Tag: 9 Rating

Serena’s Review: “Funny Story”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Funny Story” by Emily Henry

Publishing Info: Berkley, April 2024

Where Did I Get this Book: Edelweiss+

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Daphne always loved the way her fiancé Peter told their story. How they met (on a blustery day), fell in love (over an errant hat), and moved back to his lakeside hometown to begin their life together. He really was good at telling it…right up until the moment he realized he was actually in love with his childhood best friend Petra.

Which is how Daphne begins her new story: Stranded in beautiful Waning Bay, Michigan, without friends or family but with a dream job as a children’s librarian (that barely pays the bills), and proposing to be roommates with the only person who could possibly understand her predicament: Petra’s ex, Miles Nowak.

Scruffy and chaotic—with a penchant for taking solace in the sounds of heart break love ballads—Miles is exactly the opposite of practical, buttoned up Daphne, whose coworkers know so little about her they have a running bet that she’s either FBI or in witness protection. The roommates mainly avoid one another, until one day, while drowning their sorrows, they form a tenuous friendship and a plan. If said plan also involves posting deliberately misleading photos of their summer adventures together, well, who could blame them?

But it’s all just for show, of course, because there’s no way Daphne would actually start her new chapter by falling in love with her ex-fiancé’s new fiancée’s ex…right?

Review: I really don’t read contemporary romance other than my two exceptions: Emily Henry’s books and now, more and more, Ali Hazelwood’s books (though here we’ve had the best case scenario where she’s also written a paranormal romance!). But Henry was my first love as far as the genre goes, so I always schedule in time to review her new books when I see them coming out. Let’s dive in!

First of all, I would like to congratulate Emily Henry on her wise decision to make her heroine a children’s librarian. There is no better way to make yourself more beloved in librarians’ eyes (a profession that notably buys a lot of books both personally and professionally) than to write a character who works for libraries or in other ways goes on and on about how great libraries are. That said, I don’t think this is a cynical move by authors either. It’s not hard to imagine that most authors grew up with a love of reading, and often libraries play a central role in that development, and thus hold a lot of nostalgic power for adult writers.

All of that to say, beyond the central romance plot line, I loved reading about Daphne’s experience as a children’s librarian. I also appreciated that her profession was worked centrally into the story, and not just as another “character trait” that is just loosely draped on her shoulders but never shown. Indeed, the long work of putting together a large community event at her library serves as a time piece by which the rest of the book is measured. There were also some very cute moments where Daphne’s friends and love interest come to her storytimes and are all duly impressed. *sigh* Every children’s librarian’s dream: adults to appreciate the work that goes into storytime!

But, all of that aside, most readers will be picking this one up for the romance, not the library side plot. And, of course, Henry delivers with flying colors! I loved this take on fake dating (very different from her previous foray into this trope with “Happy Place”) as well as the forced proximity aspect of the story. All of the cute and satisfying scenes that readers often expect from these tropes play out in adorable, and yet still fresh-feeling, ways. However, I think the real strength to not only the romance but the book itself comes in the exploration of how these two characters are attempting to re-build their lives after their ex’s cheat on them with each other. It’s a kind of ridiculous concept at its core, and yet Henry tackles it all with such a careful and sincere manner that the reader can’t help but buy in totally. I also really enjoyed how much this re-building was seen on an individual level for both Daphne and Miles, beyond their coming together as a couple. It was nice to see them both grappling with their own life choices that lead them to where they were, rather than simply using a new relationship as a band-aid to not deal with the previous one.

I also appreciated the way that Petra and Peter were dealt with. They only make brief appearances here and there, but their presence was felt strongly through much of the narrative. But instead of taking the easy way out and writing them each as soulless villains, Henry was more realistic in their portrayal. They aren’t given a pass on their more despicable moments, but by the end of the novel, the reader, alongside Daphne and Miles, comes to view them more with pity as the rather broken people they are, than as horrible beings who would just hurt their loved ones for fun.

And, of course, I very much enjoyed Daphne and Miles and their romance. It builds up nicely, and I also felt that the necessary third act conflict felt believable and in line with both of their characters (rather than shoed-in for necessity’s sake, as you so often see in romance stories). I will say, that while I loved Miles, he probably wasn’t my favorite of Henry’s romantic leads. But this is just a personal preference thing for sure. He is often described as a bit of a “golden retriever” of a man, and as much as he’s lovable, I tend to gravitate towards the more serious romantic heroes, if given my druthers.

This was another solid romance from Emily Henry. It delivers in all of the areas I’ve come to expect from her, and I’m sure it will please all of her many fans as well as any new contemporary romance readers who pick it up!

Rating 9: Sweet, heart-wrenching, and achingly romantic, Henry proves once again why she’s the GOAT of contemporary romance!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Funny Story” can be found on this (and many others just like it) Goodreads list: 2024 Contemporary Romance Releases

Serena’s Review: “Dark Water Daughter”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Dark Water Daughter” by H.M. Long

Publishing Info: Titan Books, July 2023

Where Did I Get this Book: Netgalley!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Mary Firth is a Stormsinger: a woman whose voice can still hurricanes and shatter armadas. Faced with servitude to pirate lord Silvanus Lirr, Mary offers her skills to his arch-rival in exchange for protection – and, more importantly, his help sending Lirr to a watery grave. But her new ally has a vendetta of his own, and Mary’s dreams are dark and full of ghistings, spectral creatures who inhabit the ancient forests of her homeland and the figureheads of ships.

Samuel Rosser is a disgraced naval officer serving aboard The Hart, an infamous privateer commissioned to bring Lirr to justice. He will stop at nothing to capture Lirr, restore his good name and reclaim the only thing that stands between himself and madness: a talisman stolen by Mary.

Finally, driven into the eternal ice at the limits of their world, Mary and Samuel must choose their loyalties and battle forces older and more powerful than the pirates who would make them slaves.

Review: I’ve been wanting to get back to H.M. Long’s books for a while now, and even had this mentally slotted as one to review last summer when it came out. Obviously, that didn’t happen. But better late than never! And as the sequel is scheduled to drop this coming July, I can even say I’m getting this review out of the way several months in advance! We’ll see if I can be timely about getting to that one! Though, given how much I enjoyed this book, I think think the chances are high!

I feel like there was a very brief blip where pirate fantasy stories were trending, around when Adrienne Young wrote her “Fable” duology. But it didn’t quite take off in the same way we’ve seen with other incredibly popular trends (the vampire one currently is a good example, where every third book you see will be a vampire book in some way or another). It’s too bad though, as I think that pirate stories or even just sea-fairing adventure stories are a perfect match for a lot of classic fantasy fiction. They both often involve quests of some sort that move from location to location; there are often larger parties of characters who all have their own motivations and loyalties; and, of course, lots of fight scenes! Long was able to hone in on all of these elements perfectly in this book.

For the fantasy elements, I really liked the world we have here. Not only is Mary’s weather singing ability super interesting on its own, but I enjoyed the way this kind of ability was worked into the organization of this society and the history behind how Stormsingers have historically been treated. Especially for a very nautical group of countries, we can easily see how Stormsingers would be in the sort of demand they are, as well as how their abilities could be exploited by those around them. Beyond the Stormsinging, however, there were a lot of other excellent fantasy elements. I feel like we only scratched the surface of Samuel’s own abilities, with some big swings coming towards the end of the book (I’m especially excited to see where his story goes in the next book). And on top of all of this, we have the ghistlings. These beings felt like a bit of an after thought in both the book summary and in the beginning of the story, but man, that was a bait and switch! There were some truly shocking twists and turns in this arena throughout the book.

I also really enjoyed Mary and Samuel as characters. Each had a rich and compelling back story that was slowly revealed, and I particularly enjoyed the extreme slow burn of their growing relationship. We’re talking slooooowww. After reading a bunch of romantasy books recently, I very much appreciated the return to fantasy where there is a romance, but it is definitely a subplot to not only the greater plot but also to the individual character arcs. As an aside, I had a moment reading this book where I realized I may have been reading a bit too much romantasy recently when the villain was first introduced and I found myself wondering if he was being introduced as a second spoke in a developing love triangle (there is a bare whiff of a love triangle, to be fair, but not with this character.) Sometimes villains are just villains, Serena! Once I re-oriented myself to the real world of most fantasy fiction, I appreciated just how villainous this character really was, and how clearly everyone around him saw this fact.

I also really enjoyed the many various side characters we met. There were several different ships with their own crews and captains that wove in and out of this story, and I enjoyed how all of these moving parts worked together to build to the ultimate show-down. There were some great twists and turns with these side characters as well, with swapping loyalties and a shifting scope of who were the good guys and bad guys at any given moment. It all felt very “Pirates of the Caribbean” in the best way.

I loved this book! It managed to balance so many things all at once without dropping a single plate. There was action, there was danger, there was loyalty and betrayal, love and friendship, and, of course, a large dose of magic in a creative secondary world. After reading this book, I can fairly confidently move Long into my “must read” category for fantasy authors currently writing. If you enjoy fantasy adventures, and especially pirate stories, definitely check this one out!

Rating 9: A perfect combination of a high stakes pirate adventure and a fantasy-fueled quest of discovery. I couldn’t put it down!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Dark Water Daughter” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Nautical Fantasy and Gunpowder Fantasy.

Kate’s Review: “The Angel of Indian Lake”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Angel of Indian Lake” by Stephen Graham Jones

Publishing Info: S&S/ Saga Press, March 2024

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: The final installment in the most lauded trilogy in the history of horror novels picks up four years after Don’t Fear the Reaper as Jade returns to Proofrock, Idaho, to build a life after the years of sacrifice—only to find the Lake Witch is waiting for her in New York Times bestselling author Stephen Graham Jones’s finale.

It’s been four years in prison since Jade Daniels last saw her hometown of Proofrock, Idaho, the day she took the fall, protecting her friend Letha and her family from incrimination. Since then, her reputation, and the town, have changed dramatically. There’s a lot of unfinished business in Proofrock, from serial killer cultists to the rich trying to buy Western authenticity. But there’s one aspect of Proofrock no one wants to confront…until Jade comes back to town. The curse of the Lake Witch is waiting, and now is the time for the final stand.

New York Times bestselling author Stephen Graham Jones has crafted an epic horror trilogy of generational trauma from the Indigenous to the townies rooted in the mountains of Idaho. It is a story of the American west written in blood.

Review: Thank you to Saga Press for sending me an eARC of this via NetGalley!

When I first picked up “My Heart Is a Chainsaw” by Stephen Graham Jones, I didn’t really know what to expect, but I thought that it would at the very least be a fun meta horror story with an abundance of references to the genre I love most. And it was. BUT, it was also the start of a trilogy that would expand upon and defy conventions of the slasher genre while still showing complete adoration for it. And we have now come to the end of Proofrock, and the end of Jade Daniels, final girl for the ages, with “The Angel of Indian Lake”. By the time I had it in my hands on my Kindle, I was very, VERY excited to start it, but also nervous. Was Stephen Graham Jones going to stick the landing of this series? What a fool I was for questioning him. Because “The Angel of Indian Lake” is a worthy end to a love letter to slashers and their final girls everywhere.

Jade can officially join the exalted ranks of Laurie, Sidney, Nancy, and Sally when all is said and done. (source)

Jade Daniels remains the MVP of not only this trilogy, but one of Jones’s best characters of all, and it was so great seeing her character arc from the beginning of the trilogy up until and through this book. I love how she has persevered, how she is still a HUGE weirdo in her own way, how she is still scrappy but vulnerable and goes beyond the expected qualities of a heroine in a slasher film. In “The Angel of Indian Lake” she is trying to live a normal life as a teacher, she is going to therapy, she is acting as a godmother to her best friend Letha’s daughter Adie. But Proofrock’s demons keep pulling her back in, and as a whole new cycle of horrific murders, as well as a new gentrification cycle, AS WELL AS A FOREST FIRE, threatens the town, Jade, once again, has to step up. And this time you can tell how weary she is, even if she is always going to go forth and fight.

In terms of the horror action, there is a LOT in this book, almost like there are just so many slasher beats and meta themes that are all fighting to come through. There are cursed objects, decapitations, the return of previous killers, things rising from the lake that are long thought dead. Like I said, it’s a LOT, and it can skew towards chaotic, but it’s done in a way that feels like a wink and nudge to the way that the end of a trilogy (before the reboot or requel, of course) needs to pull out all the stops to keep a fan on their toes. My head was spinning a bit, partly because of all the curves and twists, partly because Jones’s writing style can be steeped in more literary styles that I like but have a harder time parsing through for whatever reason. But it’s also very enjoyable and worth the parsing out.

And, of course, the horror references. I’m repeating myself a bit here as in each and every “Indian Lake” book there are so many references to slasher films and horror tales in general, and “The Angel of Indian Lake” keeps that tradition going. I like to think that I am more versed than the average horror fan in the genre, but man, Jones always puts me to shame while also filling me with awe, not only with the flat out reference points that Jade alludes to, but also with the story devices and character choices and moments that ALSO made references. But in this final entry to the trilogy, many of the references feel almost bittersweet as Jade has to face so many demons, be they supernatural beasties wreaking havoc in the town, or the trauma and despair that she has had to face over and over again, only to keep on fighting while not quite accepting that she, too, is worthy of the final girl title. Jones knows what he is doing with his genre choices, and Jade is a final girl inside and out, and even beyond what that generally means in the broader trope. It’s just so meaningful, how he ties it all together.

“The Angel of Indian Lake” is a gory and emotional final tale for Jade and the town of Proofrock. I don’t generally get choked up during slasher stories, but Stephen Graham Jones has put so much heart into this I was absolutely crying by the end. What an accomplishment this trilogy is.

Rating 9: A complex and multilayered end to a trilogy that is a Valentine to a sub-genre that isn’t known for complexity, “The Angel of Indian Lake” brings Jade Daniels full circle, and redefines what it means to be a ‘Final Girl’.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Angel of Indian Lake” isn’t included on many Goodreads lists yet, but it would fit in on “Slasher Fiction”.

Kate’s Review: “Worm”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Worm” by Edel Rodriguez

Publishing Info: Metropolitan Books, November 2023

Where Did I Get This Book: The library!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: From “America’s illustrator in chief” ( Fast Company ), a graphic memoir of a childhood in Cuba, coming to America on the Mariel boatlift, and a defense of democracy, here and there.

When Edel was nine, Fidel Castro announced his surprising decision to let 125,000 traitors of the revolution, or “worms,” leave the country. The faltering economy and Edel’s family’s vocal discomfort with government surveillance had made their daily lives on a farm outside Havana precarious, and they secretly planned to leave. But before that happened, a dozen soldiers confiscated their home and property and imprisoned them in a detention center near the port of Mariel, where they were held with dissidents and criminals before being marched to a flotilla that miraculously deposited them, overnight, in Florida.

Worm tells a story of a boyhood in the midst of the Cold War, a family’s displacement in exile, and their longing for those they left behind. It also recounts the coming-of-age of an artist and activist, who, witnessing American’s turn from democracy to extremism, struggles to differentiate his adoptive country from the dictatorship he fled. Confronting questions of patriotism and the liminal nature of belonging, Edel Rodriguez ultimately celebrates the immigrants, maligned and overlooked, who guard and invigorate American freedom.

Review: Every once in awhile my Mom will send me a link to an article through the New York Times that has a review of a book that she thinks that would interest me. More often than not I’ve already read it or it was at least on my radar, but sometimes she will send one my way that is totally novel. In this case it was “Worm: A Cuban American Odyssey” by Edel Rodriguez. Perhaps you know of Rodriguez as an artist, specifically the artist behind the viral and infamous Trump artwork that has been on the likes of Der Spiegel and Time Magazine. Rodriguez felt it important to call out Trump on his dangerous and totalitarian tendencies, something he recognized even during the 2016 Primaries when a Trump Presidency was seen as merely a fantasy (we all know how that went). Rodriguez knows this because his family fled Cuba in the 1980s, after his family was being watched, surveilled, and threatened by the Government. “Worm: A Cuban American Odyssey” is that story, as well as story about life in a totalitarian regime, and how even a country that seems filled with idealism can fall into that trap.

Rodriguez combines modern Cuban history, starting with the Cuban Revolution, and moves through it until the 80s, tracking his family’s experience living under Castro in the town of El Gabriel. His father was a photographer while his mother stayed at home, but joined up with the local CDR, a group that was made up of Cuban citizens that would essentially ‘keep an eye’ on the community for any anti-regime activities or sentiments. Edel and his sister grew up with a meager education, and with parents who were constantly worried about watching what they said or did, all while trying to keep their family alive under pretty poor conditions due to poverty and corruption. We follow Edel through various childhood anecdotes and experiences, from the mundane involving friends and family, to the disturbing (such as the time Edel contracted a parasite that went through his legs, and the local hospital didn’t have enough medicine to treat him). As times become more dire as Edel grows older, his family make the choice to leave when Fidel allowed anyone who wanted to leave to leave so long as they could find a boat (and so long as they weren’t killed in the process whether it be by the Government or their own communities, who saw them as traitors and ‘worms’). It’s a deeply harrowing and emotional memoir, and as someone who knows very little about the Cuban Revolution and had certain ideas about Cuban immigration in my mind, this was pretty educational and eye opening (little did I know that the Cuban Immigrant community has MANY reasons to leave, not just because they were Batista loyalists). It also tracks the story of what adjusting to America was like for the family, not only through the eyes of Edel, but also through the eyes of his parents, who came with nothing and had to find their way to provide for their children in a wholly new environment. His parents are so well depicted in all of their complexities, and Rodriguez also touches a bit on how the traumas of escaping this kind of life can spill over into a new life with new challenges.

But this isn’t only a memoir about escaping a totalitarian regime: it is also a warning about the rise of totalitarianism through the eyes of someone who lived it, and how romanticizing or ignoring it is so, so dangerous. Rodriguez doesn’t only take those who romanticize Castro’s Cuba to task, he also REALLY digs into the way that America is embracing their own totalitarian tendencies, as Trump became President and his stink has infected so many other people (or perhaps just let them let their own stink loose). The connections that he draws between the life his family fled and how it all has to start somewhere is bleak and really alarming, and the way he compares the lies of January 6th and the Unite the Right Rally and other far right rage and venom to the violence he saw back home is really, really stark. And we’d best pay attention.

And the artwork is just astounding. It’s visceral and surreal in some ways, but always knows how to cut to the bone. In mostly blacks, whites, greens, and reds, it has a unique and signature style that is reminiscent of Rodriguez’s political works, but which still feels very personal. There is a LOT of text in this book, it almost feels like more of a memoir with an artistic backdrop on each page, but it never feels overwhelming and is still very easy to read.

(source: Metropolitan Books)

“Worm” is a fantastic memoir with an artistic and emotional edge. It’s so important to learn history, especially from those who lived it, and to remember that just because things feel abstract or like they couldn’t happen in your own life, that there will always be people to tell you that you may be wrong. Edel Rodriguez is here to do that.

Rating 9: A harrowing and deeply personal memoir about fleeing totalitarianism, and the looming threat of it in a new home, “Worm” is a fantastic graphic memoir from an outspoken artist.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Worm” is included on the Goodreads lists “NPR’s Books We Love 2023: Favorite Comics and Graphic Novels”, and “Memoirs Published in Year: 2023”.

Serena’s Review: “Salt & Broom”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Salt & Broom” by Sharon Lynn Fisher

Publishing Info: 47North, December 2023

Where Did I Get this Book: Netgalley!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: A gifted healer unravels the mysteries of a cursed estate—and its enigmatic owner—in a witchy retelling of Jane Eyre .

“Salt and broom, make this room
Safe and tight, against the night.”

Trunks packed with potions and cures, Jane Aire sets out on a crisp, clear morning in October to face the greatest challenge of her sheltered girls’-school existence. A shadow lies over Thornfield Hall and its reclusive master, Edward Rochester. And he’s hired her only as a last resort. Jane stumbles again and again as she tries to establish a rapport with her prickly new employer, but he becomes the least of her worries as a mysterious force seems to work against her. The threats mount around both Jane and Rochester—who’s becoming more intriguing and appealing to her by the day. Jane begins to fear her herb healing and protective charms may not be enough to save the man she’s growing to love from a threat darker and more dangerous than either of them imagined.

Review: No, your memory is not failing you: Kate, not me, was the one to include this book in her Highlights post back in December! But this is a perfect example of the sort of book that has cross-over appeal for Kate and I. For one thing, we both love “Jane Eyre” and thusly any “Jane Eyre” retellings are automatically appealing to us both. From there, I imagine she looked at this one and saw “witchy cozy horror,” and I looked at it and saw “witchy cozy fantasy,” and in truth, it’s a little bit of both. Never fear, however, I didn’t poach this one from her! She confirmed that she didn’t have a full review planned, so I was in the clear!

“Jane Eyre” is a tough nut to crack as far as re-tellings go. I think both Jane and Mr. Rochester are fairly complicated characters in their own right, and their romance is by no means straight forward or easy. But I have to commend Fisher for the version she presents here! This book walks the perfect tight-rope of hitting the main story beats that one expects from a “Jane Eyre” story, while also completely re-imagining large chunks of the story to fit in a fantasy world where witches, ghosts, and fairies exist. It would be very easy for either side of this balance to shift and throw the entire book into disarray, but that’s not a concern here! Instead, the book confidently moves forward in the world its has created, trusting the reader to strike this balance as well. I was also impressed with the overall style and tone of the writing, as capturing the specific “voice” and manner of speaking can be a challenge when adapting older works like this. Again, this ability to capture this tone was all the more impressive since you had to pair this sort of “period piece” voice with all kinds of fantasy terms about witches and magic.

In particular, I really enjoyed the adaptations and liberties the author took with the original story. All of the main plot beats were hit (and even a few minor ones, the sort that will definitely please the fans!), but the author didn’t hold back from truly making this one her own. Several familiar characters are completely re-imagined, while others play roles that are relatively unchanged. Some fairly major plot lines are also changed, but in ways that still hold true to exploring the themes and love story of the original. This include the plot line regarding Mr. Rochester’s wife. Obviously, I don’t want to go into spoilers, but I was very impressed by how this was re-done! And, again, the magical elements tied into all of this in ways that were truly surprising! Going in, I had it in my mind that it would mostly be the same story but with Jane doing a bit of magic here and there. Nope! Major fantasy elements all over the place, but in the best ways!

I also really enjoyed this version of Jane and Rochester. Jane, especially, was a fantastic leading lady. This version captured the same spirit of independence and resolve that we see in the original, but the story also allowed her to explore themes regarding female friendships, motherhood, and family in ways that the original didn’t. Rochester was also excellent, capturing much of the same dark and broody motifs that we expect from this classic romantic hero. That said, I liked some of the updates we got to this version as the original had moments where he came off as a bit, well, jerkish. This Rochester is still reserved and mysterious, but also updated in small ways to appeal to modern romance readers. I especially loved all of the scenes where he and Jane team up to solve the magical mysteries surrounding them.

Overall, I really loved this book! It managed to take a beloved classic story and retain all that makes it great while also adding a fun fantasy spin to the proceedings. I’ll definitely be looking through this author’s back catalog to see what else she’s written and will keep any eye out for anything coming in the future! If you enjoy magical re-imaginings of classic stories, definitely check this one out!

Rating 9: Darkly romantic and mysterious, a perfect book for all “Jane Eyre” fans!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Salt & Broom” is on any relevant Goodreads lists yet, but it should be on Jane Eyre Retellings.

Serena’s Review: “A Feather So Black”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Feather So Black” by Lyra Selene

Publishing Info: Orbit, March 2024

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: In a kingdom where magic has been lost, Fia is a rare changeling, left behind by the wicked Fair Folk when they stole the High Queen’s daughter and retreated behind the locked gates of Tír na nÓg.

Most despise Fia’s fae blood. But the queen raises her as a daughter and trains her to be a spy. Meanwhile, the real princess Eala is bound to Tír na nÓg, cursed to become a swan by day and only returning to her true form at night.

When a hidden gate to the realm is discovered, Fia is tasked by the queen to retrieve the princess and break her curse. But she doesn’t go with her is prince Rogan, Fia’s dearest childhood friend—and Eala’s betrothed.

As they journey through the forests of the Folk, where magic winds through the roots of the trees and beauty can be a deadly illusion, Fia’s mission is complicated by her feelings for the prince…and her unexpected attraction to the dark-hearted fae lord holding Eala captive. Irian might be more monster than man, but he seems to understand Fia in a way no one ever has.

Soon, Fia begins to question the truth of her mission. But time is running out to break her sister’s curse. And unraveling the secrets of the past might destroy everything she has come to love.

Review: While Disney reigns supreme as far as fairytale movies go, for my sister and I, the collection of favorites wasn’t complete without including “Anastasia” and “The Swan Princess.” And, as far as the latter goes, the original fairytale itself has flown under the radar as far as fiction re-tellings go. I’m not sure I can even think of one off the top of my head? I feel like Mercedes Lackey might have done one at one point, but it’s definitely a lesser told story. All of that to say, I was incredibly excited when I discovered this book coming out this spring. Now, did it live up to admittedly high expectations?

Short answer, yes, yes it did! I loved almost everything about this book in fact! From the main character and her fierce, broken story, to the whimsical but dangerous Fae world that she explores, to the manner in which the story unfolds over an entire year, to the exemplary manner in which the author deals with the love triangle (proof that it’s possible!). On top of this all, the writing was confident and sure throughout, nicely balancing the vicious but beautiful nature of fairytales alongside the intricacies of depicting the complicated familial dynamics at play in Fia’s life. Telling a story that takes place over an entire year, with month-long breaks between trips to the Fae world is a complicated technique. It would be easy for the pace to languish between these trips or to feel as if time is not passing in a natural way. Instead, I was very impressed with the way the author balanced her more obviously exciting trips to the other world alongside the much greater period of time that Fia spends waiting back in the “real world.”

But this decision to draw out the story in this way over an entire year worked in more ways than just form. By giving the story this amount of time to breathe, Fia’s slow understanding about the truths regarding the people around her played out in a believable way. It’s always frustrating when main characters have grown up being told certain things their entire lives, trusting close family members or whomever, and then are told some alternate story by a relatively new source and easily throw off everything they knew before and all other feelings of loyalty or love that would be challenged. It’s just not believable. Instead, here, Fia’s journey is one of excruciating realizations about how she has been used by those around her and how her views of herself have been poisoned from the start.

On top of this, the use of this year-long approach to the story also allowed for the love triangle to play out in a believable way. Again, she didn’t just “get over” her feelings for the prince when she met some dark Fae guy in the other world. I feel like I’ve read that story a million times. No, instead a good chunk of the story is devoted to exploring the relationship between Fia and the prince, thoroughly exploring their complicated history, their wishes for the future, and the realities of their situation. On top of that, the reader can always look forward to the incredibly compelling and increasingly romantic scenes in the Fae world with the Fae lord. Here, too, Fia’s trust and understanding of this character grows naturally. No insta-love here! I will say, my one critique comes towards the end where Fia makes a few fairly questionable decisions and put her relationships with those around her at risk. But, while I was partly frustrated by this, it also was believable that Fia, with her complicated history of trust and deception, would be make some of these decisions. And even here, I really enjoyed the way this particular arc was resolved.

I also really liked the overall plot of the story. Yes, there are definite bits from the original “Swan Princess”/”Swan Lake” story. But this is also a wholly unique story. It was appropriately grim and dark, like all good fairytales are, had confusing curses at its heart all driven by a ticking clock by which they needed to be solved, and explored a complicated world and history between the humans and the Fae world. I was also incredibly surprised by some of the turns it took towards the end. I had a few ideas about a certain things that did play out the way I expected, but others were a complete shock! I can’t wait to read the next book in this series (though this one also concludes in a way that feels satisfying). Readers who enjoy fairytale fantasies should definitely check this one out!

Rating 9: A breath of fresh air in a crowded room of Fae fantasy stories! Dark, whimsical, and romantic, this book has it all!

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Feather So Black” isn’t on any relevant Goodreads lists yet, but it should be on Swan Lake Retellings.

Serena’s Review: “The Tainted Cup”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Tainted Cup” by Robert Jackson Bennett

Publishing Info: Del Rey, February 2024

Where Did I Get this Book: Edelweiss+

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: In Daretana’s most opulent mansion, a high Imperial officer lies dead—killed, to all appearances, when a tree spontaneously erupted from his body. Even in this canton at the borders of the Empire, where contagions abound and the blood of the Leviathans works strange magical changes, it’s a death at once terrifying and impossible.

Called in to investigate this mystery is Ana Dolabra, an investigator whose reputation for brilliance is matched only by her eccentricities.

At her side is her new assistant, Dinios Kol. Din is an engraver, magically altered to possess a perfect memory. His job is to observe and report, and act as his superior’s eyes and ears–quite literally, in this case, as among Ana’s quirks are her insistence on wearing a blindfold at all times, and her refusal to step outside the walls of her home.

Din is most perplexed by Ana’s ravenous appetite for information and her mind’s frenzied leaps—not to mention her cheerful disregard for propriety and the apparent joy she takes in scandalizing her young counterpart. Yet as the case unfolds and Ana makes one startling deduction after the next, he finds it hard to deny that she is, indeed, the Empire’s greatest detective.

As the two close in on a mastermind and uncover a scheme that threatens the safety of the Empire itself, Din realizes he’s barely begun to assemble the puzzle that is Ana Dolabra—and wonders how long he’ll be able to keep his own secrets safe from her piercing intellect.

Featuring an unforgettable Holmes-and-Watson style pairing, a gloriously labyrinthine plot, and a haunting and wholly original fantasy world, The Tainted Cup brilliantly reinvents the classic mystery tale.

Review: There were many reasons this book quickly ended up on my TBR list. For one thing, I really enjoyed Bennett’s “Divine Cities” trilogy when I read it years ago (I enjoyed those books so much that I’ve toyed around with the idea of trying to sneak a re-read in here on the blog). I also somehow never got around to reading his most recent series. So I was pleased to see this book coming out as it was a way to re-acquaint myself with a favorite author without having to commit to a series with a number of pre-existing books. But, almost as important as the author, I’m pretty much always interested in reading a book that is a play on Sherlock Holmes and Watson. And this one sure sounded like a unique take! Not only do you have the classic brilliant detective/assistant character dynamic, but somehow that is then superimposed on a fantasy world that is besieged by kaiju like creatures?? What an odd mix and also count me in!

Let’s start with the world-building first! I was impressed by how fleshed out this world was, and by the careful balance the author struck between the various aspects of the story. It would have been very easy for the entire plot and world to be sucked up by the grandiose nature of the Leviathons. Obviously, gigantic creatures that besiege a continent during certain seasons are an intriguing focal point for a story. However, I was impressed by the way these gigantic threats were held largely in the shadows, serving as a looming threat which inspired more dread than anything else. Used carefully in this manner, the book was then better able to focus on the kind of society and world that would be built up under these sorts of conditions. Not only do you have the balance of constant military action needing to mingle with civilian life, but the Leviathon bring extreme contagions that affect the environment. In many ways, it was these contagions that served as the greater point of horror throughout the story. Not only is the central murder gruesome (a tree bursting out from within a living body), but as the story unfolds, we see many examples of the ways that humanity has had to work to survive in a environment and ecological system that is actively adapting to kill them off.

For all the excellent fantasy elements that went into the world-building as I described above, this book is truly a mystery story at its core. You could take almost the entire plot, adjust the manners of death and a few other small details, and plop it down in any old real-world story and it would largely work as it stands. And, again, the fact that the mystery itself is not over-shadowed by these, at times literally, larger-than-life fantasy elements is proof of the tight control that Bennett has over all of the elements that make up this book. While the fantasy stuff was, well, fantastical, as the story unfolded, my investment was largely focused on these two main characters and the increasingly complicated mystery that they were slowly working through. There were all of the good red-herrings and misdirections that one looks for in a mystery novel, as well as the satisfying payoff when all is finally revealed.

The third point of success came down to our two main characters. The story is told from the perspective of Din, our “Watson-like” character, as he works with a brilliant, but eccentric investigator, an older woman named Ana. I think Bennett did a brilliant job with these two, perfectly honing in on many of the dynamics that make the “Sherlock/Watson” duo such time-tested favorite. Din is endearing and an approachable “everyman” type character. He is at times bewildered by his strange boss and her ways, but loyal and devoted to supporting her in their investigation. I also liked the hints of his own struggles and secrets that are slowly revealed over the course of the story. We also see the strengths that he brings to this team and that, while brilliant herself, Din has unique contributions that are crucial to their success. In this instance, he has a unique skill (pulled from some of the magic systems of the world) to essentially permanently memorize everything he sees. But, even here, not everything it as it seems.

For her part, Ana is an excellent character in that she is used effectively but sparingly. The risk is always to overplay a character like this, but Bennett wisely and carefully chose his scenes and moments during which to play up Ana’s strange, but brilliant, approaches to investigation. The author also nailed the perhaps predictable, but no less appreciated, moments where Ana effectively lays out all of the pieces of the puzzle as if they were oh, so obvious. While anyone who reads a mystery novel with a detective like this at its heart knows that these sorts of scenes are coming, these moments are somehow always just as satisfying as ever. Especially when the author has been sparing with the build up, as Bennett is here.

I really enjoyed this book! I could probably go on and on praising it, but I think we all get the idea. I’ll say perhaps that the pacing, especially in the first third of the book, was a bit on the slower side. But as that time is spent laying down the building blocks of this world and who both Din and Ana are as characters, I think the slower start is earned. If you enjoy mystery novels as well as unique fantasy settings, definitely give this one a shot!

Rating 9: Genre-blending at its finest, Bennet’s brilliant take on the Sherlock/Watson character duo is only one part of many that makes this creative fantasy novel a must-read!

Reader’s Advisory:

“The tainted Cup” can be found on a lot of generic Goodreads lists like this Can’t Wait Sci-Fi/Fantasy of 2024, but it should be on Sherlock Holmes Retellings and Reimaginings.

Blog Tour & Joint Review: “Bride”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Bride” by Ali Hazelwood

Publishing Info: Berkley, February 2023

Where Did We Get This Book: eARC from blog tour!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: Misery Lark, the only daughter of the most powerful Vampyre councilman of the Southwest, is an outcast—again. Her days of living in anonymity among the Humans are over: she has been called upon to uphold a historic peacekeeping alliance between the Vampyres and their mortal enemies, the Weres, and she sees little choice but to surrender herself in the exchange—again…

Weres are ruthless and unpredictable, and their Alpha, Lowe Moreland, is no exception. He rules his pack with absolute authority, but not without justice. And, unlike the Vampyre Council, not without feeling. It’s clear from the way he tracks Misery’s every movement that he doesn’t trust her. If only he knew how right he was….

Because Misery has her own reasons to agree to this marriage of convenience, reasons that have nothing to do with politics or alliances, and everything to do with the only thing she’s ever cared about. And she is willing to do whatever it takes to get back what’s hers, even if it means a life alone in Were territory…alone with the wolf.

Serena’s Thoughts

I was super excited when I saw this book pop up! Not only am I always on the look out for the next (finally!) great urban fantasy story, but I was intrigued to see Ali Hazelwood venturing into paranormal romance after releasing several contemporary romances over the last few years. I’ve read a few of them and really enjoyed them, but, still, contemporary books are never my real preference. So this was a best of both worlds situation!

And, overall, I found myself really pleased with this one! Frankly, at this point it’s just a relief to read a book that is told from only one perspective (I feel like recently all I’ve read are books with 2, 3, or more POVs). And on top of that, Misery is a fantastic leading character. She has a strong voice, both sympathetic and hilarious, and an interesting character arc. Her story explored the abuses that can be served on children by parents, as well as the prejudices that can rule groups of people. I also enjoyed that her motivation throughout this book was centered around her love and devotion to her best friend/adopted sister. Yes, the romance is the main relationship, but as far as Misery’s decisions, they were largely focused on this female friendship. It was a great balance to the love story and really rounded out the text; too often I feel that romances rely so heavily on their central romance that the characters don’t feel like people who have had any other relationships in their lives. Here, Misery is not only falling in love, but she’s also missing her friend and trying to understand her shifting relationship with her brother.

But, of course, this is a romance, and I really loved that as well! I feel like it would have been very easy for Lowe’s character to go very wrong. Indeed, there were several times where the character walked right up to the edge of a trope and I was halfway through an eye roll before Hazelwood neatly sidestepped the entire issue. I also really liked the brief little passages at the headings of the chapters that gave us glimpses into Lowe’s mindset. Honestly, more authors should do this! It gave us some insights into the other romantic partner, but saved us from what would have been a redundant second perspective.

Kate laughed at me for this next part, but somehow, even as a reader of urban fantasy/paranormal romances/fan fiction, I’d missed out on a certain, um, aspect of werewolf romances stories that apparently does pop up fairly often. That said, I’m super curious to see how readers deal with this aspect of the book! Hazelwood is an author who has previously appealed to largely normie readers, and this…is not normie! All of that to say, this book is definitely on the spicy side, so readers should take that into account when they pick it up!

Overall, I really enjoyed this! There were a few moments towards the end that did fall into a few romance pitfalls, which knocked it down from a 10, but it was still a highly enjoyable read!

Kate’s Thoughts

At this point I have read all of Ali Hazelwood’s romance novels, and have been a huge fan of hers since I got “The Love Hypothesis” on NetGalley based on the cover alone. I really love her characters, I love her banter, and I love how she can bring in some fun science-y topics to her contemporary romance (or at the very least geeky; “Check and Mate” wasn’t really science-y as I don’t consider chess STEM). But I, like Serena, was VERY intrigued by the idea of her taking on a paranormal romance! I’ve not read many of those in my life (though I have read a LOT of “Buffy” fanfic), so the idea of her doing it was out there. But I also trusted her to do something with it that I would like, and yep, she didn’t disappoint. “Bride” was just as enjoyable as her other books. Sub genre jumps come naturally to her I guess!

I’m probably going to kind of echo a lot of what Serena said, so to avoid just a repeat of her thoughts I will try and focus on some other aspects of this book that I noticed. For one, as someone who does love some interesting and expansive monster lore in my horror and dark fantasy reads, I very much enjoyed the social structure and world building Hazelwood had for the Vampyres and the Weres in this book. The long feuding factions held together by tentative but fragile tolerance is a tried and true trope, but I thought it was very clever to throw in how alliances with humans can so easily throw wrenches into these complicated relationships, and how corruption in leadership can make things that much worse. Having Misery and Lowe be somewhat reluctant bridge builders through a marriage, with their own places in their societies being tenuous and somewhat challenged, made for higher stakes than a mere forced proximity romance.

And like Serena I really liked Misery as a main character. She is definitely funny and scrappy, but she is also someone who has NEVER felt like she fits in outside of her relationship with her surrogate sister, due to never really being raised with vampyres but also not being human. It’s a great way to tap into the ‘not like other girls’ trope while actually making it feel genuine and totally understandable in this specific instance, and seeing her try to adjust to yet another group where she doesn’t really belong makes for an interesting growth arc for her. Making connections to others obviously doesn’t come easy, so having her connect with Lowe, and his younger sister Ana, led to some very lovely moments of a protagonist finding connection when she thought she could only have it with one person. And that made the slow burn romance between her and Lowe that much more satisfying for my reading experience.

“Bride” is another great romance from Ali Hazelwood! She is really showing her prowess as a chameleon in the romance genre, and I love to see it and hope she keeps on surprising me!

Serena’s Rating 9: Hazelwood does it again, this time mastering the paranormal romance genre as easily as she did contemporary! She makes it look easy!

Kate’s Rating 9: A charming romance, some well done vampire and werewolf lore, and some slow burn steamy goodness makes for a very fun and enjoyable new romance from Ali Hazelwood!

Reader’s Advisory

“Bride” is on this Goodreads list: Upcoming Romantasy Releases 2024

Serena’s Review: “The Butcher of the Forest”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Butcher of the Forest” by Premee Mohamed

Publishing Info: Tor, February 2024

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: A world-weary woman races against the clock to rescue the children of a wrathful tyrant from a dangerous, otherworldly forest.

At the northern edge of a land ruled by a monstrous, foreign tyrant lies the wild forest known as the Elmever. The villagers know better than to let their children go near—once someone goes in, they never come back out.

No one knows the strange and terrifying traps of the Elmever better than Veris Thorn, the only person to ever rescue a child from the forest many years ago. When the Tyrant’s two young children go missing, Veris is commanded to enter the forest once more and bring them home safe. If Veris fails, the Tyrant will kill her; if she remains in the forest for longer than a day, she will be trapped forevermore.

So Veris will travel deep into the Elmever to face traps, riddles, and monsters at the behest of another monster. One misstep will cost everything.

Review: I’m a sucker for “deep, dark woods” books. I see that pop up in a book summary and you’re already halfway to me requesting the book immediately! Add on top of that a creepy, fairytale-like cover, an adult leading lady, and the mention of “traps, riddles, and monsters,” and yeah, I didn’t hesitate to slot this one down for review. And man, it was both everything I expected and wanted, and yet somehow also much more.

There was so much that I loved about this book that I don’t even know where to start! I will say, this is a novella, so readers are plopped down fairly quickly into this world and left to piece together an understanding of its politics and dangers fairly quickly. To accomplish this, the book relies on fantasy readers’ knowledge of some of the tropes commonly found in this type of book: a deep, dark cursed forest that everyone know not to enter; a cruel, tyrannical lord who is as brutal as he is unpredictable; and, of course, a leading character with a particular set of skills and a mysterious past. But while all of these elements are familiar, the fantastic skill of the author deploying them raised it all to a new level, allowing me to not only easily orient myself but to also find myself quickly invested in Elmever’s story.

She’s the exact sort of character I love: brave, but not foolhardy; sad and worn down by a cruel world, but unwilling to forfeit all hope; willing to take action, but also capable of dealing with the blows dealt to her. I also loved the slow reveal of the mysteries in her past, with the final clincher coming late in the story in a way that completely took me by surprise. Not so much what the reveal was itself, but how it played into the current events unfolding on the page.

This book is also incredibly dark and would comfortably fit under the “horror” umbrella. And while “horror” isn’t my preferred genre, I do like seeing aspects of the genre pop up in books like this. There’s nothing more disappointing than a fantasy book with a cursed forest that turns out to be fairly…tame. This is not that. Scene after scene buffets the reader with gruesome creatures, terrible choices, and the inevitable feeling that there’s no way Elmever can possibly keep this up much longer. The stakes always feel high, and by the midpoint of the book, I was frantically reading at a pace that could almost be described as “frenzied.” And on top of these horror elements, this book is dark in the sense that it tackles some very tragic themes. These characters have not had easy lives, and no one is safe. I was honestly surprised by just how willing the author was to fully go there with some of these scenes.

It’s hard to say I “enjoyed” this book per se, given how tragic and tense it was for much of the time. But I did love it and was incredibly impressed throughout the story. For such a short book, it packs a powerful punch. I never felt like a scene was wasted, unnecessary or not fully explored. Instead, the book felt succinct, sharp, and incredibly poignant at times. I highly recommend this one to readers who enjoy dark fantasy novels and are looking for a short, satisfying read.

Rating 9: Heart-breaking and fear-striking, this book will catch you up in its claws and wring you out, all in the best possible way!

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Butcher and the Forest” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Animal Sculls on Cover and Cottagegore

Book Club Review: “Earthdivers (Vol. 1): Kill Columbus”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. Our current theme is Centuries, where we were given a random century and had to pick a book based during that time period.  For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club!

Book: “Earthdivers (Vol.1): Kill Columbus” by Stephen Graham Jones & Davide Gianfelice (Ill.).

Publishing Info: IDW Publishing, September 2023

Where Did We Get This Book: We both received an ARC at ALAAC23.

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Century: 22nd and Beyond (aka The Future)

Book Description: The New York Times–bestselling author of The Only Good Indians and My Heart Is a Chainsaw makes his comics debut with this time-hopping horror thriller about far-future Indigenous outcasts on a mission to kill Christopher Columbus.

The year is 2112, and it’s the apocalypse exactly as rivers receding, oceans rising, civilization crumbling. Humanity has given up hope, except for a group of Indigenous outcasts who have discovered a time travel portal in a cave in the desert and figured out where everything took a turn for the America.

Convinced that the only way to save the world is to rewrite its past, they send one of their own—a reluctant linguist named Tad—on a bloody, one-way mission to 1492 to kill Christopher Columbus before he reaches the so-called New World. But there are steep costs to disrupting the timeline, and taking down an icon isn’t an easy task for an academic with no tactical training and only a wavering moral compass to guide him. As the horror of the task ahead unfolds and Tad’s commitment is tested, his actions could trigger a devastating new fate for his friends and the future.

Join Stephen Graham Jones and artist Davide Gianfelice for Earthdivers, Vol. 1, the beginning of an unforgettable ongoing sci-fi slasher spanning centuries of America’s Colonial past to explore the staggering forces of history and the individual choices we make to survive it.

Kate’s Thoughts

Perhaps we are being a bit brazen here, doing yet another Book Club review of books that we have already read and reviewed previously, especially given that we JUST DID IT last month. But hey, it all depends on the theme that we are assigned, and when I was given “The 22nd Century and Beyond” for our newest “Centuries” theme, and we only had a few weeks time WITH THE HOLIDAYS coming up, my mind went immediately to the graphic novel “Earthdivers: Kill Columbus” by Stephen Graham Jones. After all, I really liked it, it would be a faster read, and since I’m not as versed in Sci-Fi it was the first futuristic story I could think of. It was a gamble, as Book Club doesn’t tend to go to very violent or scary works, but ultimately I feel like it was a gamble that paid off, because “Earthdivers: Kill Columbus” was just as enjoyable the second time around, and fostered a lot of good conversation.

My opinion from my previous review hasn’t changed too much, given that I just read it in the past few months, but something I will say about reading it the second time was how much more I appreciated the complexity of Jones’s overall arc (it probably helps that I had just read the second volume thanks to NetGalley right before diving in; look for that in February!). It’s definitely a lot of jumping around, but I found that I really appreciated the way that Jones set up the Columbus storyline and how he executed it, and the way that he took on pretty tried and true time travel tropes and subverted them while also drawing out the most from them.

All in all it was a great read for Book Club and a great conversation starter! Stephen Graham Jones continues to do creative and bold things with his writing.

Serena’s Thoughts

I don’t really read graphic novels other than when they come up for bookclub. And I honestly don’t know why, because I always enjoy them when I do! And this one was the same! True, it was a bit of whiplash given that the last graphic novel was a very cozy, middle grade fantasy story. And this…was not that. We have one bookclub member in particular who doesn’t read dark, graphic stories and we all were kind of watching her carefully over some of the things depicted in this one! That said, I didn’t think any of it was gratuitous, but instead focused on the very high stakes of the situations portrayed.

That said, I did struggle with this book a bit in the beginning. As Kate has read the second book, she’s better able to gauge how the overall story progresses. But as a reader just starting out with this one, there were some initial basic premise things in the beginning of this one that left me wondering. I wasn’t quite sure about the basic cause/effect that was set up for the main action of the story, for one thing. That said, as I continued to read, it was easy enough to get caught up in the action and not worry too much about some of these questions. I also really liked some of the greater points that the book was getting at towards the end. It could have been easy to write a fairly simplistic version of this story. Instead, the author doesn’t shy away from the repercussions of the choices these characters are making.

As its a time travel story, it was also a bit hard to follow at times. There were points in the middle of the book that I truly wasn’t sure whether or not I was missing something. But again, as long as I just kept with it, soon enough I was able to re-center myself in the goings on.

Kate’s Rating 9: Still a great time travel commentary with an anti-Colonial twist. This re-read made me appreciate the complexity more.

Serena’s Rating 8: A bit confusing at times and definitely the start to a larger series, but I still really enjoyed this one!

Book Club Questions

  1. What did you think of the magical/sci-fi system in this story with the time traveling cave? How does it compare to other time travel tales you are familiar with?
  2. Do you believe that the one key to fixing the future is is stopping the Discovery of America by Columbus as hypothesized by Yellow Kid? Why or why not?
  3. Tad isn’t the only person to go through the cave in this story, though we have yet to see where each of them are going. Of the other travelers (Emily, the posse looking for the missing children), whose story would you want to see?
  4. What did you think of the outcome of killing Columbus? What did you think of the portrayal of Columbus and his crew as a whole?
  5. If you could travel to one moment of history to change something in the past, what would it be? Or would you do it at all?

Reader’s Advisory

“Earthdivers (Vol. 1): Kill Columbus” is on the Goodreads list “Comic Book Club Recommendations”.

Next Book Club Pick: “An Extraordinary Union” by Alyssa Cole