Tag: Romantasy

Serena’s Review: “The Enchanted Greenhouse”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Enchanted Greenhouse” by Sarah Beth Durst

Publishing Info: Bramble, July 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Terlu Perna broke the law because she was lonely. She cast a spell and created a magically sentient spider plant. As punishment, she was turned into a wooden statue and tucked away into an alcove in the North Reading Room of the Great Library of Alyssium.

This should have been the end of her story . . . Yet one day, Terlu wakes in the cold of winter on a nearly-deserted island full of hundreds of magical greenhouses. She’s starving and freezing, and the only other human on the island is a grumpy gardener. To her surprise, he offers Terlu a place to sleep, clean clothes, and freshly baked honey cakes—at least until she’s ready to sail home.

But Terlu can’t return home and doesn’t want to—the greenhouses are a dream come true, each more wondrous than the next. When she learns that the magic that sustains them is failing—causing the death of everything within them—Terlu knows she must help. Even if that means breaking the law again.

This time, though, she isn’t alone. Assisted by the gardener and a sentient rose, Terlu must unravel the secrets of a long-dead sorcerer if she wants to save the island—and have a fresh chance at happiness and love.

Previously Reviewed: “The Spellshop”

Review: While I didn’t love “The Spellshop” as much as other readers did, I definitely still wanted to give this sequel a chance. As many of my struggles with the first book came down to my dislike of the main character, I had a lot of hope for this one as it is following a new character; I mean, she’s a librarian, so….. And, as predicted, I did enjoy this book more for this very reason!

Overall, I thought Terlu was a much more interesting and sympathetic character to follow. I enjoyed the set-up, with her having spent the last six years frozen as a statue as punishment for creating a sentient plant. Thus, when she wakes up, she, like the reader, is seeing her world through fresh eyes. Yes, there were times where her internal monologues and reflections became a bit repetitive, and I think the book could have benefitted from some editing down. But, overall, her story was exactly the sort of low stakes cozy experience that readers of this genre are looking for.

I also think that the love story worked better here. Again, I did have a few quibbles with it (it was a bit too fast burn for my personal taste), but the grumpy/sunshine nature of their relationship worked much better here than it did in the first book (if indeed that was even trying to be a grumpy/sunshine relationship; I’m still not convinced the heroine wasn’t meant to be a better character than how she came across).

I also enjoyed the quirky cast of characters found in the greenhouses. As I was returning to this world, I was better able to turn my brain off a bit as far as the world-building goes, but the entire set up of the new location we explore in this one helped with many of my qualms from the first. Here, I think the whimsical nature of the greenhouses worked in natural-feeling manner and left me with few questions about how this all worked.

I have to say that I struggled with some of the inner narrative word choices at times. I just don’t like modern lingo in books like this, and there were too many instances of a casual “yay!” and such for me to fully settle in to the story. But, again, this is highly subjective, and there were many other parts of the writing that I enjoyed more, particularly some of the descriptions of the world and its magical creatures.

However, in many ways, this book was very familiar. This can be seen as a good or bad thing, depending on how you feel about that first entry. I think there were definite improvements with the main character and with the love story. But many of the beats of the plot felt very familiar, as well as the cozy elements. They were cute and quirky, but just a bit too shallow for me to fully enjoy any of them. That said, I’m not a huge cozy fantasy reader, and given the popularity of the first book, some of my negatives here will be definite positives for others! So, for readers looking for more of the same, this will likely be a hit! And even for those who were a bit on the fence with the first book, this may be worth a read!

Rating 8: Perhaps aggressively cozy at times, but I still enjoyed the love story overall!

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Enchanted Greenhouse” is on these Goodreads lists: CozySFF and Heartwarming Books of 2025.

Serena’s Review: “Soulgazer”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Soulgazer” by Maggie Rapier

Publishing Info: Ace, July 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Saoirse yearns to be powerless. Cursed from childhood with a volatile magic, she’s managed to imprison it within, living under constant terror that one day it will break free. And it does, changing everything.

Horrified at her loss of control, Saoirse’s parents offer her hand to the cold and ruthless Stone King. Knowing she’ll never survive such a cruel man, Saoirse realizes there is only one path forward…she must break her curse. 

On the eve of her wedding, Saoirse seeks out the legendary Wolf of the Wild—Faolan, a feral, silver-tongued pirate. He swears to help rid her of the deadly magic, if she’ll use it to locate a lost mythical isle first. Crafted by the slaughtered gods, it’s the only land that could absorb her power.

But Saoirse knows better than to trust a pirate’s word. With the wrath of her disgraced father and scorned betrothed chasing them, Saoirse adds one last condition to protect if Faolan wants her on his ship, he’ll have to marry her first.

Review: Ok, I’ll admit it: I was first drawn to this book based purely on the romantic and whimsical nature of the cover art alone. This artist has illustrated a number of fantasy book covers, and I’ve never once not immediately wanted to pick that book up! Doesn’t hurt that this one also promised pirates!

While this book didn’t quite work for me the way I had hope, there were still plenty of strengths to be had. One thing that stood out immediately, both as a pro and a con, was the style of writing. This book leans heavily towards a sort of lyrical, lush style of storytelling. There is a lot of imagery used and many lovely turns of phrase that I couldn’t help but admire. However, conversely, there were times that even as I was wowed by the beauty of the writing, I was left wanting in actually understanding what was meant to be portrayed. At times I found it difficult to place the setting in which the story was taking place, or how the action flowed from one scene to another.

This was particularly challenging at the start of the book, when the reader is plopped down in the middle of a busy scene, full of magic, religion, and political power moves. Even a few chapters in, I still didn’t feel as if I fully grasped the social-political situation of the scene the story was taking place within or the heroine’s magical abilities. That said, as the book continued and the plot focused in on the main characters and the action surrounding them, I had less trouble. Even here, though, there were still times where this focus on beautiful strings of words was prioritized over clarity of description. Ultimately, I think this is a case where the author has a lot of potential, but still needs to grow a bit in her craft.

I did enjoy the romance at the heart of the story for the most part. I didn’t necessarily need as many of the steamy scenes as we got, but the development of the love story on an emotional level was done well. This was largely helped by how well-done the love interest was written. He felt complex, interesting, and well-suited for the sort of romance that was being explored. On the other hand, I found myself struggling a bit more Saoirse. This was unfortunate, because there was a lot I liked about this character.

For one thing, she was very much outside of the typical romantasy heroine mold, being much more reserved, with her journey focusing on her slowly coming out of her shell and escaping the mental and emotional abusive systems that she had been raised within. Even at the end, she was in no way a “girl boss” or “badass” sort of heroine. This was refreshing! However, she was also hard to enjoy at times, being sometimes incredibly naive. There were also several points in which conflict could have been easily handled with simple communication, which made her silence all the more frustrating to follow.

Overall, while this book wasn’t a favorite of mine, I think the author has a lot of potential! There were the bones of a really great story to be found here, and with a bit more polish, I think this book could have been a hit! That said, even as it stands, I think there are a number of readers who will really enjoy this one, especially romantasy fans who are looking for a quieter heroine and a swoon-worthy hero!

Rating 7: While I struggled at times with some of the writing, there is a lot to enjoy in this romantasy story, not least of which is the excellent romantic lead!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Soulgazer” isn’t currently on any Goodreads lists but it should be on Beautiful Covers.

Serena’s Review: “The Nightshade God”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Nightshade God” by Hannah Whitten

Publishing Info: Orbit, July 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Lore has failed. She couldn’t save King Bastian from the rotten god speaking voices in his mind. She couldn’t save her allies from being scattered across the continent—their own lesser gods whispering to them in their dreams. She couldn’t save her beautiful, corrupt city from the dark power beneath the catacombs. And she couldn’t save herself.

Banished to the Burnt Isles, Lore must use every skill she earned on the streets of Dellaire to survive the prison colony and figure out a way to defeat the power that’s captured everything and everyone she holds dear. When a surprise ally joins her on the Burnt Isles she realizes the way forward may lie on the island itself. Somehow, her friends must help her collect the far-scattered pieces of the broken Fount—the source of all the god’s powers—and bring them back together on the Burnt Isles, returning all magic to its source and destroying, once and for all, the gods corrupting the land.

But as Lore gets closer to her goal, her magic grows stronger… and to a woman who’s always had to fight for survival, that kind of power may be hard to give up.

Previously Reviewed: “The Foxglove King” and “The Hemlock Queen”

Review: Well, this was a bit of a let down. It’s always disappointing to see a series take a downward trend, especially when you look back at a high point at the start. The first book introduced a compelling cast of characters, a well-thought out, complex world, and a hidden history with promises of many exciting reveals to come. The second book languished a bit with “middle book syndrome,” little plot actually took place and several of the characters seemed to stall out in their progression (I also began to see the writing on the wall of a romantic arc I was less interested in). And here we are with the third.

To start with what I did like. I continue to enjoy Whitten’s style of writing. She has a way of drawing me in, even when I’m struggling to enjoy the relationships being portrayed or there isn’t necessarily a lot of plot to speak of. In less capable hands, that second book could have really gone another direction. Here, too, she takes the risky choice of swinging the focus away from our main three characters and back towards the gods they have come to embody. Now, I didn’t love this choice, but her writing is of such a high quality that I still pushed through what might otherwise have been a DNF from me.

But that urge to DNF was there, especially when I got to the middle section of the book and realized that I was halfway through the conclusion to a trilogy about three main characters and I had spent most of my time focusing on three OTHER characters (the gods in the past) and my main trio weren’t even together on page. Bizarrely, this book read almost like another middle book, where the author introduces a bunch of new characters and keeps the main group apart, with the expectation that this will all pay off in the end.

But this is the end! I get that the three gods are reflections of Lore, Bastian and Gabe. But no matter how closely they resemble those characters or their relationships mirror those of our main trio, they are still, demonstratively, not those characters. That being the case, I was frustrated with how much of the story focused on the interplay between these gods and their histories. Further, unlike an actual middle book, this one was our last chance to see our main trio together, so to spend so much of the story with them separated was truly unfortunate. For her part, Lore remains a good character on her own. But the dynamics between the characters is really what helps Bastian and Gabe to shine, so by distancing them all from one another, there was a decline in overall character quality to be found.

Lastly, I didn’t enjoy the romance. This is a completely subjective take, and I know many readers’ primary interest was in the throuple at the heart of the story. And, stepping back from my own preferences, I think all of those readers will be completely satisfied with this book. However, romance is a genre/topic that is incredibly subjective. Of all the genres, I think it is the one best served with tropes/hashtags assigned from the very start. A reader who enjoys dark romance is going to be into very different scenes and topics than a cozy romance reader. And the latter is best served by knowing right from the start that its a dark romance that they are picking up. So, too, with various pairings. Some readers enjoy reverse harems and throuples, while others are solidly monogamous/fated mates/etc. readers. I’m definitely the latter, and that being the case, this love story wasn’t for me.

This is one of those exact situations where I wish the book had been properly tagged from the start. Now! Don’t get me wrong, I probably still would have read this trilogy and been pleased I had, because I enjoy this author’s work and it’s not like throuples/polyamory are dealbreakers in any way. However, my expectations would have been properly aligned from the start. As it stands, the first book set up a love triangle, but I finished it still with the expectation that the trilogy would conclude with Lore ending up with one or the other, not both. So I was ultimately disappointed when I saw the direction the love story took, as throuples aren’t really my thing

All of this to say, this was just a fine read. As a whole, I don’t think the trilogy was properly paced, with the last two books both floundering a bit after the tightly plotted first book. That said, I think readers who are heavily invested in Lore/Bastian/Gabe will be incredibly happy with the way this book wraps up! I’ll definitely check out what Whitten writes next, but this trilogy won’t go down as one of my favorites from her.

Rating 7: This will definitely work for some, but I think it suffers from losing its focus on the main three characters at the heart of the story.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Nightshade God” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Romantasy TBR 2025 and Baroque Fantasy.

Serena’s Review: “The Baby Dragon Cafe”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Baby Dragon Cafe” by A. T. Qureshi

Publishing Info: Avon, July 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: When Saphira opened up her café for baby dragons and their humans, she wasn’t expecting it to be so difficult to keep the fires from burning. It turns out, young dragons are not the best magical animals to keep in a café, and replacing all that burnt furniture is costing Saphira more than she can afford from selling dragon-roasted coffee.

Aiden is a local gardener, and local heart-throb, more interested in his plants than actually spending time with his disobedient baby dragon. When Aiden walks into Saphira’s café, he has a genius idea – he’ll ask Saphira to train his baby dragon, and he’ll pay her enough to keep the café afloat.

Saphira knows her happy-go-lucky attitude isn’t Aiden’s cup of tea, but everywhere she goes, Aiden seems to follow. Has Saphira finally found the answer to the baby dragon cafe’s problems, and maybe a little love along the way, too?

Review: It looked so cute and yet I struggled so much! And really, by the end of the book, the “cuteness” is really the most this book has to offer. The cover art is adorable, and I’m sure it will do its job selling this book to many fans of cozy fantasy. The concept, also, is fun. Dragons are obviously very “in” right now, and what’s better than an adult dragon? A baby dragon! And when the book was setting up these initial world-building aspects, it was enjoyable enough. But unfortunately, quite quickly things began to fall apart.

Right off the bat, I knew this was going to be a bit of a struggle with the decision to not only use modern lingo, but hyper “online” lingo. This is, of course, a personal bugaboo of mine, so I’m not a totally objective agent when reporting annoyance at this style of writing. However, I do think a legitimate criticism can be leveled when a book relies on these sorts of “quirky” vocab choices as strongly as this one does. And in this case, it’s not just a matter of “modern” phrases or word choices. After all, this is a contemporary cozy romance, for all that it is set in a fantasy world. But the writing seriously read like the author leads her life online and was forming her entire vision of dialogue, description, and interactions based on what was found in Threads conversations. It was cringy to the extreme, and I guarantee it won’t age well. I’m sure authors are primarily focused on just getting their books out the door and into the world, but I do think some attention should be given to the book’s ability to then last in the world and not immediately date itself into oblivion with Bookthreads-speak.

Another of my main struggle points with cozy fantasy is the challenge of striking the correct balance between a homey, comforting vibe with low stakes and simply not having any stakes or plot to speak of. This unfortunately fell firmly in the latter category. As this is a romance story first and foremost, most of the plot revolved around the development of and conflict within the romance, and it struggled in every area. Right off the bat, the story fell into instalove/lust territory, with the characters quickly becoming enamored of one anther. This is annoying but not necessarily a deal breaker.

However, what really took me out of the story was what followed: a series of decisions by the main characters WHOLLY disconnected from any motivation shown to us on the page. With inner dialogue, they would reflect on choosing not so share certain bits of information (for no reason!) and then literally pages later, they would change their mind and just casually mention that same information (again, for no reason!). Quite quickly it became evident that the author was struggling to maintain any sort of tension or arc within this romance, and all of these bizarre decisions and interactions were simply being clumsily slotted in to draw out the romantic resolution.

Beyond this, the writing was simply rather bad, overall. Again and again, the reader was told basic facts about things and how they are meant to feel about it all. There was basically no showing to speak of. The sentence structure and vocabulary was similarly limited and straight-forward (I guess there was some variety in the type of Internet slang you’d be reading from one moment to the next…). Even things like punctuation were off, with a plethora of exclamation points to be found littered across any given page!

Honestly, this book was incredibly disappointing. It’s all the more surprising in that it’s coming from an established author, which makes me suspect that something perhaps was missing on the editing side of things. Too often, we keep seeing authors/publishers trend chasing at a pace that outruns quality and creativity, and such was the case here. Unfortunately, I can’t really recommend this one. There are simply too many other great books to read out there!

Rating 5: With bizarre character choices and drowning beneath Internet slang, this book was a disappointing read.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Baby Dragon Cafe” can be found on this Goodreads list: July 2025 Most Anticipated Romance Releases

Serena’s Review: “A Dance of Lies”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Dance of Lies” by Brittney Arena

Publishing Info: Del Rey, June 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Vasalie Moran was once a dancer in King Illian’s court, until he framed her for murder. Barely surviving her two years in the dungeons, she’s suddenly called to face her king. He offers her a deal: become his spy at the six-week royal Gathering and he’ll grant her freedom.

As Illian’s orders grow bloody and dangerous, forcing her to harm and betray those around her, Vasalie discovers that the monster she serves may be aligned with a bigger monster—one far closer to home. With her world threatened, Vasalie enlists the help of Illian’s brother and greatest adversary, the infamous King of the East.

As the rivalry between brothers escalates, with Vasalie caught in the middle, the horrifying truth of her past comes to light. If she wants to survive, she must decide who to trust, who to fight for, and how much of her soul she’s willing to damn in the process.

Review: Well, another romantasy down in the books. Another mixed bag affair. At this point, I acknowledge that I’m probably just a picky reader when it comes to this subgenre, and more often than not, I’m better off in “romantic fantasy” than romantasy, a distinction you wouldn’t think would make as much of a difference as it does! This one had a lot of potential, but in the end, it didn’t work for me in the way I had hoped it would.

Not a lot really worked for me with this one, unfortunately. But some of that is definitely objective. The style of writing, for one thing, felt fairly simplistic, leaving me feeling distanced from the characters and action and not able to fully invest myself in what was happening on the page. Part of this came down to what I felt was an imbalance between inner monologues and outward action/description. Yes, our main character has had a rough go of it, but there came a point in the first third of the story where I simply didn’t need to revisit some of these hardships as often as we were. All of this said, however, readers who prefer a more straight-forward style of writing or who prefer more inward-reflecting main characters may not struggle with the writing as much as I did.

I also liked the general idea of Vasalie’s disability and the inclusion of a character like this. That said, I’m not sure the execution quite worked. Again, a lot of inner narration was devoted to the struggles and adjustments that Vasalie needed to make due to this disability. However, whenever she needed to perform, it felt as if this disability suddenly, magically disappeared! The story didn’t outright say this, but the implication and depiction was that a person affected by a disability could simply “get past it” whenever it was needed. There was nothing egregious in this area, but I did think there was a heavy disconnect between the inner reflections of Vasalie’s disablity and the actual affect it had on her life (very little, especially when her dancing was needed for plot purposes).

I also didn’t love the romance. I didn’t expect a love triangle situation, so I was displeased to see one emerging fairly early on. While not the worst I’ve read, I often found myself frustrated by Vasalie’s choices. I definitely had a preference of her two choices, and I felt like she spent way too much time chasing the wrong one. Beyond that, I’m not sure if I’ve ranted about it before, but I’m so over the cutesy little nicknames that seem to now be a requirement in the romantasy genre. Authors, they’re not cute. Please stop.

Me cringing so hard at the latest “clever” nickname to pop up in my romantasy read

So yeah, this was kind of a bummer of read. Nothing was horribly wrong with it, but on the other hand, nothing was really great. More general fans of romantasy (i.e. less picky ones) will likely enjoy this one, especially those who like love triangles/less defined romantic interests. However, if you’re just a casual fan, I’m not sure this is the read for you.

Rating 6: Unfortunately, this one just didn’t click with me, feeling at once too familiar and too remote to become invested in.

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Dance of Lies” can be found on this Goodreads list: June 2025 Most Anticipated Romance Releases

Serena’s Review: “Realm of Thieves”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Realm of Thieves” by Karina Halle

Publishing Info: Ace, June 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ebook from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: For Brynla Aihr, crime and survival have always gone hand in hand. Ever since she escaped the fanatical dragon-worshipping cult that controls her homeland, she’s had to carve out a life doing the stealing dragon eggs. Egg theft is illegal and, in most cases, fatal. To breach a dragon’s nest means a harrowing journey through the ancient wards spelled to keep the monstrous beasts confined. Dragons can’t get out and only those with a death wish can get in.

Despite the risks, dragon eggs are highly coveted for their magic. A black market flourishes under competing criminal empires, and Brynla’s loyalty has always been to the highest bidder. Until she finds herself kidnapped and blackmailed by Lord Andor, a formidable lieutenant of House Kolbeck, and thrust into the dangerous political games of rivaling dynasties.

Brynla and Andor clash at every turn, sparking heat in ways Brynla’s never felt before. But in a world that’s prophesized to return to the dragons, and rife with betrayal and secrets at every turn…how close to the flames is she willing to stand?

Review: There are so, so many dragon books in romantasy. To be fair, dragons were always pretty popular in fantasy/romantasy, even before “Fourth Wing.” But now it seems out of control! I honestly sometimes lose track of them all, which one’s I’ve read, how many new ones are coming out and what differentiates them, etc. etc. So, yes, here’s another dragon romantasy review!

Unfortunately, I’m still thwarted in this area. I’m starting to think that I may just need to stick with my more traditional fantasy books for my dragon kick, at least until it dies down a bit in massive popularity. As it stands, too often it feels as if authors and publishers may just be trying to cash in on a popular trope instead of following an organic story-making process. Such is the case here. While there were aspects of the world-building here with its use of dragons that I thought were interesting, as the story continued, this book ultimately seemed to turn more into a gangster/mafia romance story. Which I don’t dislike as a romance subgenre on its own, but wasn’t why I was picking this book up.

Ultimately, from early in the story, everything felt rather flat. The author was telling me a lot of things, but I wasn’t seeing many reasons to become emotionally involved. The characters were just kind of there, following along in many of the standard FMC/MMC archetypes that we’ve come to expect from books like this. The pacing was fairly stilted, with the book dragging significantly in the middle of the story only to fall through the floor with the almost bait-and-switch with the genre change from fantasy to mafia romance in the end. And over and over again characters and plot points operated in ways that didn’t make sense other than as quick resolutions to any challenges that presented themselves. Things happened because a problem needed to be solved. And solved quickly with very little conflict being given any time to brew.

Much of this only came to play as I continued reading, but I was already started off on the wrong foot by the way the romance was handled. When I say “fast” I can’t emphasize enough just how fast I mean. The characters meet and that’s pretty much it. Their insta-attraction/lust/love was so extreme that it felt totally unbelievable and threw me out of the book. True, I prefer a slow burn (typically even across multiple books!) but there are numerous romantasy titles I can point to that have an established romance in book one that I enjoyed (see “Shield of Sparrows.”) This book totally missed the mark for me in this department. As a bit of a side note, I’m very over the cutesy nicknames that the MMCs give FMCs. They are getting more and more ridiculous and over-the -top. If someone talked like this in real life, the cringe would be off the charts.

Sadly, this was a miss for me. I know that this author is quite prolific, so I might need to dig around her back catalog and see if I connect better with one of her previous books. I’m sure fans of her work will enjoy this, but if you want a well-developed romance or a book that focuses strongly on the fantasy elements, you may want to pass on this one. That said, if you like mafia romance, this may be the unexpected hit you’re looking for!

Rating 6: With a flat-feeling plot, lack of complex characterization, and a romance that went from zero to one hundred in two seconds flat, this one sadly wasn’t for me.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Realm of Thieves” can be found on these Goodreads lists:Most Anticipated Romantasy releases of 2025

Serena’s Review: “The Knight and the Moth”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Knight and the Moth” by Rachel Gillig

Publishing Info: Orbit, May 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Sybil Delling has spent nine years dreaming of having no dreams at all. Like the other foundling girls who traded a decade of service for a home in the great cathedral, Sybil is a Diviner. In her dreams she receives visions from six unearthly figures known as Omens. From them, she can predict terrible things before they occur, and lords and common folk alike travel across the kingdom of Traum’s windswept moors to learn their futures by her dreams.

Just as she and her sister Diviners near the end of their service, a mysterious knight arrives at the cathedral. Rude, heretical, and devilishly handsome, the knight Rodrick has no respect for Sybil’s visions. But when Sybil’s fellow Diviners begin to vanish one by one, she has no choice but to seek his help in finding them. For the world outside the cathedral’s cloister is wrought with peril. Only the gods have the answers she is seeking, and as much as she’d rather avoid Rodrick’s dark eyes and sharp tongue, only a heretic can defeat a god.

Review: Some may have noticed that I didn’t review the “One Dark Window” duology back when it came out a few years ago. Well, I tried! But it was one of those book that I just couldn’t get into to, struggling through the entire reading experience. Sometimes I’ll post reviews for books like this if I feel like I have anything constructive to contribute to the conversation or if it’s a title I committed to covering for a publicist. But the rest of time, I usually just pass them by. Well, over the last several years, that duology has exploded in popularity! So much so that I began to question my initial judgement of the book I read. Was I, perhaps, just not in the right mood for it? Did the second book (which I didn’t read) massively improve on the first? People seemed to universally love this series! That being the case, when I saw that Gillig was coming out with her debut adult romantasy title, I was excited to give it a chance! Perhaps I would finally get to hitch a ride on this hype train!

Whelp. Not so much. I really struggled to enjoy this book and was reminded strongly why I didn’t connect with the first one. They both had similar struggles with writing structure and characterization. But let’s start with some positives! The book started on a strong note, with the introduction of this world and the set up for themes regarding religion and prophesy. Some of these initial scenes were incredibly compelling, and it was all the more disappointing seeing some of this early strong work flail under weak characters as the story continued. I also have to give a shout-out to the fun gargoyle companion, the only character who actually seemed to, you know, have a personality? Due to how out-of-step I was with my opinion of Gillig’s other book, I won’t be surprised to find myself on the opposite side of this one as well. But I can almost guarantee that the other reviewers who may, like me, struggle with this book will ALSO love the gargoyle!

I think I would have enjoyed the gargoyle on its own, but it did end up standing out in stark contrast to our main character and the love interest, only highlighting just how little THERE was there for either of them! I couldn’t tell you a single fact about either of these characters, other than things that were strictly having to do with the actual plot points of this story. She is a seer, he is a knight. Yes, yes, and? As we follow Sybil, she was by far the worse of the two. Her “voice,” such as it was, was incredibly bland and dull. This carried over to the romance. We were never given any reason why these two would even like each other, let alone fall in love. It was like reading about to cardboard cut outs of people snark badly at each other and then suddenly declare their deep feelings. Chemistry is a hard thing to peg, but man, when it’s lacking, it’s obvious. And that was definitely the case here!

I was also reminded why I struggled to enjoy the previous book I read by this author. I simply do not enjoy her writing style. There’s a very odd mix of purple prose woven in alongside incredibly modern vernacular. She’s also way too fond of writing incomplete sentences. Every once in a while, this choice can make sense to add emphasis or weight to particular scene or moment. But Gillig uses it constantly and to an overwhelming degree. Here’s a quick example of what I’m talking about: “I shivered. Turned to the gargoyle.” Why not just put an “and” in there? Or simply put a comma after “shivered.” There are many options, but again and again this structure is utilized, making the writing feel choppy and, I think, contributing to the sense of distance I felt from the characters. Often it’s these little style choices that give readers the clues to pick up on the personality of the characters they’re following. And when the writing is choppy and inconsistent, so, too, the characters feel lacking.

The story was also incredibly predictable. And anything the reader couldn’t guess based on any previous exposure to typical fantasy plot points is almost spoon fed to them by the author herself. By the end of the book, I felt like not only had this one followed a familiar structure (very similar to “One Dark Window” in fact) but that I could easily guess the conclusion of the duology as a whole, without even picking up the second book.

I don’t really know how to conclude this review. Obviously, this was a complete miss for me. But I also know that Gillig is a fairly beloved author at this point, and that this book in particular is incredibly hyped in the genre. So, I guess if you’re a huge fan of her previous duology, this one might work for you. However, if you struggled to connect to this author’s style before, this was more of the same, in all of the worst ways.

Rating 5: Choppy sentences, purple prose, and characters who read like wet cardboard; unfortunately, not the book for me.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Knight and the Moth” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Epic High Fantasy/Romance/Mythology in 2025 and Gothic Fantasy.

Serena’s Review: “Shield of Sparrows”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Shield of Sparrows” by Devney Perry

Publishing Info: Red Tower Books, May 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Long ago, the gods unleashed monsters upon the five kingdoms of Calandra to remind us that humans are insignificant—that we must pray to the gods for mercy throughout our fragile, fleeting lives.

I didn’t need a deity to remind me I was powerless. Being a princess had never been more than a performance—twenty-three years of empty titles and hollow traditions. My sister revels in the spectacle, basking in the attention and flawlessly playing her part. I was never asked to be part of the charade.

Until the day an infamous monster hunter sailed to our shores. The day a prince walked into my father’s throne room and ruined my life. The day I married a stranger, signed a magical treaty in blood, and set off across the continent to the most treacherous kingdom in all the realm.

That was the day I learned that not all myths are make-believe. That lies and legends are often the same. And that the only way to kill the monsters we fear was to become one…

Review: I was approached by the publicist to read and review this book, so I’ll be honest, I knew next to nothing about it going in. I had the vague understanding that the author was fairly prolific in the contemporary romance world, but as I read very little of that genre, I’d never checked out any of her books. Beyond that, the book summary look interesting, but also fairly generic. Well, let this be a lesson to never write anyone off! This was one of those books where I ended up binge reading it late into the night over two nights total!

I’m always a bit nervous when an author unfamiliar to the genre decides to tackle fantasy. Will they understand the conventions of the genre? Will they be be able to add something unique and not become mired in generic tropes? I think these are valid concerns. But not only did Perry prove me wrong in these concerns, but I think she also highlighted a key factor in why the romantasy genre may need MORE cross-over authors.

Romantasy is a super popular, fairly new genre, and as such, publishers are whipping out new titles as fast as they can without a steady list of veteran authors to pull from. And over the last few years, this desire to catch the bandwagon has produced a run of books where it feels like debut authors were not given the proper editing support they needed or titles were picked up that really had no business being published in their current state. And lacking many veteran voices in the genre, this can lead to the feeling that the genre as a whole is a bit shaky as far as quality goes. Perry illustrates how an experienced author with numerous books under her belt can elevate even the most mundane romantasy tropes and produce a book that feels like a breath of fresh air to the genre!

So, now I’ve written several paragraphs and not really talked about this book at all! But let’s start with the characters. Right off the bat, I liked the variation in the main character from the typical leading lady we see. There are a million and one feisty, snarky, fighter FMCs in romantasy. Instead, we follow the overlooked sister, Odessa, who has her rather dull life already plotted out before her. So when she’s thrust into the role of new Queen and secret spy, she’s totally unprepared. And by that I mean…actually unprepared! She doesn’t suddenly reveal incredible powers of fighting prowess or the skillset to properly infiltrate a foreign nation. We see her flounder her way through the “spying” again and again, and the book devotes a healthy amount of time to her attempts to learn to fight. By the end of the book, it’s been months, and it’s clear that while she can now pull off basic moves, she’s by no means a powerhouse. Instead, her strengths are found in her resilience, her empathy for those around her, and her bravery in the face of a world of new dangers and unknowns.

I also really enjoyed the romance and the romantic lead! It’s easy for the readers to guess the real situation, but I particularly appreciated the care that was taken with the main character’s handling of this situation. Odessa’s attempts to balance her obligations, bond with the man she believes to be her husband, and deal with her growing attraction for another all feel believable and sympathetic. I’ve seen this sort of set up go very wrong in the past, and I was glad to see that avoided here.

I also have to give a shout out to the creativity and complexity to the plot line and the world-building. While there is a heavy focus on the romance, it’s definitely of the slow-burn variety, which leaves a lot of page time freed up. And instead of the fluff that I feel like I often see in books like this, here we get not only a rich world, full of creative and horrific monsters, but also a detailed history and political situation that took several twists and turns towards the back half of the book that I didn’t see coming! I was also impressed by the author’s dedication to portraying the horror that would be living in this world. There are terrible monsters filling this land, and that being the case, terrible things often happen to those who live in it. There were a few scenes that definitely had me tearing up! Again, it was gratifying to read a romantasy that took its world-building seriously, even when that lead to rough situations and scenes.

So, shocking no one at this point, you can see that I really enjoyed this one! It took me completely by surprise and now not only can I not wait for the sequel, but I’m even thinking about checking out some of this author’s contemporary romance books (if I can find the time to escape my massive TBR!). If you’re a romantasy fan who’s aching for a book with a bit more meat on the bones, this is definitely one to check out. That said, it does end on a cliffhanger of sorts, so go in knowing you’ll have a wait for any real conclusion (talking to my aunt here!)!

Rating 9: A perfect example of the highs that the romantasy genre can reach when in the hands of a skilled author! Swoon-worthy romance, rich world-building, and an fast-moving plot that doesn’t let up!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Shield of Sparrows” isn’t currently on any Goodreads lists, but it should be on Romantasy TBR 2025.

Serena’s Review: “Behooved”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Behooved” by M. Stevenson

Publishing Info: Bramble, May 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Bianca knows her duty comes before her heart. So when the threat of war looms, she agrees to marry the neighboring kingdom’s heir. But not all royal weddings are a fairytale, and Prince Aric, Bianca’s betrothed, is cold, aloof, and seems to hate her on sight.

To make matters worse, on their wedding night, an assassination attempt goes awry―leaving Aric magically transformed into a horse. Bianca does what any bride in this situation would do: she mounts her new husband and rides away to safety.

Sunset returns Aric to human form, but they soon discover the assassination attempt is part of a larger plot against the throne. Worse, Bianca has been framed for Aric’s murder, and she’s now saddled with a husband who is a horse by day and a frustratingly attractive man by night.

As an unexpected romance begins galloping away with their hearts, Bianca and Aric must rely on each other to unravel the curse and save the throne.

Review: Right off the bat, the comparisons to “My Lady Jane” are inescapable! Who knew there could be two fantasy novels where the love interest is cursed to turn into a horse by day?? Unfortunately, while this one did have a few high points, I mostly set it down wishing that stupid Amazon hadn’t cancelled the “My Lady Jane” show!

I do think this book is at its best when it was leaning into its romcom elements. The absurdity, the banter, and the swift-moving romance are all best appreciated in line with tropes found romcoms. In these moments, the characters were amusing and the love story sweet, if a bit underdeveloped. On the other hand, I think the book struggled when approached from a fantasy perspective. There simply wasn’t enough “there” there. The magic system was incredibly ill-defined and there were many plot moments where, if you allowed your brain to turn back on, you’d be left scratching your head.

I also struggled to enjoy the main character. While I appreciate the author’s creation of a character who suffers from chronic illness, I think the execution was too heavy handed to be very effective. In the first few chapters, especially, it feels as if this is the only aspect of Bianca’s character that anyone cares about, including Bianca herself! It’s referenced a truly boggling number of times in a very small number of pages. Of course, this is an important part of her life and is a source of friction between her and her parents, who see this only as a weakness. However, I began to feel as if Bianca didn’t have anything else making up her character either, defining herself completely around this one aspect of herself, which seems completely contrary to how one should understand people who live with chronic illnesses.

I also struggled with the romance itself. Alas, the story leans heavily into the miscommunication trope, one of the banes of my existence. The wild leaps of logic were truly baffling at times. For example, on the night of the attack, Aric and Bianca are both attacked. But for some reason Aric goes on to think that Bianca was behind it all? And, as is so often the case with this trope, much of the confusion and animosity between them could have easily been solved with a few very short conversations.

Overall, this was an ok read. Strangely, this is one of those cases where I feel like the book would have been better served to have leaned more fully into the comedy aspects of the story. The attempts at serious fantasy elements or its handling of important themes all became stumbling blocks to my enjoyment of the book. That said, straight romcom readers may enjoy this one more than me! Especially if you don’t care as much about the fantasy portions of the story!

Rating 7: While the book did have some sweet and funny moments, I struggled to enjoy it due to its weaker main character and the heavy use of the miscommunication trope.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Behooved” can be found on this Goodreads list:2025 Cozy Fantasy Romance

Serena’s Review: “Inked in Ashes”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Inked in Ashes” by Shannon Mayer

Publishing Info: Kindle edition, April 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the author!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: I’ve spent twenty-five years in the Hollow, poor as dirt, cursed with a stepmother who hates me, and dreaming about a faraway land that I don’t understand. Only two things that make life worth living are my falcon, Fetch, and my best friend, Molly.

But when Moll’s plot to land a royal husband at the palace ball goes horribly wrong, I find myself staring at a king with a glass stiletto buried in his chest and a blood-covered Molly standing over him. We’ve got to move…and fast, or we’ll both wind up swinging from the hangman’s noose.

Worse? The palace sorcerer is using everything he can to find the culprit including raising the dead.

More complicated? Duncan…brother to the King, whose eye I’ve unintentionally caught, a man whose secrets might be deadlier than the undead soldiers breathing down our necks, is making me second-guess everything I’ve ever known. With revolution brewing and a mysterious man calling to me from my dreams, I have no choice but to embrace my fate…But what if my fate is beyond anything I could ever imagine? What if the only land I’ve ever known isn’t home at all?

What if I’m trapped inside a fairytale, and the only way out…is through?

Review: Any one who is familiar with my reviews will understand immediately why I was interested in checking this book out, based on the description above! Always love me some fairytale action! And this one had a super unique take, with essentially one fairytale set within another. The opening sequence which set up the book and this premise was fantastic, laying out high stakes, a great villain, and introducing some of the magic of this world. The story then shifts to the “inner story” and we pick up with our main character.

First of all, I really enjoyed Harmony. It was refreshing to follow a protagonist who not only is an adult but who is also looking at life through an adult’s viewpoint. Her early interactions with her friend Moll perfectly speak to that rather panicky stage that can happen in one’s twenties when you look around and realize life is going on, you’re aging, and you need to get your shit together. Of course, Harmony and Moll’s stakes are much higher than your average person in our world!

Again, no surprise for those who know my preferences, but I loved the heavy focus on the sister-like bond between Harmony and Moll. This relationship served as a healthy balance point to the romance. Too often in stories like this the love story seems to overwhelm every other aspect of a character’s personality. But by having Moll as such an important and crucial part of Harmony’s life, Harmony herself remains a fully realized character throughout.

I also really enjoyed all of the nods to fairytale tropes and plot points. Some are more subtle than others, but it was always fun running up against a new one! That said, for all of the the light-hearted moments, the author definitely didn’t shy away from the more awful aspects of fairytales as well. Right from the start, it’s clear that this is a violent, dangerous world, and that doesn’t let up throughout. The story itself follows a fairly predictable fantasy plot line, but the pacing was steady and quick, so I never found myself losing interest.

Overall, this was a fun, fast read. It fully took advantage of its fairytale setting and by the end I was excited to see where the story would go from here! Fans of fairytale fantasies should definitely give this one a shot!

Rating 8: Brimming with whimsy and romance, “Inked in Ashes” is fresh fairytale fantasy that is sure to please fans of the genre!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Inked in Ashes” isn’t on any Goodreads lists currently, but it should be on Twisted Fairytales.