publishing Info: Bramble, September 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: For Solana, survival has always meant staying sharp—and staying alone. With a blood-forged dagger as her only inheritance, she’s made herself Supay’s fiercest demon slayer, hunting muki—monsters born from human death—through the kingdom’s streets.

But the work comes with a curse of its every body she leaves behind swells the muki’s ranks. The city that raised her has been her cage for so long she’s stopped believing freedom is real.

Then a twist of fate drags her into the palace and crowns her Royal Demon Slayer, a title wrapped in silk and sharpened like a blade. The magic is dazzling. The secrets are darker. And whatever is poisoning Supay didn’t start in the alleys. It started behind gilded doors.

Worst of all is Reyes, the king’s right-hand man, a captain of the Masters, and her personal torturer turned mentor who’s dangerously hard to resist. Wanting him is a mistake. Trusting him could be fatal. Because if Solana walks away, the kingdom falls. And if she stays, she may have to become the monster Supay needs.

Review: I don’t typically look at other reviews before writing up my own so as to preserve a more uninfluenced opinion, but this book had me stumped for a bit. There was something about it that was both familiar and not particularly to my taste, and when I went to the reviews, someone had the perfect comparison: this book’s heroine is almost an exact replica of Celaena from “Throne of Glass!” And suddenly my feelings were clear. I wasn’t loving this, but some part of me was also recognizing that I was likely going to be the outlier. After all, “Throne of Glass” is incredibly popular, and I’m definitely an outlier for my dislike of it and of Celaena.

So yes, our main character was one of my main struggles with this book. She’s your typical badass assassin with oh, so many secrets. But, of course, we don’t really see much of this and instead are repeatedly simply told that she’s the best at what she does. Similarly, the love interest feels like some jumble of all the love interests from the “Throne of Glass” series combined. He wasn’t terrible or anything on his own, but he was also so familiar as a type that I was immediately bored by him.

I think that was my main problem with this book. It’s competently written, the characters are all the sort that often appeal to romantasy fans, and the pacing was fast-moving. And I’m sure there are a bunch of readers out there who will gobble this one up. But I’m getting so tired of reading the same characters and love interests time after time. And the style of writing that is popular now, which relies heavily on simply telling readers traits about the main characters, is so dull that I’m getting to the point where it’s a struggle to finish books where this pops up in the first few chapters. Which I hate. Because there have definitely been examples of books that didn’t immediately enthrall me, but then, after a few chapters, successfully drew me in.

I will say that I think the world-building here was its strongest aspect. The exploration of the underworld and the demon-like creatures was fascinating. I also really liked the overall Peruvian culture that carried through in some of the descriptions of food and architecture. That said, I could have used even more of this. I especially thought that the magic system was a bit underdeveloped and didn’t take full advantage of its interesting origins.

Overall, this was a bit of a disappointment. The cover is fantastic, and I know there are a lot of readers who will enjoy this. If you like “Throne of Glass,” for example, and that heroine in particular, this will definitely be up your alley! So subjectively, as I didn’t like that book or its lead, this wasn’t my favorite and would probably be a “6” for me personally. But I’m bumping it up a notch since that’s such a “me thing” problem.

Rating 7: The Peruvian influences were the most interesting part. And from there, it may come down to how much you’d like to re-read “Throne of Glass.” Which…not so much for me.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Daughter of the Dark” can be found on this Goodreads list: Can’t Wait Sci-Fi/Fantasy of 2026.

Kate’s Review: “A Beginner’s Guide to Leveling Up”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Beginner’s Guide to Leveling Up” by Elizabeth Agyemang

Publishing Info: G.P. Putnam’s Sons Books for Young Readers, September 2026

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from the author

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: TRON meets sixth grade in this heartfelt and fantastical graphic novel where a pixelated quest helps one girl navigate grief, friendship, and the wilds of middle school.

Sixth grade. The game just got real. For Lexie, this year was supposed to be all about joining clubs, claiming the perfect lunch spot, and gaming after school with her best friends. But shifting friendships and the grief of losing her beloved grandfather make middle school feel more like someone switched her life to hard mode.

Then Lexie discovers a mysterious journal tucked inside her grandfather’s things. It’s filled with cryptic notes and cheat codes from an unfinished video game he was Warrior’s Quest. When Lexie and her older sister, Eunice, are suddenly transported into the game’s pixelated world, the line between reality and fantasy starts to blur. Can Lexie and her sister level up and face the monsters in the game—and in real life—or is it game over for good?

Review: Thank you to Elizabeth Agyemang for sending me an eARC of this graphic novel!

I have lots of fond memories of playing computer games with my sister and/or the neighbor kids after school when I was a kid. We would play games like “Oregon Trail”, “Are You Afraid of the Dark: Orpheo’s Curse”, “The Lost Mind of Dr. Brain”, and more that I can’t remember the names of. When Elizabeth Agyemang reached out to me with “The Beginner’s Guide to Leveling Up” these memories definitely bubbled up, and when I read that the premise was not only kids being sucked into a video game and having to find their way out, but also kids dealing with real life anxieties, I was on board to give it a try.

Taking into account the target audience I found “A Beginner’s Guide to Leveling Up” to be a fun fantasy/Sci-Fi tale with a good premise of kids being sucked into a video game and having to find their way out. Our main character is Lexie, who is dealing with starting sixth grade and the stresses that come with that as well as the recent death of her grandfather, a video game designer that she misses very much, and how she and some friends become part of a mysterious game they find in his belongings. The description makes reference to “Tron” and it definitely fits, and made me think a bit about “Jumanji” as well. I enjoyed seeing Lexie and her friends have to solve the game mechanics and how it makes literal villains out of the mean girls that Lexie and her friend Mika have been dealing with while also making an escapist game seem like a way to get away from the real world problems she’s been going through (more on that in a bit). The game itself felt pretty realistic, and this elder Millennial was hit with a full on nostalgia bomb of playing CD ROM games with friends.

The strongest aspect of this book, however, was how Agyemang tackles real life issues that may be relevant to the intended audience, aka middle grade kids who are experiencing life changes as they get older. Whether it is the grief that Lexie and Eunice are experiencing in the aftermath of their grandfather’s death (and their opposite ways of dealing with said grief), or the growing pains of entering a new school environment and how that can cause issues between friends, or the difficulties of dealing with other kids who aren’t so great, or racism, and so forth, we have a story about a girl who is going through a LOT and is having a hard time dealing. It’s presented in an empathetic way without being overly melodramatic, and I definitely think that some of the things Lexie is going through would be relatable to middle grade readers. Lexie herself is an enjoyable protagonist who misses her grandfather so much, and her grief and awkwardness about her new school life are realistic to be sure.

“A Beginner’s Guide to Leveling Up” is a cute graphic novel that will be fun for kids who may be navigating some tougher issues and who happen to enjoy a nice video game!

Rating 8: A cute middle grade tale about school growing pains, grief, and teamwork in life and video games.

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Beginner’s Guide to Leveling Up” is included on the Goodreads list “Middle Grade Graphic Novels of 2026”.

Serena’s Review: “Reign”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Reign” by Bethan Croome

Publishing Info: Cosmo Reads, September 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: The Kingdom of Lyonesse is absent of magic but not of rain.

In the rain-soaked Kingdom of Lyonesse, magic is outlawed―punishable by death. So when Niamh’s forbidden witchcraft is exposed, she flees her rainy village disguised as a man. She never meant to end up on a battlefield.

Mistakenly conscripted into a brutal war engineered by a paranoid king against a vengeful sorceress determined to reclaim the throne, Niamh now hides another secret―her womanhood. Between fighting terrifying beasts and confronting arcane powers she once believed were merely folklore, Niamh is thrust into a world where survival relies on more than luck―it demands alliances.

In battle, Niamh must obey Prince Fitzroy, the king’s infuriatingly handsome illegitimate son and sharp-tongued commander tasked with eradicating magic. He is everything she despises…and everything she struggles to resist. Back at camp, she forges a complicated friendship with Bash, a fellow soldier who sees her like no one else does and stirs forbidden feelings that could shatter her disguise.

As war tightens its grip on the kingdom, Niamh is forced to choose: obey the prince who could expose her, trust the soldier who could love her, or embrace the forbidden magic that could save them all.

But war is merciless, and not everyone will live to see which side prevails.

Review: I’ve seen a lot of reviewers mentioning Mulan when referencing this book. And while I get it, that’s one of the most well-known examples of a “woman dressing as a man” story we really have, it’s also a very specific tale, and mentioning it every time a book features a female character dressing as a man just messes with people’s expectations. We might as well reference the “Alanna” series by Tamora Pierce or, heck, Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night” while we’re at it! Anyways, I’ll get off this weird soapbox and get on with the review.

By the time I finished this book, my primary feeling was that I really wished I had liked it more than I did. There were some good ideas here, and I’ll be honest that some of my struggles came down to my own preferences (we all know my feelings on love triangles by this point). But the book also struggled in too many basic ways to truly be thought of as a successful read or one that I would recommend generally to other fantasy readers.

For one thing, the writing itself was a tough read. It felt wooden and lacked any sense of a unique tone or voice. The structure felt very rigid, and the entire affair left me feeling cold and unable to connect to anything that was happening on the page. In the most basic sense, there was way too much telling throughout the entire book and not enough showing. From character development, to plotting, to world-building: it all felt like a slow progression of checklists just being tacked one upon the other.

The characterization was equally bland. This wasn’t helped by the fact that the dialogue was incredibly choppy-feeling and didn’t read in a way that felt like believable interaction. And while I could appreciate some of the basic components of these characters, they also quickly began to feel overly familiar, without much new to be added or experienced while following their stories. And, of course, this didn’t help the romance. Setting aside the multiple love interests thing, which is very much just a “me issue,” I also simply didn’t buy any of these relationships. It never felt like any true connection was built between these characters. Instead, like everything else, the reader was simply informed that a connection was there.

Overall, this was a very lackluster read. I really enjoy fantasy stories that follow a woman dressing up as a man, as I think this can explore some really interesting concepts of misogyny and the different dynamics between the sexes. But this one didn’t really do anything with all of this. Instead, the wooden and choppy writing took me out of it almost immediately, and the flat characterization prevented me from ever connecting to the story. Readers who enjoy romances with multiple love interests and who want to experience another “woman undercover as a man” story may still want to check it out, however!

Rating 6: I wanted to like this one, but everything fell just a bit short, from the characterization, to the choppy dialogue, to the flat prose.

“Reign” can be found on this Goodreads list: 2026 Most Anticipated Romantasy & Fantasy Romance Releases

Kate’s Review: “The Calamities”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Calamities” by Chuck Wendig

Publishing Info: Del Rey, August 2026

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from NetGalley

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: The heir to one of the world’s most influential families reckons with the demonic secret to their power, in this contemporary dark fantasy that melds occult magic with shocking family drama from the New York Times bestselling author of The Book of Accidents.

Mourning Mayne knows he’ll one day bear the duty of managing his family’s vast empire of wealth and power. But the feckless Mourning has always struggled to accept this legacy, which is one of cruelty, domination, and exploitation… and something even darker.

Because the Maynes are no ordinary family: Hidden in our world are the fiends—half-human, half-demon, and possessed of dark magic born from buying human souls—and the Maynes are one of the oldest and most influential fiendish families.

But when Mourning’s estranged father, the formidable and terrifying Hadrian Mayne, demands that he return to the fold, Mourning has to make a decision whether to accept his legacy and embrace his role in the family, or to forge his own destiny, and with it, change the course of the world.

Because along the way home, he will meet Key, a black-market seller of human souls, and Quinn, an artist who may hold the dark truth behind the fate of the fiends. Alone, they have all struggled with the darkness of their fiendish nature… but together, they might find a path out of the shadows.

Review: Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eARC of this book!

It’s been a few years since “Succession” ended, and while I don’t particularly MISS it (it was good but it ended well and man they were all just horrible), I was still immediately thinking of it when I read about Chuck Wendig’s new novel “The Calamities”. We all know that I like Wendig as a horror author, and the idea of him writing a book about an uber wealthy and uber powerful family that just so happens to have demon blood and soul snatching powers just tickled me. “Succession” meets cosmic and demon horror? Hell yes! The Roy Family is basically filled with demons anyway, why not do a story that just leans all the way into that?

Only a man who feeds on human souls and misery could come up with boar on the floor as far as I’m concerned. (source)

Off the bat I will admit that the theme of ‘billionaires and billionaire families are soul sucking demons’ is a bit on the nose, but that doesn’t make it any less resonant. Especially these days. And Wendig is always so thorough and deliberate with his world building that even if the theme is obvious, he makes it feel fresh and brings in so much originality, probably because he has built an entire mythos around the idea of ‘Fiend’ families (aka people who have demon blood in them and who take human souls for feeding) gathering wealth, power, and souls for their own devices, hoarding and exploiting power with no care for the consequences. With different families having rivalries and motives to hold on to souls to consume, we have a lot of well done motivations and a tellar history and world of people with demon blood and soul snatching powers. The horror in this book is less ‘demonic’ and definitely more in the realm of body and cosmic horror, with some really nasty moments that had me squirming, while also building up the suspense in a way that kept me reading. Wendig is such a reliable horror writer and while this one did feel a little bit meandering at times, I was generally locked in.

And unsurprisingly so, the characters in this one are a feast, with morally grey ones, traumatized ones, funny ones, and incredibly creepy ones. Wendig has the gross entitlement and cruelty of a wealthy family a la the Sacklers or Du Ponts, but also brings out interesting complex characters who are sometimes infuriating but at other times wholly sympathetic. We also get an interesting examination of the way narcissistic parents can favor some kids while scapegoating others, and how they can pit their children against each other. This dynamic is especially prevalent in the Maynes Family, with our protagonist Mourning being a black sheep to his cruel and megalomaniacal father Hadrian while his twin siblings Lachlan and Lorelei are highly favored and keep him under their boots because of this advantage (this whole family was very Lannister-esque). But we also have characters like Key, who is a black market soul merchant who finds herself teaming up with Mourning when his father (and their fount of souls) disappears, who is also struggling with her own culpability in the business even if she doesn’t have the monetary advantages of the Maynes and other Fiend families (and uses her soul stealing skills in a way that leaves her incredibly conflicted as the story progresses). Other characters include an artist named Quinn who has a part to play in the nefarious plan, and a Fiend named Silas who has a cold and predatory nature, but who has been muzzled. While sometimes the four perspectives felt a little harried, I overall enjoyed them.

“The Calamities” also has set up a clear path to more books about the Fiends, and I would absolutely keep reading about them should this come to pass. I so enjoy Chuck Wendig and his creepy horror tales, and this one is another good time.

Rating 8: The world building is stellar and while the metaphor is kind of obvious Wendig creates a nasty and fun world of demons, billionaires, cosmic horror, and undoing familial trauma and damage.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Calamities” is included on the Goodreads blog post “Peek If You Dare: Our Guide to New Horror Books Coming This Fall”.