This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Monster in the Mirror” by Janasha Prabhu
Publishing Info: Sourcebooks Landmark, October 2026
Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publisher
Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound
Book Description: Her uncle was a serial killer. The town whispers, could she be a killer too?
On the night Jiah Rai was found cradling her girlfriend Georgia’s dead body at the bottom of Wailing Cliff, everyone suspected her. There wasn’t enough evidence to charge her, but the town refuses to forget. Murder must run in the family. Jiah’s uncle was a convicted serial killer, and while he died behind bars, his legacy lives on in Jiah and her sister. It doesn’t matter that they’ve lived in Dumont their whole lives—they have never fit into the insular white community, and perhaps they never will.
But legacy isn’t done with Jiah just yet. A few years later, a threat from Georgia’s brother threatens to crumble the shaky peace Jiah has rebuilt. Desperate to feel safe again, Jiah decides to take matters into her own hands and seeks support from her best friend, Estrella. After all, Estrella has been there for Jiah ever since they met after Georgia’s death. But when Estrella never shows up to a dinner party, a series of texts lead Jiah to the beach below, where she finds a body positioned exactly how her uncle displayed his victims over a decade ago. The killer mocks Jiah, hinting they know about her secrets, too. But is Jiah really the monster Dumont thinks she is? As Jiah hunts the killer, she begins to realize she might be unable to save the next victim…and that she may not want to.
Review: Thank you to Sourcebooks Landmark for sending me an ARC of this novel!
We have exited Horrorpalooza and are now into my birthday month of November! I feel like I tend to start playing catch up with the other genres that I review on the blog whenever November rolls around after my full month of horror reads, and I am jumping to a thriller! “Monster in the Mirror” by Janasha Prabhu felt like a nice way to get back into other genres, as I love a small town mystery, I love familial trauma stories, and I love the idea of perhaps a serial killer back to torment a person who thought they had escaped them in the past. I was hoping with all the really fun tid bits about the plot I would really enjoy this one, but unfortunately it was a bit more a mixed bag.
But first the good! I thought that the themes of having to exist in a predominantly white, Christian small town as a POC (who is also queer) were pretty well fleshed out and made the story that much more interesting as Jiah has to contend with rumors and speculation based on her identity. The way that everyone looks at her with suspicion was laid out in the narrative background even before her on again off again girlfriend Georgia was killed in an accident on the side of a cliff, with references to people trying to pressure her to join the church, rude comments being made in school about the food she brings from home, or comments about her father and his relationship with her white mother. The constant Othering that Jiah has to contend with even before the story starts for the reader added a lot of well done context and depth. I also liked how Jiah herself has a lot of issues that make her into a, frankly, rather messy main character, but in a way that feels completely understandable. She is complicated and messed up and fairly unlikable, but I liked that because women characters SHOULD get to be unlikable, dammit! So Jiah was also something I enjoyed about this book.
But I struggled with the way that the mystery played out. There is so much potential with this plot, I really had high hopes because of all of the aspects that involve a serial killer, a dead lover, new suspicions and murders happening, all of that really checks so many boxes for me. But I felt that the pacing was a bit off, and I had already figured out some of the reveals long before the actual twists were explained. This doesn’t usually bother me if the journey getting there is fulfilling, but while I enjoyed certain aspects of this book, the suspense didn’t really reach the levels I had hoped for and the mystery didn’t keep my attention as well as I would have liked. I enjoyed the concept, and I would definitely seek out future works by Prabhu because there is, like I said, such potential there. But the execution of the main suspense elements of this thriller never quite got off the ground.
So “Monster in the Mirror” had things I liked and things I didn’t, but I would say that if you are curious to check it out, definitely do so.
Rating 7: I liked the themes of small town closed mindedness and the main character was the kind of messy that I appreciate, but the mystery itself wasn’t as engaging as I had hoped.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Monster in the Mirror” is included on the Goodreads post “Upcoming Mysteries and Thrillers Readers Can’t Wait to Read”.

















