This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “Murder at Enscombe Park” by Vanessa Kelly
Publishing Info: Kensington, November 2026
Where Did I Get this Book: Netgalley!
Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound
Book Description: Emma, her husband George, and her father and his new wife have journeyed to Enscombe Park, the grand estate where Jane and Frank live with his uncle, who adopted Frank as a boy. Upon their arrival, they are concerned to find Jane wan from her condition, Frank bruised from a mysterious accident, and Mr. Churchill in an ill temper, as well as surprised by additional houseguests including Miss Caroline Bingley and a distant cousin from the West Indies.
Emma worries this might all be too much for Jane, but it is Mr. Churchill who is decidedly out-of-sorts, possibly due to his heart medication. When Frank’s uncle is found dead in the library, it appears he’s fallen victim to heart seizure. But Emma—despite George’s admonitions to stay out of it—begins to wonder if he may have been poisoned.
Experience has taught Emma that her matchmaking instincts may not always be spot-on, but her sleuthing skills are as sharp as ever. As a recently altered will and secret debts come to light, suspicion falls on Frank Churchill of all people. Now it’s up to Emma to save her friend’s husband from the gallows . . .
Previously Reviewed: “Murder in Highbury” and “Murder at Donwell Abbey”
Review: While I still largely enjoyed this novel, as the series has continued and moved further and further afield of Highbury and the classic characters of the original book, I’ve found myself starting to fall off a bit. And such was the case again here.
To begin with what I still very much enjoy, however, I still really like this version of Emma as a burgeoning detective. Her snooping, gossiping ways translate very nicely into the sort of character who would easily find themselves caught up in a mystery and unable to let it go until a solution has been found. Her characterization also remains fairly true to the original, foibles and all, which I very much appreciate.
Mr. Knightley is probably my favorite Austen hero, so I’ve been pleased to see his characterization remain steady as well. His long-suffering but besotted approach to Emma’s antics always leads to some of my favorite scenes. I’ve also enjoyed watching him slowly come to accept that his wife will not be stopped from this current trend, and it could always be worse: she could go back to matchmaking!
That said, I did struggle with a few other aspects of this story. There was one subplot that I’m never particularly a fan of reading, and while it was done fairly well here, it did lose my interest and added certain dynamics that I always find frustrating. But this was a fairly subjective point.
Beyond that, however, this book did feel a bit overlong, and some of the length-increasing portions came at the expense of its characters. Mr. Churchill is already a bit of a complicated character. Is he likable or not? Does he behave well or poorly? But here it felt like there was a series of repetitive scenes where he was simply angry, again and again. Not only did this make him fairly unlikable, but Jane’s tolerance of his behavior was also frustrating.
I’ve also been a bit on the fence about the changes to Miss Bates with her relationship and now marriage to Mr. Woodhouse. Something that always stands out when I reread Jane Austen is her willingness to write comedic characters with no excuses or punches pulled. Miss Bates is a kind woman, but she is never presented as anything other than fairly ridiculous and silly. And because Austen never shied away from fully highlighting the folly of her comedic characters, she ended up writing them brilliantly. As such, Miss Bates was one of my favorites.
But by now, in the third book, the version of Miss Bates we have here is barely recognizable from the original. Instead, she is a steadying, reasonable force of good, one who is indeed capable of providing support to Emma in the management of Mr. Woodhouse first and foremost. Not only is this a loss of the original version, but in this unwillingness to allow characters to be as ridiculous as they were in the original book, characters began to feel more washed out and one-note.
I did enjoy the mystery itself, but, again, the story felt a bit too drawn out to succeed as well as the previous two. That said, if you’ve liked the series so far, this is still largely a successful follow-up, and I will be happy to return to the series if another book is on the way!
Rating 7: Give me a more ridiculous Miss Bates and a less angry Mr. Churchill, and I would have enjoyed this one a bit more. But as I’m mostly here for Emma and Knightley, this was still a fun read.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Murder at Enscombe Park” can be found on this Goodreads list: Jane Austen Mysteries.
















