This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “The Never List” by Jade Presley
Publishing Info: Red Tower Books, April 2025
Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from publicist!
Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound
Book Description: Threatened by invaders, the kingdom of Lumathyst is on the verge of chaos, and no one can stop it. Unless the four immortal god-princes find their fated mate―and safeguard the throne―Lumathyst will fall.
Five women have tried. Five have failed. And tonight in the royal city, the princes need to find their Chosen and hope she can survive the transformation that will make her immortal.
Only Rylee Gray wasn’t supposed to be here. She snuck in for her own dark reasons―and now they claim they’ve found their perfect match. Her. Of course, they have no idea she’s concealing a secret big enough to damn them all.
The four princes have no choice. They’ll use every delectably wicked skill they have to make Rylee fall for all of them…or watch their kingdom collapse.
Review: So, I’ll be honest, I’m not really a fan of “Why Choose” romances. I usually struggle with them both on a personal preference side of things (I’m a monogamy gal myself) and on a practical level (I think it’s very difficult to write a number of romantic interests who all are equally developed and interesting). But I never want to write off a trope altogether. Love triangles are also not my thing, but I can think of a handful of books that used this trope that I very much enjoyed! So all of that to say, I was happy to check out this book when I was offered an ARC for review! Hope lives eternal!
I’m going to try to review this both from my own subjective take and from a more objective angle, as, again, those who love “why choose” romances are going to have a totally different experience of that aspect of this book than I did. So to start with the obvious positives, this book was incredibly fast moving! Things get started right away and never really let up! Probably not surprising when you have the primary plot to get through, plus the introduction of an entire cast of characters, all who need to be developed enough to serve as romantic interests! While I think the balance was off between the spice and the plot, I will say that what we do get of the trials was interesting and fun to follow.
Our main character, Rylee, was also easy to root for throughout. Between these flare-ups of fun action scenes and the fast moving pace, at the best points in my reading experience, this book reminded me of my experiences reading Armentrout’s books: that is, they’re fun in that “kind of stupid, turn your brain off” sort of way. But still fun!
However, as I mentioned above, this book definitely struggles finding the correct balance between the smut scenes and the plot itself. There were often large jumps in time between scenes, and between that the rather thin descriptions that make up the actual plot elements themselves, it sometimes felt like we were just jumping from one spicy scene to the next. Nothing wrong with some spice, but I never want to pick up a book and feel like that makes up over 50% of the book, and this one felt over that even at times!
I also struggled with the type of tropes used here. I went on a bit of a rant about mix and matching romance tropes and where that can go wrong in another review recently. And I think here we see another example of that. On one hand, you have the “why choose” trope where the FMC ends up in a relationship with numerous love interests. And on the other hand, you have “fated mates,” which is, by definition, tied up in exclusivity and the rarity of the connection between one individual and another. Trying to mix the two waters down the appeal of both, in my opinion. Not to mention, I just don’t think the core fans of either of these tropes are also often huge fans of the other! Like I said, there’s an inherent contradiction between these tropes’ approach to romance, one that would like carry over to readers’ preferences. All of this to say, I’m not sure this book really pulled this off either. The fated mates trope, especially, felt like it was missing the mark of what readers may expect from that sort of romance.
Overall, this was an ok read. I don’t think I’m the primary audience for this one, so I can’t speak to strongly for how fans of “why choose” romances will react. I suspect well! The book is a fast, fun read, so if you’re on board for the tropes at its heart, you’ll probably like it. That said, there’s a pretty stark imbalance between the plot and the spice, so readers should go in aware of that fact.
Rating 7: “Why choose” romance readers will likely really enjoy this! I’m not sure it will speak to “fated mates” fans in quite the same way.
Reader’s Advisory:
“The Never List” can be found on this Goodreads list: April 2025 Most Anticipated Romance Releases.
The Library Ladies 
Thank you for such an honest and well-balanced review! I really appreciate how you approached The Never List both from your personal preferences and with an objective lens for readers who enjoy “why choose” romances. Your comparison to Armentrout’s style—fun, fast-paced, and easy to sink into—definitely caught my attention. I’m intrigued by the premise and the worldbuilding setup, especially the idea of immortal god-princes and trials, but I totally see how blending “fated mates” with “why choose” could feel thematically mismatched.
Your thoughts on the plot-to-spice ratio were also super helpful—sometimes that balance makes or breaks a read. Still, it sounds like a fun escape read for the right audience. Thanks again for your thoughtful review and for giving ARC readers a clear idea of what to expect!
LikeLike