This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “Mortal Things” by Marie Lu
Publishing Info: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, October 2026
Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!
Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound
Book Description: Rose despises Raven, the god of Death. His mysterious commands. His mercurial moods. His closed heart. But most of all, she loathes that she was forced to become his Harbinger, a human mercenary tasked to fulfil their god’s every want and whim. Still, she would do it again, because being a Harbinger is the only thing keeping her best friend alive.
When a murder rocks the world of the gods, Rose is suddenly thrust into the immortal realm’s spotlight as Raven’s heir. This is her chance to free her friend once and for all. But in order for her to ascend, she must first prove herself to the other gods—and the one person standing in her way is a fellow Harbinger.
Étienne Beauchard is notorious for his sly wit and charming good looks. Rose can’t stand that he is the one assigned to test her abilities, but as their initial hostility evolves into an intense attraction, they find that the gods’ secrets go deeper than they ever expected. Something is wrong in the immortal world, something that threatens to break their bond and engulf them all in war.
As Rose and Étienne fight to uncover the truth and trust each other with their hearts, they realize that everything hinges on the same How far would you go to save the person you love?
Review: Unfortunately, I’m starting to come to the conclusion that Marie Lu’s books might just not be for me. I really enjoyed her original YA trilogy, and I even met her once at an ALA conference, and she was wonderful to talk with. However, I’ve now read several of her other books, and none of them have quite hit the way I’d like them to, and such was the case here again.
My main takeaway when I turned the last page on this book was an overwhelming sense of “fine-ness.” There was nothing offensive about it, it didn’t lack in technical skill, the story had its moments…but there also wasn’t anything that would make me ever think about it again. Everything we see here is familiar in one way or another. Gods toying with mortals and using them in complex political games. A chosen one-type main character who “defies” the gods. And, of course, the enemies/rivals romantic subplot. But on each of these counts, Lu didn’t add anything to make her version of these tropes stand out.
The world-building had its moments of interest, and when the world was first introduced, I was intrigued. But the story quickly introduced so many plot holes that I immediately was drawn out of the story. For such powerful gods, we never really see them do anything. And the system for how they become gods quickly becomes incoherent the moment you think about it too hard. Further, the way that our main character ends up in the position she does is also highly questionable. Wouldn’t this happen all of the time in this system?
As for our main character, again, there were moments that I liked from her. The flashbacks to her time as a mere mortal and the friendship that set her on her current trajectory were interesting. But as the story continued, it became more and more apparent that I was simply going to be told everything I needed to know both about our main character and about the relationships that are important to her. Again and again, Lu defaulted into a telling style of writing rather than showing, leaving me to begin questioning whether our main character had really shown anything that we were being told she was capable of.
As for the romance, there were moments that I liked here, especially the introduction of these two and their original dynamic. But again, the contrived nature of the plot that puts them at odds did very little to add anything to this relationship. Instead, it took anything that might have felt original about them and watered it down with overly familiar interactions. By the end, I couldn’t tell you what uniquely drew either of these characters to the other. Like everything in this book, they were interested in each other because that’s what the story needed.
Underwhelming, that’s my main takeaway. By the time I got to the end of this book, half of my mind was already thinking ahead to what I was going to read next. I didn’t hate this one by any means; I simply didn’t care. That said, I have to now assume that some of this disconnect is simply on my side. I know that Lu remains a very popular author for many fans, so if you’ve enjoyed many of her books in the past, I’m sure this one will also be up your alley. But if you’re on the fence, there are perhaps more original and interesting books to pick up this fall.
Rating 7: “Inoffensive” is the word that comes to mind. There were moments where I felt like this could have been something special, but those quickly sunk back beneath the wave of overly familiar story beats that made up most of this book.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Mortal Things” can be found on this Goodreads list: 2026 – Paranormal Romance (Standalones and 1st in Series).
