Tag: LGBT

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. Our current theme is song inspirations, where we were given a random song from a random genre and had to pick a book based on the song.  For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club!

Book: “Music From Another World” by Robin Talley

Publishing Info: Inkyard Press, March 2020

Where Did We Get This Book: Kate owns it; Serena got it from the library!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Song Inspiration: “Alternative Ulster” by Stiff Little Fingers

Book Description: A master of award-winning queer historical fiction, New York Times bestselling author Robin Talley brings to life an emotionally captivating story about the lives of two teen girls living in an age when just being yourself was an incredible act of bravery.

It’s summer 1977 and closeted lesbian Tammy Larson can’t be herself anywhere. Not at her strict Christian high school, not at her conservative Orange County church and certainly not at home, where her ultrareligious aunt relentlessly organizes antigay political campaigns. Tammy’s only outlet is writing secret letters in her diary to gay civil rights activist Harvey Milk…until she’s matched with a real-life pen pal who changes everything.

Sharon Hawkins bonds with Tammy over punk music and carefully shared secrets, and soon their letters become the one place she can be honest. The rest of her life in San Francisco is full of lies. The kind she tells for others—like helping her gay brother hide the truth from their mom—and the kind she tells herself. But as antigay fervor in America reaches a frightening new pitch, Sharon and Tammy must rely on their long-distance friendship to discover their deeply personal truths, what they’ll stand for…and who they’ll rise against.

Kate’s Thoughts

Our newest Book Club theme is pretty unique, I think, in which we picked music genres out of a hat and then picking a random song from said genre. I was lucky in that I got punk, which is one of my favorite music genres, and then I got “Alternative Ulster” by Stiff Little Fingers, a Northern Irish band I had very limited knowledge of. But when I looked into the lyrics and it was about people dreaming of a better life and a better place where everyone can just live freely, my mind went to “Music From Another World” by Robin Talley, a book I bought in the early days of COVID but never read. It just seemed perfect given that it’s a book about two queer girls who are pen pals in the 1970s, who are contending with various laws that are threatening to make queer people targets of discrimination, hate, and violence. Sounds familiar, right? That’s the other reason I chose this book. And it just so happened punk music was also a theme!

Overall I really enjoyed “Music from Another World”, for a number of reasons. The first is that I liked the setting of late 1970s California, as this was a time that was pivotal in the gay rights movements of the 20th century, with Harvey Milk making history and making waves and LGBTQIA+ people pushing back against hateful legislation like Proposition 6 and other bills like it (all while said bills were being embraced and promoted by right wing bigots like Anita Bryant). Talley did a pretty good job of setting the scene, and showing protagonists Sharon and Tammy as they lean on punk music and each other through pen pal letters. The historical details were well presented and felt pretty easy to understand, and it breaks down this moment in ways that make it easy to connect to the current moment as LGBTQIA+ are being targeted again. I also liked the epistolary style of this book, told by letters and diary entries, but I know that such a style isn’t for everyone, as it can be a bit clunky at times (and is in this novel). I was able to forgive it because I like these kinds of found media/transcript plot devices, but also because I liked Tammy and Sharon slowly start to trust each other and develop a bond that neither were expecting. I also, as you can probably tell, really liked how this felt like a hopeful and earnest cry out to readers to not let discrimination and hate towards LGBTQIA+ people fester and take hold, and to push back. It’s hard to find hope in that regard these days. But like Harvey Milk said, ‘ya gotta give ’em hope’. And I fell like this book does that.

I enjoyed “Music from Another World”. It’s just the start of a new Book Club theme, and I have a feeling it’s going to be an interesting one!

Serena’s Thoughts

Overall, I liked this book, too, and agree with everything Kate said. I think the historical elements were particularly interesting and relevant to younger readers who may not be as familiar with this period in history, especially in the LGBT community. As Kate mentioned, there were some clearly intentional choices to focus on hope rather than despair, and I think that’s just always a really great message, regardless. This was especially noteworthy with the decisions made with regards to when and how to end the story.

I did struggle a bit with the style of the story. I’m a really hard sell the epistolary style in novels in general. I’m one of those annoying people who get fixated on details like “no one would EVER write out this much dialogue in a diary!!” So I did struggle to connect to the characters a bit. While I did like them, I think I felt so removed from their story due to the format of the story, that I never felt like I was really sucked into the story. I was too aware that I was reading the entire time to really enjoy this one, if that makes sense.

But I do think this book will appeal to a lot of readers and is a really unique way of telling this sort of story. It is very informative, while also reading as a sweet, teenage love story.

Kate’s Rating 8: A hopeful and far too relevant story about daring to be yourself and striving for a better reality, “Music From Another World” was enjoyable and inspiring.

Serena’s Rating 7: While I struggled with the format, I think this book will greatly appeal to a large swath of readers looking for a hopeful take on history and the present.

Book Club Questions

1. What were your thoughts on the epistolary narrative device in this book? Did you feel like it worked?
2. When Sharon visits the Castro with Peter, she notes that there are not many women at the protests, and that she feels like she doesn’t really belong. What do you think Talley was trying to say with this feeling of isolation?
3. Talley opted to end the book with the failure of Prop 6, and didn’t go into the assassination of Harvey Milk by Dan White or the White Light Riots that happened after. With Milk being such a huge part of Tammy’s narrative, did you think ending before his death was a good narrative choice? Why or why not?
4. Tammy and Sharon connected to each other at first because of their love of punk music. Have you ever connected with someone and bonded over a love of music?
5. By the end of the book it’s a bit up in the air about Sharon and Peter’s relationship with their mother? Do you think that she will eventually accept her children as they are?
6. This book came out in early 2020. What parallels do you see between this story and what is happening with American policy today?

Reader’s Advisory

“Music From Another World” is included on the Goodreads lists “Alex’s Sapphic Masterlist”, and “YA Set in the 1970s”.

Next Book Club Pick: “Girly Drinks: A World History of Women and Alcohol” by Mallory O’Meara

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. Our current theme is retellings and re-imaginings.  For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club!

Book: “The Raven and the Reindeer” by T. Kingfisher

Publishing Info: Argyll Productions, July 2017

Where Did We Get This Book: The library!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Retelling/Re-imagining: “The Snow Queen”

Book Description: When Gerta’s friend Kay is stolen away by the mysterious Snow Queen, it’s up to Gerta to find him. Her journey will take her through a dangerous land of snow and witchcraft, accompanied only by a bandit and a talking raven. Can she win her friend’s release, or will following her heart take her to unexpected places?

A strange, sly retelling of Hans Christian Andersen’s “Snow Queen,” by T. Kingfisher, author of “Bryony and Roses” and “The Seventh Bride.”

Kate’s Thoughts

I have very little familiarity with fairy tales that go beyond The Brothers Grimm, and while I know the basics of “The Snow Queen”, I never read it as a kid and I don’t know a lot of the details (if we’re being vulnerable on the blog today, my information mostly came from Tumblr posts when “Frozen” came out). But I did know that I like T. Kingfisher, and I liked the past reimagining she did, “What Moves the Dead”. So when Serena picked “The Raven and the Reindeer” I was on board. No questions asked.

I thought that “The Raven and the Reindeer” was not only a creative and unique reimagining of “The Snow Queen” based on my knowledge, I also thought that it was heartfelt and at times very funny. Which is something that I expect from Kingfisher these days. I really liked Gerta’s character arc, as she starts out as a starry eyed and somewhat naïve teenager who thinks she is in love with her life long friend Kay, who is very noncommittal to her as, really, any sort of significant person in his life. After he’s kidnapped by the Snow Queen and Gerta goes on a quest to save him, she starts her own personal journey of self discovery, with the help of a snarky raven named Mousebones with whom she can communicate, as well as that of Janna, a bandit girl with a heart of gold. I loved seeing Gerta start to realize that she may not necessarily need Kay to love her to feel whole and complete, and also starting to realize that perhaps her attractions are towards someone else. Kingfisher also makes such a fun character out of Mousebones, whose snarky attitude adds most of the humor and had me chuckling over and over again.

I really enjoyed “The Raven and the Reindeer”! T. Kingfisher has such a knack for charming stories that feel very original, and this would be a great place to start with her catalog if you haven’t already!

Serena’s Thoughts

This was a pretty easy book club pick for me. I knew I wanted to do a fairytale re-telling, and then, obviously, I’ve loved everything I’ve ever read by T. Kingfisher. Beyond that, “The Snow Queen” is a tough nut to crack as far as re-tellings go and I haven’t read too many of them (unlike the endless versions of “Beauty and the Beast” and “Cinderella” stories to be found!)

As predicted, I really liked Kingfisher’s take on this story. I’m pretty familiar with the original, so it was easy to recognize the many similarities as well as the points of divergence. In particular, I really liked the switch made to Gerta and Kay’s relationship, with Gerta slowly beginning to understand that while she still wanted to save her friend, Kay might not be where it’s at as far as love interests go. Instead, Kingfisher also reimagines the bandit girl who in this story serves as not only the true love interest, but also as a companion for Gerta on the second half of her journey.

I also really enjoyed the quirky animals found throughout the story. This is another staple of Kingfisher’s work, and it melded perfectly with this fairytale that already has a number of animals featured within it. The raven, of course, was hilarious and excellent, as well as the exuberant, magical otters that pull the Snow Queen’s sleigh. But, I have to say, the reindeer, for all that he’s only around for a very short bit, really hit me in the feels. I’ll admit that there were tears.

Overall, this was a fun re-imaging of the classic tale, and I think it will appeal to all fairytale re-telling fans!

Kate’s Rating 8: This is a charming and funny re-imagining of a fairy tale that I wasn’t super familiar with.

Serena’s Rating 8: Sweet and heartfelt, this is an excellent re-telling of “The Snow Queen.”

Book Club Questions

1. How familiar are you with the original story? Was there a change that stood-out to you?
2. Kingfisher re-imagines the relationships at the heart of this story. What do you think of her portrayal of Gerta and Kay’s frienship?
3. There were a number of mini adventures throughout this story, which one did you enjoy the most and why?
4. Which animal companion was your favorite and why?
5. This story focuses on themes of courage and self-esteem. In what ways did the author tackle these topics and was it effective?

Reader’s Advisory

“The Raven and the Reindeer” isn’t on any Goodreads lists, but it should be on Popular The Snow Queen Retellings Books.

Next Book Club Pick: “Music from Another World”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. Our current theme is retellings and re-imaginings.  For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club!

Book: “Spear” by Nicola Griffin

Publishing Info: Tordotcom, April 2022

Where Did We Get This Book: The library!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat | Amazon | Indiebound

Retelling/Re-imagining: “Legends of King Arthur”

Book Description: The girl knows she has a destiny before she even knows her name. She grows up in the wild, in a cave with her mother, but visions of a faraway lake come to her on the spring breeze, and when she hears a traveler speak of Artos, king of Caer Leon, she knows that her future lies at his court.

And so, brimming with magic and eager to test her strength, she breaks her covenant with her mother and, with a broken hunting spear and mended armour, rides on a bony gelding to Caer Leon. On her adventures she will meet great knights and steal the hearts of beautiful women. She will fight warriors and sorcerers. And she will find her love, and the lake, and her fate.

Kate’s Thoughts

I’ve mentioned a number of times on here that I am not super versed in some of the more classic European literature tales, and that extends to Arthurian legends. I think that the adaptations I have seen all the way through are Disney’s “The Sword in the Stone”, which is more about Arthur getting the sword and not much else, and “Monty Python and the Holy Grail”, which is, of course, near perfection. But it’s not like an absurdist comedy with holy hand grenades and killer rabbits is going to reflect Arthur in all his significance. So going into “Spear” I didn’t really know what to expect, as I have a vague working knowledge of some aspects of the source material, but not much. And I’m sorry to say that while I went in trying to be open minded, “Spear” wasn’t my jam. I just kept thinking about coconuts and John Cleese slaughtering people in ridiculous ways and wishing I was watching that again.

So there were some things I liked about “Spear” and that was mostly in the ways that Nicola Griffin tinkered with the characters and the canon. Whether it was having main character Peretur be a gender bent version of Parzival during his quest with the other knights for the Holy Grail. I liked Peretur’s queer relationship with Nimuë, I liked that Arturus (Arthur), Gwenhwyfar (Guinevere) and Llanza (Lancelot) were in a loving thrupple as opposed to being in a dramatic love triangle, and I liked some of the ways that Griffin explores themes of the Grail and the magical bits of it. But there was so much I struggled with. The biggest issue I had was the writing. It is VERY lyrical, and very detailed, and I had initially picked this book up in print form but threw in the towel VERY quickly and opted for audio. My thought process was that I would be on a couple road trips to Duluth before book club and could use that time to listen, as I’ve had success in the past with that if I find the writing tricky. But it didn’t really help this time. And I think that had I had more investment in the Arthurian source material I would have been more vested in engaging, but since I don’t know it very well I found this book to be a tricky read, bordering on a chore. I am inclined to believe that this is probably a ‘your mileage may vary’ situation, but it just didn’t click with me.

Fans of King Arthur and very purple prose writing styles would probably connect with this, but it wasn’t for me.

Serena’s Thoughts

This was an interesting read for me. On paper, it has a lot of things I really enjoy. I’m fairly familiar with King Arthur legends, but mostly through a strange smattering of exposure to various retellings and adaptations and my own internet rabbit holes of research. I’ve only looked at a few of the “original” legends, themselves. All of this to say, when I picked up “Spear,” I was able to tell right away that this was going to appeal to the big fans of these stories. And that comes to the second thing I typically enjoy: lyrical writing. From the very first page, this is what stands out the most about this book for me. The writing is dense and poetic. There were many times that I found myself having to re-read long sentences to piece together exactly what was being said. As a fan of lyrical writing, I’m used to this experience to some extent, but even for me, I found this one a bit more challenging that I would have liked. That said, I can’t emphasize enough how impressed I am with Griffin’s ability to match the tone of the “original” King Arthur legends. For the big fans, this book will feel as if it can be neatly slotted right in alongside those, as the style of writing and storytelling found here match so well to those.

It’s also clear that Griffin has done her research. For such a short novel, it’s truly impressive just how many details and references she manages to pack in there. As a fan of Juliet Marillier’s, an author who largely relies on Irish folklore and legends, I enjoyed seeing some of these tales and beings woven in throughout this story.

I also really liked our main character and her story. I had a few concerns early on when she showed hints of being a bit too unbelievably good at certain skills with no explanation, but luckily there did turn out to be good reasons for this. I also enjoyed the gender-swapping of her character from male to female and the various changes and additions that Griffith brought to the story. Overall, I did find myself struggling to read this one more than I had hoped (the writing is hard), but I do think that it will greatly appeal to hardcore King Arthur fans.

Kate’s Rating 5: This was a bit of a slog for me, as I couldn’t connect to the writing style and I know very little about King Arthur lore and legend.

Serena’s Rating 8: For me, personally, this was probably a 7. But I rounded up to an 8 for the true Arthur aficionados who will appreciate the meticulous and detailed work that went into creating this story.

Book Club Questions

1. How familiar are you with the legends of King Arthur? Specifically, how much did you know about the various iterations of Percival?
2. Did you like the gender-swapped approach to this story? How do you think this changed or impacted the tale as a whole?
3. The writing in this book is very in line with the style found in many of the more traditional Arthur stories. How did this impact your reading?
4. How familiar were you with the various Irish legends and folklore that wove in and out of this story?
5. This is a novella, so it has a reduced page count from a typical novel. Did this seem to fit the story we have here? Would you have liked it to be longer or shorter? And if so, why? Were there parts you wanted to know more about or could have done without?

Reader’s Advisory

“Spear” is on these Goodreads lists: Amazons, Valkyries, and Warrior Women and Sapphic Retellings.

Next Book Club Pick: “The Raven and the Reindeer” by T. Kingfisher

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. Our current theme is retellings and re-imaginings.  For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club!

Book: “Great or Nothing” by Joy McCullough, Caroline Tung Richmond, Tess Sharpe, & Jessica Spotswood

Publishing Info: Delacorte, March 2022

Where Did We Get This Book: The library!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat | Amazon | Indiebound

Retelling/Re-imagining: “Little Women”

Book Description: A reimagining of Little Women set in the spring of 1942, when the United States is suddenly embroiled in the second World War, this story, told from each March sister’s point of view, is one of grief, love, and self-discovery.

In the spring of 1942, the United States is reeling from the attack on Pearl Harbor. While the US starts sending troops to the front, the March family of Concord, Massachusetts grieves their own enormous loss: the death of their daughter, Beth.

Under the strain of their grief, Beth’s remaining sisters fracture, each going their own way with Jo nursing her wounds and building planes in Boston, Meg holding down the home front with Marmee, and Amy living a secret life as a Red Cross volunteer in London–the same city where one Mr. Theodore Laurence is stationed as an army pilot.

Each March sister’s point of view is written by a separate author, three in prose and Beth’s in verse, still holding the family together from beyond the grave. Woven together, these threads tell a story of finding one’s way in a world undergoing catastrophic change.

Kate’s Thoughts

I’m someone who has what is probably an average relationship with the book “Little Women”. I read it once a long time ago, I really like the 1994 film with Winona Ryder, and when I was working at a historic Victorian house I was one of the people who would lead a “Little Women” themed Christmas tour. I’m not super wedded to the book like I am “Anne of Green Gables”, but I like it enough. When I saw that Book Club was going to take on a “Little Women” re-imagining that takes place during World War II, it struck me as a perfect time period to revisit this story of sisters growing up during war time and learning hard life lessons while also finding their places in the world. And I was happy to see that I was right.

“Great or Nothing” is written in four different perspectives from four different authors, one for each March sister. The story plunks us midway through the original tale, with Beth already dead and Jo, Meg, and Amy separated and feeling the distance (especially since they all left on a sour note between the three of them). The surviving sisters take on roles that women could have during WWII that perfectly fit each of them. We have Meg at the home front doing fundraising, planting victory gardens, and teaching children. We have Jo working in a plane factory, doing a whole Rosie the Riveter thing. And we have Amy in London volunteering for the Red Cross, and meeting up with Laurie who is fighting in Europe. Beth also has a perspective, with poetry being used because she’s dead, I guess? Regardless, I really felt like all of these settings were perfect for the various sisters, and I mostly liked how all of the sisters felt like their core characters set in a new time. I think that my favorite was Meg’s, as the home front has always fascinated me with war bonds, fund raising, and advocacy, but I did like Jo’s story of working in a factory and finding romance with a lady war reporter named Charlie (as a true Professor Bhaer fan, I loved how they brought this relationship into this story with a queer twist). That said, I did find it a little bit of a bummer that we were at a point in the story where Meg, Jo, and Amy weren’t really interacting with each other, as that is part of the charm of the original story for me. It seemed like an odd choice, but at the same time since it was four different authors writing each sister, I suppose that makes some sense so as not to step on each other’s toes.

“Great or Nothing” is a really well thought out re-imagining of a classic tale, with a nice blending of voices from different authors to give Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy March interesting stories in the 20th century.

Serena’s Thoughts

I’m probably similar to Kate in my devotion levels to the original “Little Women.” Enjoyed the book, liked the 90s version of the movie well enough, really liked the recent one that was released a few years ago. But, like Kate, I don’t have any strong emotions attached to it, which in many ways makes it the perfect book for a retelling! If you’re not a devoted fan, you won’t get as mad at changes!

Anyways, the first thing that stood out to me was how much I liked the change in time period. There are a million and one WWII books out there, but this story really took a unique angle at exploring all of the very different ways that women contributed to the war front, both at home and abroad. Not only did this give the reader a wide range of angles on this particular time of history, but all of these choices also worked perfectly with the characters themselves. I was also very impressed with how well the different writing styles of all of the authors worked together. Perhaps….too impressed? If I hadn’t know that this was authored by four different people, I’m not sure I would have guessed, and I’m not sure that’s really for the best. Obviously, cohesion on this sort of project is key, but I also think you lose something from the original goal if every author’s voice is paired down to the point that they’re indistinguishable from each other.

As for the story, I thought it did a good job of hitting the major plot points that fans will look for. That said, I didn’t necessarily enjoy many of these chapters. While I liked the look at the types of work that Meg and Jo were doing, their personal arcs I found more frustrating. Honestly, if I had to hear one more time about the big fight they all got into, I think I would have screamed. In this way, I felt like this book really missed the mark on the overall theme of “Little Women.” Yes, the sisters have their quarrels, but the primary heart of the story is built around the deep bonds they all share. So for this book to spend the vast majority of its time with each sister endlessly reflecting on their broken ties…it just felt like a bummer and a let down of the original premise. This being the case, Amy’s story rose to the top for me as the only one that felt as it had any real action or stakes involved. I enjoyed getting to see her and Teddy’s romance play out more in real-time as well, rather than the off-page romance we get in the original.

Overall, I felt like this book was ok. I didn’t love anything it was doing, but I also didn’t hate any of it. I think Meg and Jo both could have been done better by, but I really enjoyed Beth’s poetry sections and Amy’s plot line. Fans of the original looking for a unique take will likely enjoy this, however.

Kate’s Rating 8: A great new setting for a classic tale of sisters growing up and finding themselves, “Great or Nothing” is a successful “Little Women” retelling.

Serena’s Rating 7: An interesting reimaging with an excellent use of shifting the historical setting, but it still somehow feels as if it misses the mark on the heart of the original story.

Book Club Questions

1. What did you think of the time period in this retelling? Do you think that World War II fit in with the “Little Women” story?
2. Each of the March sisters was written by a different author. Did you like any sister more than the others?
3. Did the Beth sections with the poetry work for you as you were reading? Would you have preferred to see another character’s perspective over Beth’s, like Laurie, or Marmee?
4. Which of the sister’s plots would you like to be in? The homefront? A factory? Acting as a Red Cross volunteer overseas? Something else?
5. What is your experience with the original “Little Women” story?

Reader’s Advisory

“Great or Nothing” is included on the Goodreads lists “Book Riot 2022 #21: Read a Queer Retelling of a Classic of the Canon, Fairytale, Folklore, or Myth”, and “YA & Middle Grade Retellings of “Little Women””.

Next Book Club Pick: “The Raven and the Reindeer” by T. Kingfisher