This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “Of Blades and Wings” by Eliza Raine
Publishing Info: Scarlett Press, November 2026
Where Did I Get this Book: copy from the publisher!
Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound
Book Description: Princess Madivia is the fae Ice Court’s best kept secret; only her family knows what she can really do—and how dangerous it is for her to leave her tower. Then destiny comes for her. Maddy has been selected by the gods themselves to train at Featherblade to become a Valkyrie, an elite guardian of Odin against the lethal Frost Giants.
Trainees, or rooks, have a series of trials to pass to earn their wings. Maddy must get stronger, bond with an ancient animal gifted to her by the gods, and survive the Wild Hunt—all without revealing her hidden powers. Above all, she must determine who she can trust. At the bottom of that list is Kain the Ruinous, disgraced fire fae, villain of Featherblade…and Maddy’s obsession.
She knows she should avoid him. He’s lethal, unhinged, and feeds on fear. But when he’s standing before her, fire in his eyes and heat blazing from his cursed skin, Maddy fears she would let the world go up in flames if he told her to. And if she’s not strong enough, that may be exactly what happens.
Review: I don’t know if I’ve ever read a Valkyrie novel that I’ve really enjoyed. But I’m always hopeful that the next one will be it, so I was excited to pick up this one and see what it could do with these famous beings! All in all, it was a bit of a mixed bag, though, with a few standout strengths but also some notable low points. Let’s get into some details!
To start with, I think the book reads very easily. Things start out quickly, and Maddy is an easy heroine to become invested in. Her magic was intriguing and incorporated things that I don’t believe I’ve seen before in fantasy, which is always refreshing. We only get a few tidbits of information here in the first book about her magic, but the groundwork that is laid is intriguing, and the ways that her abilities have shaped her life (both the benefit she is to her family as well as the threat) were very intriguing. What’s more, I appreciated the sort of character she was.
She’s been kept away for much of her life, and thus is completely unprepared to deal with the circumstances that she now finds herself in. And blessedly, she doesn’t simply transform into a badass warrior out of nowhere, as too many romantasy heroines are prone to do. Instead, the book focuses on her strengths (her curiosity, her bravery, and her willingness to rise to meet the challenge before her) while also reflecting the realities of her lack of abilities. She fails, repeatedly, and the book takes the time to highlight Maddy’s need to pursue basic skill-building like strength training and running. Even here, the fact that she doesn’t even know where to start with either of these things is exposed! It was refreshing to see a heroine who properly reflects the struggles that would come with being thrust into this situation. And it made Maddy all the more compelling that she was committed to the time and work that it would take to succeed.
Beyond Maddy’s magic, I had mixed feelings about the other fantasy elements. I liked the concept of the Valkyrie and the World Tree, but the use of Fae and their various courts felt disjointed and honestly a bit tired at this point. You already have a wealth of lore with Norse mythology; why add in the ubiquitous Fae and immediately water down your own unique fantasy world? It was an odd choice and one that I don’t think added much to affairs.
I also had mixed feelings about the romance, such as it is. This is a slow-burn romance, to be sure, which I appreciate. Frankly, there’s practically no romance whatsoever in this first book, and I think the book properly deals with the fact that at this point there is no real reason for these two to have deeper feelings for each other. The book takes place over only a week or so, so based on time spent alone, these two barely know each other. And beyond that, the distrust between them is earned and valid.
However, the biggest flaw of the book is the pacing and structure of the entire story. Like I said, this book takes place over only a few days, and much of that is Maddy going through the paces of being introduced to this school and dealing with her own limitations. So while on one hand I appreciate the time devoted to her going out and running laps, on the other hand, the book itself has very little actual plot. And then, in the oddest choice of all, it just sort of…ends. There is no greater arc to this story. It feels like the first half or third of a greater story, and the author or publisher simply chopped it into pieces based on page length alone with no concern for structure or storytelling. It was just bizarre.
I also struggled with the fact that this is labeled as an adult fantasy novel and many of the characters involved are full adults. Maddy herself is well into her 20s, but beyond that, she has classmates who are in their 40s, it seems. And yet, so much of the inner drama and tension can rightly be described as “high school antics.” I just couldn’t square the fact that these were supposed to be highly trained, incredibly devoted adults who have spent their lives preparing for this only to turn around and see them pulling pranks like setting Maddy’s things on fire and basic bullying. It was stupid, frankly.
Overall, I think this was an interesting read. I liked the main character and some of the broader fantasy elements. But the mismatch between the adult characters and their YA behavior and the odd choice of how to structure the book and where to cut it off really lessened my ability to fully appreciate it. If you mentally age down the characters and treat it as a YA fantasy novel, I think it reads better. And perhaps it might be worth simply waiting for the next book to drop and reading them back to back to help alleviate the structure issue.
Rating 7: Not without merit, but there was an odd disconnect between the age of the characters and their very YA behavior. I don’t want to read about 40-something warriors behaving like the worst of high school idiots in an adult fantasy novel.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Of Blades and Wings” isn’t on any Goodreads lists, but it should be on Amazons, Valkyries, and Warrior Women.
















