This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “What Happened to Those Girls” by Carlyn Greenwald
Publishing Info: Sourcebooks Fire, June 2026
Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from the publisher
Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound
Book Description: Pretty Little Liars meets The Blair Witch Project in this harrowing thriller from the author of Murder Land, brimming with betrayal, unsettling town secrets, and a killer lurking in the woods.
Emma knows her friends all lie to her. And everyone knows Emma is the outcast of their group. She’s usually fine with that, until her friends go on a camping trip that she planned…without her. The next morning, she wakes up to the news that all three of them died at the campsite.
When Emma starts receiving unnerving videos of the girls the night they died from an anonymous source, it becomes clear their deaths weren’t an accident. And if this becomes a murder case, Emma will be suspect number one. Because while everyone knows she had been excluded from the plans, what they don’t know is that she went to the campsite that night after all, and someone has proof.
Emma teams up with Beck, one of the victims’ sisters, to return to the woods and figure out what really happened the night her friends died, uncover who is behind the mysterious videos she is receiving, and make sure that nobody can pin their murders on her. But stranded in an eerie town that doesn’t welcome outsiders with a murderer on their heels, Emma and Beck just might be next…
Review: Thank you to Sourcebooks for sending me an eARC of this novel!
While Summer is probably my least favorite season (it’s just too hot, guys), I do like a nice scary story that is set in a time that just has Summer vibes. I also love a weird and spooky forest thriller, especially when there are perhaps supernatural things afoot. So “What Happened to Those Girls?” by Carlyn Greenwald was absolutely a book that I was totally on board with. A story were an odd one out girl is left out of her friend group on a camping trip and is hurt and angry, only for her friends to be murdered on said trip, and then being pulled into the mystery of what happened to them is already golden. But then you tell me that there is maybe a witch in the woods responsible?

The main plot just feels like it was written with me in mind. It’s pretty straight forward: Emma is the outsider in her friend group of Paisley, Opal, and Harlow, never really fitting in even though she is constantly trying. Her friends ditch her on a camping trip that was her idea, but then they ended up murdered and Emma is pulled into trying to figure out what happened to them. Not only do we have a mysterious murder mystery and a spooky woods, we also have a witch urban legend that some people believe is the cause of the mysterious deaths in the state park. We all know how much I love a witch story, and any story that sounds a bit like “The Blair Witch Project” at its heart is going to appeal. And overall I did enjoy this mystery with a spooky undercurrent. Greenwald balances the thriller elements with the ‘what if it’s a witch tho?’ elements really well, and I enjoyed seeing Emma and Beck, the older sister of one of the victims, Paisley, go into the woods looking for answers after Emma starts getting weird and creepy text messages from a mysterious sender. It’s suspenseful and well plotted, and while I kind of figured out a lot of the reveals and solutions pretty early on, the journey was well done enough that I didn’t mind and I enjoyed the ride. I also love a creepy wood setting and this book delivers that and then some.
But what really struck me most in this book was Emma as a main character. Emma is an engaging and easy to root for narrator from the very start, as I’m sure there have been PLENTY of people who have felt like the odd one out in social groups and friendships, especially in high school. But what made her even more interesting is that she is autistic, which brings in even more challenges for her when it comes to her friend group because she never QUITE clicks with them due to their inability to fully understand her. She is the kind of autistic representation that we don’t see as much in literature and other kinds of media. For one, she is a girl (as autistic woman characters in media lately I can count on one hand, the most recent being Quinni from “Heartbreak High” and Mel King on “The Pitt”). And two, her traits aren’t the stereotypical cold and savant-like that is so often seen to portray autistic people (though both Quinni and Mel also buck this; maybe because they are women? I’ll have to ponder this), as she definitely feels things incredibly deeply and is more inclined to anxiety and a lack of social graces as opposed to robotic indifference. I found Emma to be so incredibly relatable and nuanced (as someone who herself is on a wait list to be evaluated for autism), I just loved her from the jump. I also loved her relationship with Beck, as they are not only united to solve the mystery of what happened to Paisley, Opal, and Harlow, Beck also sees Emma for who she is and holds very little judgement or contempt for her. Any obvious relationship bumps other authors may have taken with these two kinds of characters are not taken here, and I found it refreshing.
“What Happened To Those Girls?” is a really entertaining YA thriller. It’s a great summer mystery and I definitely recommend getting it for any summer reading you are looking for.
Rating 8: A propulsive mystery with some spooky undertones, not only is “What Happened to Those Girls?” a good YA thriller, it’s some of the best autistm representation I’ve seen in a book this year.
Reader’s Advisory:
“What Happened to Those Girls?” is included on the Goodreads lists “Neurodivergent YA Novels”, and “Queer Horror”.



















