This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Natural Selection” by Clare Edge
Publishing Info: Delacorte Press, August 2026
Where Did I Get This Book: The library!
Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound
Book Description: Three girls bond in unsettling ways when a grizzly starts picking off known abusers in their secluded mountain town in this darkly funny, deeply feminist novel for fans of books like The Honeys and Wilder Girls.
When it comes to boys and bears, always choose the bear. The girls of Riverside are raised to grin and bear it. Until three of them can’t anymore.
Megan Lawless (aka Outlaw): Riverside born and raised. Lettered in volleyball, basketball, and track. HATES Kevin Johnson, but tolerates him for her best friend, Megan.
Megan Deloria: Outlaw’s ride or die. Riverside royalty and soon to be valedictorian. Shoo-in for the homecoming crown alongside her boyfriend, Kevin.
Meghan Bach (aka Bee): Moved to Riverside last year. Still the “new girl.” Pulls tarot cards daily. Just wants to forget what happened last summer at that party with Kevin.
And then there’s Kevin Johnson: Riverside’s Golden Boy. Only scared of two things—the dark and bears. Soon, he’ll be scared of three more. Because Megan, Megan, and Meghan are done with Kevin, and they’re about to teach everyone in their tiny rural town the new natural order: Predator, meet prey.
Review: I have always really liked bears. I just find them to be fun and interesting creatures, though of course they are also quite intimidating for obvious reasons. I’ve been lucky enough to see black bears in the wild here in my part of the country, usually in the North Woods of Minnesota and Wisconsin, and I was THIS CLOSE to seeing a brown bear from a safe distance in Alaska (but I arrived to the scene JUST after it had retreated back into the woods, DOGGONE IT!). And I also really like stories about girls taking revenge on their abusers. So when I read about “Natural Selection” by Clare Edge, a YA thriller about three teenage girls who try to get revenge on a boy who hurt all of them, only for him to be eaten by a bear…. and then a bear to keep eating predatory men and boys… Well, it was obvious I had to read it.
In terms of a thriller, I thought that there was definitely a good deal of suspense about the predatory guys being killed by a bear or bears, and the question as to how much actual power Megan, Outlaw, and Bee had over the situation, whether it be because of the magic and witchy stuff that Bee dabbles in, or because of things that they are maybe hiding from each other. I kind of had a feeling about where the story was going pretty early on, but I will admit that the big reveal had a few components that caught me by surprise, and generally in a good way. I also liked having the three perspective points of Megan, Outlaw, and Bee, as they all had different and distinct points of view, while also all bringing different insights into the story. Sometimes I felt that the girls could fall into their stereotypes a little bit (Outlaw is the headstrong jock, Megan is the perfect girl next door, Bee is the weird new girl), but I did like them all and found them interesting. I especially liked the budding romance between Outlaw and Bee.
The things that worked best for me, though, were the themes of misogyny, patriarchy, small towns and their darker sides, and the way that women are silenced and shamed for the bad behavior of men. It may be a little on the nose for Edge to make this a book about literal bears attacking predatory men a couple years after the viral ‘man vs bear’ debate, but I was fine with it because this book doesn’t hold back its feminine rage. Part of me was like ‘okay, well this is a YA book so Kevin being this obnoxious and obviously bad is just par for the course for this age demographic’, but then I thought about it more and decided that it probably wasn’t too far off, with young men being exposed to manosphere bullshit online more and more, and horrifying stories like the Cornell 7 popping up in the news on a semi regular basis. Clare creates a community that not only looks the other way to the bad behavior of its young men, it’s also a community that is far more interested in not only shaming women, but making choices and an environment that makes it all the easier to serve them up on a platter. It’s horrifying and upsetting, but it isn’t terribly uncommon.
“Natural Instinct” is an enjoyable YA thriller that I found entertaining and cathartic. I will definitely have to keep up with whatever Clare Edge does next.
Rating 7: This enjoyable thriller tackles misogyny, sexual violence, and women trying to fight back in a community that doesn’t feel the need to protect them.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Natura Selection” is included on the Goodreads list “Queer Books Set in Montana”.