Kate’s Review: “The Buffalo Hunter Hunter”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Buffalo Hunter Hunter” by Stephen Graham Jones

Publishing Info: Saga Press, March 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from NetGalley.

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: A chilling historical horror novel set in the American west in 1912 following a Lutheran priest who transcribes the life of a vampire who haunts the fields of the Blackfeet reservation looking for justice.

A diary, written in 1912 by a Lutheran pastor is discovered within a wall. What it unveils is a slow massacre, a chain of events that go back to 217 Blackfeet dead in the snow. Told in transcribed interviews by a Blackfeet named Good Stab, who shares the narrative of his peculiar life over a series of confessional visits. This is an American Indian revenge story written by one of the new masters of horror, Stephen Graham Jones.

Review: Thank you to NetGalley for sending me an eARC of this novel!

The time has finally come! We have another horror novel from Stephen Graham Jones! Jones is one of my favorite authors and any of his works are automatically most anticipated on my reading list at any given time, and this time we have “The Buffalo Hunter Hunter”. Jones had tackled slasher stories, folk horror, meta commentary, werewolves, and many more, but this time he’s once again doing something new: he is taking on a historical fiction western for this tale of terror. Oh, and also vampires. I may not be as big of a western gal, but vampires? OH YES THAT IS VERY MUCH MY JAM. And with Jones at the helm I had really, really high hopes. And once again, they were basically met because Jones is a master of the genre.

First, the structure. This is an epistolary horror/historical fiction/western novel, which is a hefty endeavor, but Jones tackles it with ease. We have a few perspectives, most of which are diary entries of a Lutheran Pastor named Arthur Beaucarne, or transcripts of a ‘confession’ by a mysterious Blackfoot named Good Stab who claims to be a vampire. It’s a slow burn at first, as we find out how Good Stab was turned into a vampire, as well as his quest for vengeance against United States soldiers for the pain and suffering that it brought down upon the Blackfoot people, the community that he was from in life. It’s a bit of a mix of reliable vs unreliable with these two men as they cobble this story together, and the epistolary style makes for a more impactful device as revelations come into clarity.

Next, I want to talk about the vampire mythos in this book. I really loved what Jones did with the world building here, as not only does it have some classic vampire elements, with blood sucking, sun sensitivity, immortality, and a descent into more feral impulses when taking the vengeance that is owed. But one of the things that stood out that made this feel more unique was that Good Stab, when trying to feed, will take on the elements of whatever creature he is feeding upon. When he, in desperation, drinks from a buffalo for example he proceeds to grow two black horns in his head. I thought that was so creative and it made the vampire themes stand out.

But what really stands out is how incredibly in depth and unflinching this story is when it comes to the manifest destiny and western expansion era of the United States, and the genocidal violence that came with it when it came to the Indigenous People across the nations. When we are learning about this time period as children in this country, in general, there are a lot of framings of heroism, grit, and steadfast ambition that built this nation from sea to shining sea. I know that when I was in grade school we learned this with SOME sprinkles of the violence against Indigenous populations (in Minnesota at my prep school we did focus on the U.S.-Dakota War of 1862 in sixth grade for a unit, but even then it was pretty whitewashed), but overall it was more ‘woo, Oregon Trail, pioneers!’ at the heart of it. This book forces the reader to confront the horrendous violence that the United States military and government perpetrated against Indigenous populations, with and anchor being the Marias Massacre and the trauma and loss Good Stab endured as a member of the Blackfoot people even before he became a vampire. Jones doesn’t feel a need to cushion the blow for his readers, nor should he. And its not just in the way that he portrays the horrific violence and the fallout, but also in how Good Stab’s perspective uses terms and names from his own vocabulary as opposed to Western words (a lot of this is seen in how Good Stab refers to animals), with no reference page or glossary to be found. It made for complicated reading, but it was a fantastic choice. The real life unflinching historical horrors were so, so disturbing, and it’s important that we acknowledge the real history of this country, now more than ever, and Jones doesn’t sugar coat any of it, while also making it an emotional and devastating gut punch.

“The Buffalo Hunter Hunter” is harrowing and engrossing, heavy and necessary and another great horror tale from Stephen Graham Jones. I continue to be incredibly impressed and in awe of his horror storytelling prowess.

Rating 9: A dark horror western that takes on trauma, loss, and retribution against the violent colonial system that is the United States, “The Buffalo Hunter Hunter” is another evocative winner from Stephen Graham Jones.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Buffalo Hunter Hunter” is included on the Goodreads lists “2025 Releases by Indigenous Authors”, and “Horror Books 2025”.