Tag: historical fiction

Kate’s Review: “All The Little Houses”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “All The Little Houses” by May Cobb

Publishing Info: Sourcebooks Landmark, January 2026

Where Did I Get This Book: I received and eARC from NetGalley

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indibound

Book Description: It’s the mid-1980s in the tiny town of Longview, Texas. Nellie Anderson, the beautiful daughter of the Anderson family dynasty, has burst onto the scene. She always gets what she wants. What she can’t get for herself… well, that’s what her mother is for. Because Charleigh Andersen, blond, beautiful, and ruthlessly cunning, remembers all too well having to claw her way to the top. When she was coming of age on the poor side of East Texas, she was a loser, an outcast, humiliated, and shunned by the in-crowd, whose approval she’d so desperately thirsted for. When a prairie-kissed family moves to town, all trad wife, woodworking dad, wholesome daughter vibes, Charleigh’s entire self-made social empire threatens to crumble. Who will be left standing when the dust settles?

From the author of The Hunting Wives comes a deliciously wicked new thriller about mean girls, mean moms, and the delicious secrets inside all the little houses.

Review: Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eARC of this novel!

When I was a kid I had a nanny that really loved “Little House on the Prairie”. I remember her sometimes trying to get me to watch it, but I found it so utterly boring that she never was able to convert me. I have read a good deal of the “Little House” books (I’m a Minnesota girl after all), but never got into the TV show mythos (as it’s extensive and different from the books I hear tell). When I started reading “All the Little Houses” by May Cobb, it took me a little bit to realize that I was reading a book that was a 1980s kind of interpretation of the “Little House” TV show, but when I did I thought ‘oh, that’s kinda fun!’ Given that Cobb wrote “The Hunting Wives”, which is now a hit show on Netflix (I haven’t watched it yet but it sounds wild), I was really hoping for something unhinged and covered in suds and over the top dramatics. I live for that stuff. And with a “Little House” vibe it felt all the more ripe for the picking. Unfortunately it didn’t click for me.

But first the good stuff. As much as I am not a “Little House on the Prairie” person, I know enough about it to be able to make the connections to the characters that are representative of the characters from the show, and some of that I really enjoyed. Especially because some of the directions that a few of the characters were taken (specifically Ethan, the patriarch of the Swift family, though the reveal here is a bit more in line with the real life Charles Ingalls as opposed to TV show or book… if you know, you know). I also enjoyed the character of Jackson, Charleigh’s best friend who is an interior decorator and happens to be a gay man in the 1980s, feeling a need to be careful while also being flaunted by Charleigh as a novelty. While none of the characters were particularly likable (more on that in a bit), at least Jackson’s prickly and abrasive behaviors made some sense as being a gay man during this time was incredibly difficult.

But there were definitely some stumbles that came with this book. As mentioned above, most of the characters were completely unlikable, and very few of them had the complexities to make their terrible personalities bearable/understandable. This was especially disappointing for the character of Nellie, who is clearly the Nellie Oleson analog but is SO awful that it’s not even fun to follow her in her chapters. And even when we got a slight tread towards making her nuanced or at least a little bit complicated, Cobb never quite pulled the trigger with her to have her move beyond being completely horrendous (and while I haven’t seen “Little House on the Prairie” all that much, I’ve seen enough clips to know that Nellie has a HUGE redemption/development arc, so that made this even more disappointing). Also, these characters seemed to be 1980s caricatures of the TV show, but then also references the TV show as something in universe. Which was confusing. And finally, the ending was incredibly rushed. We got some hints throughout the book about a murder or at least a dead body in the local lake/pond with question as to who it is and who did it, but then by the time we got to the climax it landed with a huge thud, and then abruptly ended. Generally I can forgive a lot if there is a lot of suds and over the top melodrama, but it wasn’t enough to bolster it above the ho-humness of the execution.

“All the Little Houses” had potential but didn’t really meet it. It may work for others, but it didn’t really work for me.

Rating 5: With very few likable characters and a thud of an ending, even the soapy fun couldn’t fully redeem this book.

Reader’s Advisory:

“All the Little Houses” is included on the Goodreads list “2026 Mystery/Thriller New Releases”.

Book Club Review: “The Hacienda”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here

Book: “The Hacienda” by Isabel Cañas

Publishing Info: Berkley, May 2022

Where Did We Get This Book: The library!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: In the overthrow of the Mexican government, Beatriz’s father is executed and her home destroyed. When handsome Don Rodolfo Solórzano proposes, Beatriz ignores the rumors surrounding his first wife’s sudden demise, choosing instead to seize the security his estate in the countryside provides. She will have her own home again, no matter the cost.

But Hacienda San Isidro is not the sanctuary she imagined.

When Rodolfo returns to work in the capital, visions and voices invade Beatriz’s sleep. The weight of invisible eyes follows her every move. Rodolfo’s sister, Juana, scoffs at Beatriz’s fears—but why does she refuse to enter the house at night? Why does the cook burn copal incense at the edge of the kitchen and mark its doorway with strange symbols? What really happened to the first Doña Solórzano?

Beatriz only knows two things for certain: Something is wrong with the hacienda. And no one there will help her.

Desperate for help, she clings to the young priest, Padre Andrés, as an ally. No ordinary priest, Andrés will have to rely on his skills as a witch to fight off the malevolent presence haunting the hacienda and protect the woman for whom he feels a powerful, forbidden attraction. But even he might not be enough to battle the darkness.

Far from a refuge, San Isidro may be Beatriz’s doom.

Serena’s Thoughts

I’ve had this one on my TBR for a while now, ever since reading Kate’s review and thinking that it sounded like my sort of horror novel (that is, on the gothic side and only mildly horrific!). So when my prompt for book club was ghosts (guess whose prompt that was…), I knew that this was my opportunity, and boy did it not disappoint!

There was so much to love about this book that I’m not sure where to start. One thing really stood out, however: I don’t know enough about this location and point in history. The historical setting and events of the time played a crucial role in much of the story, and while the book didn’t go into tons of detail, I really enjoyed what we did see. For one thing, I liked the careful handling of the realities of so many revolutions. Often, they don’t end when they “end,” and there are rarely sides that are completely in the right or wrong, or who won’t switch positions on the moral compass as a conflict progresses. I didn’t expect to see these themes in a gothic ghost story, but I definitely enjoyed them!

I also really enjoyed our two main characters. Beatriz was brave but believably mystified about how to handle her increasingly terrifying prospects. And while Andres brings many answers to the situation, even he is challenged by the extreme horror of the situation before them. I really enjoyed the relationship that was built up between them, and the story took a surprisingly romantic turn toward the end of the book.

The gothic elements were also on point. The house itself was a character in and of itself (something that I think is almost a requirement for any haunted house story), and just when you think you have a handle on the mysteries, another wrench is thrown into the situation.

I really enjoyed this one! So much so that I definitely plan on checking out the other books by this author! Vampires, here I come!

Kate’s Thoughts

I still really love this book on a re-read. I was so happy that Serena picked it because going back to it with new eyes sounded like a fun time, and my opinions haven’t really changed much. It just goes to show that there’s a reason that Isabel Cañas is one of my favorite horror authors writing today.

Reading this again, I still feel like some of the strongest elements are the way that Cañas addresses the ways that European colonialism has destabilized and completely uprooted so much of the culture that Beatriz and Andres have been living within, whether it’s the realities of colorism and racism that Beatriz and other darker Mestizo characters have to deal with, or how Andres has decided to hide his brujo and healing skills by joining the Catholic Church as a priest.

And the book is still really really unnerving, with a great ghost story and a Gothic flair in a place that isn’t as expected in Gothic stories. Cañas is so good at capturing a time and place and creating unease and fear, while having many supporting players to be terrorized (or in some cases doing the terrorizing).

I really love “The Hacienda”! It absolutely holds up on a re-read and it created a lot of good discussion in our book club to boot!

Serena’s Rating 9: Just the right combination of fantastic and horrific, with a splash of historical fiction and romance to sweeten the pot!

Kate’s Rating 9 : Still so wonderfully Gothic and creepy with lots of interesting history and critique of imperialism within the aftermath of a revolution.

Book Club Questions

  1. How familiar were you with this time and place? What did you learn that was new?
  2. The various women in this book all experienced limited choices regarding their own lives and futures. What stood out to you about these women’s tales and what you have done similarly or differently?
  3. The story has a lot to say about religion, both Catholicism and author’s interpretation of local faith systems. How did religion and magic mix in this book and how well do you feel these themes were explored?
  4. This is a gothic horror novel. Did you enjoy the horror elements? What there a scene that was particularly scary to you and why?
  5. Beatriz and Padre Andres both experienced challenges in this book, ultimately turning towards one another to face their foe. Did you enjoy this relationship? How did you interpret the ending?

Reader’s Advisory

“The Hacienda” is included on the Goodreads lists 2022 Gothic and Books Set in Mexico.

Next Book Club Pick: “The Magic Fish” by Trung Le Nguyen

Kate’s Review: “Oxford Soju Club”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Oxford Soju Club” by Jinwoo Park

Publishing Info: Dundum Press, September 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from the publicist

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: When North Korean spymaster Doha Kim is mysteriously killed in Oxford, his protege, Yohan Kim, chases the only breadcrumb given to him in Doha’s last breath: “Soju Club, Dr. Ryu.” In the meantime, a Korean American CIA agent , Yunah Choi, races to salvage her investigation of the North Korean spy cell in the aftermath of the assassination. At the centre of it all is the Soju Club, the only Korean restaurant in Oxford, owned by Jihoon Lim, an immigrant from Seoul in search of a new life after suffering a tragedy. As different factions move in with their own agendas, their fates become entangled, resulting in a bitter struggle that will determine whose truth will triumph.

Oxford Soju Club weaves a tale of how immigrants in the Korean diaspora are forced to create identities to survive, and how in the end, they must shed those masks and seek their true selves.

Review: Thank you to River Street Writing for sending me an eARC of this novel!

I’m not really one for spy and espionage thrillers, but when “Oxford Soju Club” by Jinwoo Park ended up in my inbox I had a hard time saying no. Maybe it’s because I am always trying to stretch my reading boundaries. But I also was super intrigued by the idea of North Korean spies trying to maneuver in England with the CIA hot on their tails. I decided to go for it, and I’m happy I did because I found this spy story contained surprises I wasn’t expecting.

So yes, the spy elements are pretty present, but it is done in a way that was interesting to me. We have three separate perspectives for each chapter, setting up a flashpoint of North Korean spies in the face of a shifting political landscape, a CIA agent trying to keep track of their movements, and a South Korean restaurant owner whose business serves as a backdrop for politicking, all set in Oxford, England. Yohan Kim’s mentor, fellow North Korean spy Doha Kim, has been stabbed to death, and with his dying breath he tells Yohan to go to the Soju Club restaurant to meet with the mysterious Dr. Ryu. It starts the novel off with a bang, and it’s only the start as Yohan tries to keep himself safe and discreet, while CIA agent Yunah Choi starts to make moves for the American side of spies as the heat starts to turn up in the wake of North Korean regime change and political shifts, making openings for American intelligence. And while spies make moves, they all center at the Soju Club, the only Korean restaurant in Oxford that is run by South Korean immigrant Jihoon Lim. The story goes quickly in the present, while flashing back to see all of the characters paths that lead up to this point with double crosses, deaths, conspiracies, and unthinkable pressure. I do admit that sometimes I found the pacing and time jumps to be a little confusing, and found myself having to read back to keep up a fair amount. Spy stories are complicated enough without hasty time jumping.

The other huge theme of this book, and the theme that resonated the most for me, was a common feeling between all of our characters, be they spies or civilians, about their connection to their Korean identity and how it informs their choices and movements forward. For Yohan, his ties to the North are mostly because of his relationship with his mentor Doha, whose influence has shaped Yohan’s entire perspectives as this point, and whose companionship is really all he’s ever known. For Yunah, she is the daughter of Korean immigrants who raised her in New Jersey, and who has been treading a line between her American childhood and her relationship with parents who have so many dreams for her that she can’t quite line up with. And for the non-spy Jihoon, he is trying to make an homage to his mother, who ran a restaurant in Seoul and whose love has inspired him to open his own Korean restaurant in Oxford. We followed all of these perspectives and got an insight into all of their motivations, and I found it poignant and emotional given that in spy/espionage stories there are few happy endings.

“Oxford Soju Club” was a tense thriller with a lot of emotions at its center. It was a pleasant surprise that went to places I didn’t expect! Confusing timeline shifts aside, I enjoyed it.

Rating 7: While it is a spy thriller on the surface, “Oxford Soju Club” is also an examination of identity, culture, loyalty, and the conflicts that can come with them.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Oxford Soju Club” is included on the Goodreads list “ATY 2026: Korean or Korean Diaspora Author”.

Book Club Review: “The Bletchley Riddle”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here

Book: “The Bletchley Riddle” by Ruta Sepetys & Steve Sheinkin

Publishing Info: Viking Books for Young Readers, October 2024

Where Did We Get This Book: The Library!

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: Remember, you are bound by the Official Secrets Act…

Summer, 1940. Nineteen-year-old Jakob Novis and his quirky younger sister Lizzie share a love of riddles and puzzles. And now they’re living inside of one. The quarrelsome siblings find themselves amidst one of the greatest secrets of World War II—Britain’s eccentric codebreaking factory at Bletchley Park. As Jakob joins Bletchley’s top minds to crack the Nazi’s Enigma cipher, fourteen-year-old Lizzie embarks on a mission to solve the mysterious disappearance of their mother.

The Battle of Britain rages and Hitler’s invasion creeps closer. And at the same time, baffling messages and codes arrive on their doorstep while a menacing inspector lurks outside the gates of the Bletchley mansion. Are the messages truly for them, or are they a trap? Could the riddles of Enigma and their mother’s disappearance be somehow connected? Jakob and Lizzie must find a way to work together as they race to decipher clues which unravel a shocking puzzle that presents the ultimate challenge: How long must a secret be kept?

Serena’s Thoughts

Other than the fact that this is a middle grade novel (I don’t tend to love reading this genre as an adult, which honestly makes me a bit sad!), this book was right up my alley! I enjoy both historical fiction as well as mysteries, and both are done so well in this story. I was also a big fan of the code-breaking and puzzle aspects. I enjoyed trying to put things together myself, but also was happy to simply follow along with the characters as they pieced it all together and then explained it to me later.

I have a long record on this blog of complaining about poorly executed alternating POVs, but this was a good example of how to do this right. One of my biggest complaints is that authors often have a hard time writing multiple characters in ways that make them feel distinct. This story was well suited for this, however, focusing on a pair of siblings, an older teenage brother and his younger middle grade sister. Between the age and gender differences, they both felt very distinct. It was also great following their different experiences with Bletchley Park and the roles they took on there.

I also thought many of the side characters were very good, and I appreciated the way the authors managed to weave in real-world historical figures throughout the text. It would have been nearly impossible to not include these figures, but there’s always the danger, when writing fiction, that any real-life characters won’t blend well with their fictional counterparts. Not the case here! I think both authors well understood the truth in the saying “a little goes a long way” in this area.

Overall, this was a great middle grade read! Not being a middle grade reader myself, I may not have enjoyed it as much as the target audience, but this would be an easy book to recommend to large swaths of younger readers!

Kate’s Thoughts

I too am not much of a middle grade reader unless the topic is VERY interesting to me, but I have loved basically every book I’ve read by Ruth Sepetys so I had pretty high hopes for this one. Middle grade or not. And I also find books about World War II’s ally home fronts interesting in general, especially for places like Britain that were dealing with the constant fear of invasion. And finally, I had some vague knowledge about Bletchley Park thanks to stories about Alan Turing, as well as the miniseries “The Bletchley Circle”. All of that combined to make this a potentially good match for me, and overall it was.

Now I’m not super good at codes and puzzles, but I really enjoyed the way that the authors not only explained the importance of Bletchley Park and the goals that it had, it also gives really accessible examples of codes and ciphers to contextualize what kind of work they were doing (and how daunting the Enigma Machine was even for the most skilled of code breakers). Similarly to how she writes historical fiction books for teens, Supetys really has a skill for bringing out the most interesting and sometimes complex topics and parsing out that information for her audience, this one being middle grade. I also liked how she not only touched on the British code breakers through Jakob’s work (and the important work of messengers like Lizzie, who could be young teens!), but also the code work that more in the thick of it countries were doing, like Poland.

I also generally enjoyed the sibling relationship between Jakob and Lizzie, who butt heads sometimes but always have each other’s backs even in the most stressful of times. We have not only the stress of being at Bletchley, the stress of being in a place that could be bombed at any time, AND the question of where their espionage adjacent mother is, who disappeared in Poland and who Lizzie is convinced in still alive (while British intelligence is convinced she is a traitor). Watching them not only try to figure out how they can help in any way they can at Bletchley but ALSO try and hold on without knowing where their mother is was at times emotional, and both Sepetys and Sheinkin bring their talents together to create an informative and gripping family story.

I found “The Bletchley Riddle” to be a well done World War II read that history buffs of ANY age may like!

Serena’s Rating 8: A great balance of historical facts and exciting adventure, perfect for any middle grade or young adult readers who are interested in learning more about the lesser-known parts of WWII.

Kate’s Rating 8: An accessible and entertaining historical fiction for kids about code breaking, World War II, and siblings fighting against Nazis and surviving a war in more ways than one.

Book Club Questions

  1. How familiar were you with the history of Bletchley Park before reading this book?
  2. Did the setting of World War II London ring true for you?
  3. We follow the Novis siblings, Lizzie and Jacob, with their voices alternating between chapters. Did you find these two characters voices different enough as you read the book? Did you like one perspective more than another?
  4. What did you think about the friendships in this book?
  5. How did you like the inclusion of real life figures like Alan Turing? Did it feel like it fit, or did it feel distracting?
  6. What were your thoughts on the mystery Willa Novis and her disappearance? What about the code mysteries?

Reader’s Advisory

“The Bletchley Riddle” is included on the Goodreads lists “World War Two England”, and “Books Set in Bletchley Park”.

Next Book Club Pick: “The Hacienda” by Isabel Cañas

Kate’s Review: “Sisters in the Wind”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Sisters in the Wind” by Angeline Boulley

Publishing Info: Henry Holt & Co., September 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from NetGalley

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: From the instant New York Times bestselling author of Firekeeper’s Daughter and Warrior Girl Unearthed comes a daring new mystery about a foster teen claiming her heritage on her own terms.

Ever since Lucy Smith’s father died five years ago, “home” has been more of an idea than a place. She knows being on the run is better than anything waiting for her as a “ward of the state.” But when the sharp-eyed and kind Mr. Jameson with an interest in her case comes looking for her, Lucy wonders if hiding from her past will ever truly keep her safe.

Five years in the foster system has taught her to be cautious and smart. But she wants to believe Mr. Jameson and his “friend-not-friend,” a tall and fierce-looking woman who say they want to look after her.

They also tell Lucy the truth her father hid from her: She is Ojibwe; she has – had – a sister, and more siblings; a grandmother who’d look after her and a home where she would be loved.

But Lucy is being followed. The past has destroyed any chance of normal she has had, and now the secrets she’s hiding will swallow her whole and take away the future she always dreamed of.

Review: Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eARC of this novel!

I was so elated when I saw that Angeline Boulley had a new YA novel coming out this year! I saw a big poster for it at ALAAC25 and it made my day (sadly I wasn’t able to attend her talk this year, but if she comes back she will get priority). I finally sat down to read “Sisters in the Wind” a few months later, and I went in with very high hopes. I’ve so enjoyed her other YA thrillers, and I was hoping for another winner. And I got it.

Like Boulley’s other YA novels, “Sisters in the Wind” tackles some pretty heavy societal issues to go along with the thriller and mystery elements in this story. In this book, the mystery is less about her main character, Lucy, solving a whodunnit, and more about the reader starting to untangle Lucy’s secrets and her difficult and traumatic past as a foster child who has been dealing with the foster care system since her father’s death. To make matters for difficult, her identity as an Indigenous person (as her mother was Indigenous and her father left her mother and took Lucy with him when she was a baby) has been suppressed her entire life, which cuts her off not only from her culture but from a family that is shocked to find her once they finally do. Boulley is so good at presenting difficult topics about racism and oppression of Indigenous people in this country to her audience, dismantling dark histories and white supremacy and showing how it reverberates and harms people. The big topic in this book is the Indian Child Welfare Act and how Lucy’s situation was lost through the cracks, and also puts a focus on the foster system and how corrupt and traumatic it can be. We don’t know what exactly happened to Lucy when the story starts, just that she’s on the run and someone wants to kill her, but as we go through her history we find a girl failed by so many finding her way back to a community that was taken from her. I know that some people have said that they found this endless tragedy to be unrealistic, but I don’t agree because Lucy’s story isn’t exactly unique to real world experiences, whether it’s racism, sexual abuse, coercion and manipulation, or even human trafficking. It’s a hard read, but it’s, sadly, still relevant.

We also have a welcome return to Sugar Island and familiar faces, characters, and the return of one who was missing in “Warrior Girl Unearthed”. In the timeline “Sisters in the Wind” takes place after “Firekeeper’s Daughter”, but before “Warrior Girl Unearthed”, and we find Lucy meeting a Daunis who exists between the scrappy teen in the first book and the grounded and nurturing mentor in the second book. I really enjoyed how Boulley gave us some more insight into Daunis and her trajectory, including more insight into her relationship with Jamie from the first novel, and I thought that she worked it in better in this one than the previous one. But I also appreciated that the presence of Daunis and Jamie and their connection to Lucy didn’t overshadow Lucy’s story or characterization, and if anything it made her family connections and her journey to the home she never knew feel all the more poignant and powerful. It also filled in some gaps and questions that were in place once we got to “Warrior Girl Unearthed” regarding how some of these characters got to the point they were at in the time jump, some of it incredibly satisfying, some of it devastating (but still satisfying? Just trust me). I really hope we get more stories from Sugar Island and the characters who live in the pages of these books.

“Sisters in the Wind” is another impactful and emotional thriller from Angeline Boulley. It had me running a full gamut of feelings, with difficult subject matter but an ever present thread of hope and love moving throughout the narrative. Good golly I love these books.

Rating 9: Another emotional and important book about Indigenous life in America from Angeline Boulley, with a compelling mystery, familiar faces, and some moments of heartbreak, hope, and coming home.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Sisters in the Wind” is included on the Goodreads lists “Native American Lit”, and “ATY 2026: Indigenous Character or Author”.

Serena’s Review: “Murder Most Haunted”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Murder Most Haunted” by Emma Mason

Publishing Info: William Morrow Paperbacks, October 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: A grand country estate.
On her last day as a Detective, Midge McGowan is given the retirement present from a ticket to take part in a haunted house tour. She’ll have to spend the weekend before Christmas ghost-hunting in an isolated mansion with a group of misfits, including a know-it-all paranormal investigator and a has-been pop star.

An impossible crime.
It isn’t long before the tour starts to spiral out of control. Midge and the guests see an unsettling figure walking the grounds late at night. Then the unthinkable happens – someone is murdered in a room that’s been locked from the inside.

A Christmas they might not survive.
Heavy snow cuts them off from help, the house’s own dark secrets begin to surface, and Midge can’t shake the creeping sense that they are walking into a nightmare. Could a ghost really be responsible, or is the culprit one of the guests?

Review: I’m always looking for another mystery book or series to pick up, and this one sounded like a great place to start, what with its Christmas vibes on top of the haunted house. In one fell swoop, I covered two holidays at once (and timed my review for the month that falls between them!)

Ultimately, this one was a bit hit-and-miss for me. But one thing I unquestionably enjoyed was the overall vibe of the story. Some of the haunted house portions were the best part of the book, and I enjoyed the juxtaposition of gothic creepiness with the inherent cozy factor found in the Christmas holiday. The setting itself was perfectly set up for a closed-door mystery, and I think the author did an excellent job setting the stage for this story.

I both did and did not enjoy the cast of characters. On one hand, there was a lot of variety to be found here, and I enjoyed the interactions between the many strong personalities making up this group. There were plenty of good red herrings and potential suspects for the murder as well, which will surely keep readers on their toes until the last minute. However, I also found almost everyone incredibly unlikable in some way or another, which made it tough for me to become too invested. I was perfectly fine with any of them being the murderer because I didn’t care about any of them enough to want them to be innocent!

I did enjoy Midge for the most part, though I think she may be hit-or-miss for some readers. Much of the story is seeing her slowly come out of her shell and push through her own insecurities. She’s familiar with murder, but her experience was working in the background, so finding herself in the middle of an active crime scene and needing to stand up for her own opinions is clearly a new experience. I thought she was a refreshing change from the typical detectives you find in this kind of book, though I will say that there were times I felt like her insecurities overwhelmed other portions of her characterization.

Overall, this was a quick, satisfying read. I didn’t come away from it blown away, but I also was able to get through it quickly and enjoyed it for what it was. Readers looking for a good holiday mystery should probably check this one out (though I will warn about the characters being a bit on the weaker side overall).

Rating 7: While the characters were all a bit too unlikable for my taste, the vibes were on point for the holiday season (Halloween or Christmas—take your pick!)

Reader’s Advisory:

“Murder Most Haunted” isn’t currently on any Goodreads lists, but it should be on Christmas Mysteries.

Kate’s Review: “The Butcher and the Liar”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Butcher and the Liar” by S.L. Woeppel

Publishing Info: Books Fluent, September 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received a finished copy from the publicist

Where You Can Get This Book: Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: Daisy Bellon thinks she may have buried her skeletons forever. At thirty-five, she runs a butcher shop in a forgotten corner of Chicago, keeping her past locked away. But when an anonymous letter arrives, she’s thrust back to the day her life split in two.

At nine years old, Daisy meets Caleb Garcia, a boy who makes her believe in the possibility of friendship and happiness. But that same night, she stumbles upon her father dismembering a woman in their basement and becomes his unwilling apprentice, sworn to keep his monstrous secrets. When the victim’s ghost appears in Daisy’s room, she’s bound to a haunting legacy. To endure, Daisy weaves a web of lies, clinging to the light of Caleb’s friendship while slipping deeper into the darkness of her father’s shadow.

More than two decades later, following the arrival of the mysterious letter, someone close to Daisy is brutally murdered in an all-too-familiar fashion. Forced to confront the truth about her family and herself, Daisy must decide whether to let the darkness consume her—or to fight for love and redemption, even if it means revealing everything she’s tried to bury.

A haunting psychological thriller perfect for fans of Gillian Flynn, The Butcher and the Liar has mystery lovers and literary fiction readers on the edge of their seats.

Review: Thank you to Books Forward for sending me a copy of this novel!

I know that she is a darling of the modern thriller genre these days (and I do feel like it’s a well earned reputation), I have to admit that I have had mixed feelings about Gillian Flynn’s books. Loved “Dark Places”. Hated “Gone Girl”. Was middle of the road on “Sharp Objects”. I do kind of wish she’d come back and write another book like so many others do, but I also respect her for doing her own thing. Ultimately, if a book is compared to Gillian Flynn I’m a bit hesitant, both because I have mixed feelings about her works, but also because her works are so influential and hard to replicate. I wanted to check out “The Butcher and the Liar” by S.L. Woeppel when it ended up in our inbox because the premise sounded interesting (a woman made into an accomplice to her serial killer father’s crimes when she was a child trying to piece her life back together, oh my GOSH yes), but the Gillian Flynn angle made me say ‘okay sure, whatever you say’ because we’ve heard it so much. But as I was reading it I realized that it’s actually not a bad comparison.

I enjoyed the way that Woeppel combines a few different genres here to create something gritty yet dreamy, with thriller, historical fiction, family saga, and coming of age mixing up with a dash of the supernatural. We follow Daisy Bellon, the daughter of a notorious serial killer who murdered women over many years, and made Daisy an unwilling accomplice after she found him trying to dispose of a body of one of his victims. As a child she has only one friend, the boy next door named Caleb, whose friendship she always holds at arm’s length even as she grows to adore him… Until a ghost named Marina, who she believes is a victim of her father, latches on, and they too form a bond. In the present Daisy is an anonymous butcher in Chicago, who only opens up to her dear friend Miles. But when a neighbor is murdered in a similar fashion to her now imprisoned father’s M.O. she starts to wonder if she can ever really escape her past. It’s a lot of different vibes, but Woeppel is pretty good and finding the highlights of all the genres at their best to create a mystery, a ghost story, and a coming of age tale that mixes well and never feels too overstuffed. Whenever I would find myself questioning if it was too much going on, there would be things that made it clear that no, Woeppel knows what she’s doing with the different genres and it almost always came together in a satisfying manner.

I also really liked the two timeline narratives, flipping between Daisy in 2015 as she is dealing with potentially coming into the spotlight again with an art installation a new love interest is throwing and the murder of her neighbor, and the late 1980s into the early to mid 1990s as her father is murdering women and making her a witness. Daisy is such a complicated and damaged person who is both figuratively AND literally haunted (as the ghost of Marina is always by her side), and I found the way that she pushes others away and turns inwards upon herself in the past timeline to be very realistic and hard to read. And I really liked that she never falls into an all too common trope of ‘messy woman main character is bogged down by her messiness’, as I found Daisy to be very complicated but rarely frustrating in her journey. She’s traumatized, and there is lots of grace and nuance given to her. As we find out the connecting threads between the past and the present and what her motivation to be better has been, it comes together in the most satisfying way that left me both filled with heartache for her as well as satisfaction for how her story turn out, perhaps still a little messy, but not without hope for those who have done things that they regret and perhaps can’t fully understand. It’s such a bittersweet coming of age tale that went in ways I didn’t expect and it was really enjoyable.

“The Butcher and the Liar” should be on peoples radars if they like thrillers, coming of age tales, and complicated main characters. Maybe bring tissues too.

Rating 8: A haunting coming of age novel about a girl grappling with her dark family history and the part she played, “The Butcher and the Liar” is an emotional story about trauma and redemption.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Butcher and the Liar” isn’t on any relevant Goodreads lists as of now, but it would fit in on “Best Coming of Age Thriller”.

Serena’s Review: “Murder at Donwell Abbey”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Murder at Donwell Abbey” by Vanessa Kelly

Publishing Info: Kensington Books, November 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Emma’s spirits are elevated after she and husband George Knightley host a joyful holiday celebration at the Hartfield estate. But it’s instantly a bitter January when her father makes an unexpected announcement—he and Miss Hetty Bates have decided to marry. Not only must Emma relinquish her role as mistress of the household, but also accept the reality that the excitable Miss Bates will become her stepmother . . .

More unwanted news arrives during an extravagant betrothal ball at Donwell Abbey, the grand Knightley estate where Emma and George will soon permanently reside. Nearly every villager in Highbury revels in the dazzling affair—except Emma’s hardworking lady’s maid, Prudence Parr. To Emma’s horror, Prudence is found dead, sprawled across the stones of the library terrace . . .

The woman’s tragic fall is quickly ruled a terrible accident and whispers circulate around personal troubles leading up to her untimely demise. But Emma’s instincts tell her that something far more sinister is at play. Now, Highbury’s matchmaker-turned-sleuth vows to outwit a cunning criminal before an innocent man loses his freedom—or Donwell Abbey plunges into a darker mystery . . .

Previously Reviewed: “Murder in Highbury”

Review: It’s kind of funny that the two mystery series that I’m currently keeping up to date on are both based on reinterpretations of Jane Austen characters! They’re also very different, which is probably what makes the entire situation doable! Given how much I enjoyed the first book in this series, I was excited to see how the sequel would turn out.

Ultimately, I didn’t love this one quite as much as the first one, but it was also a solid read overall! For one thing, this book begins to firmly move the characters and story beyond the bounds of what we were given in the original Emma. There were hints that Miss Bates and Mr. Woodhouse were moving into new territory at the end of the first book, but here we get confirmation with the announcement of their engagement. With this upcoming change, Emma and Mr. Knightley are free to begin moving back to Knightley’s home of Donwell Abbey, and the location of much of the action of this book. It was great fun getting to see a new side of Emma and Knightley as they navigate a new phase of their marriage. Emma, in particular, was quick to rise to the challenge of becoming the mistress of a new household.

With this relocation, we also were introduced to a whole host of new characters, both side characters and the victim and potential suspects. There were both pros and cons to this influx of new characters. For the positives, I really liked all of the new additions. They all felt like characters who could have existed in Austen’s original story but simply hadn’t been mentioned. I particularly enjoyed the housekeeper of Donwell and her team-ups with Emma at various points. However, the downside of all of these new additions was the simple fact that by having so many new characters, the book had less time to focus on the beloved originals.

While I enjoyed the Emma/Knightley scenes we had, I do wish we had more. I also would have liked to see more of Harriet and Mrs. Weston as well. That said, Miss Bates played a surprisingly large role in the story. I do think that some of her actions/reactions were a bit out of character (indeed, Vanessa Kelly didn’t devote entire pages to blocks of rambling dialogue from her, but I guess I can excuse that), but I still enjoyed seeing her in this sidekick role.

I also think the mystery itself was a bit predictable. Pretty much right from the start, I had a finger on who was involved in this entire situation. There were a few twists and turns throughout, but many of the major beats were telegraphed fairly clearly. That said, I really liked the numerous action scenes, something I wasn’t really expecting to find in this sort of historical mystery book.

Overall, this was an excellent entry in the series! I enjoyed the fact that it began to move the story beyond the confines of what we have from the original, and I’m excited to see even more of that in future books!

Rating 8: The mystery was a bit predictable, but I was mostly here for all the great Emma action, and that I got in spades!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Murder at Donwell Abbey” isn’t currently on any Goodreads lists, but it should be on Jane Austen Mysteries.

Book Club Review: “My Best Friend’s Exorcism”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

We are part of a group of librarian friends who have had an ongoing book club running for the last several years. Each “season” (we’re nerds) we pick a theme and each of us chooses a book within that theme for us all to read. Re-visiting some of our past themes, we’re once again pulling genres from a hatch and matching them together in one book. For this blog, we will post a joint review of each book we read for book club. We’ll also post the next book coming up in book club. So feel free to read along with us or use our book selections and questions in your own book club!

Book: “My Best Friend’s Exorcism” by Grady Hendrix

Publishing Info: Quirk Books, May 2016

Where Did We Get This Book: Kate owns it

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Mix-and-Match Genres: Horror and Humor

Book Description: Abby and Gretchen have been best friends since fifth grade, when they bonded over a shared love of E.T., roller-skating parties, and scratch-and-sniff stickers. But when they arrive at high school, things change. Gretchen begins to act….different. And as the strange coincidences and bizarre behavior start to pile up, Abby realizes there’s only one possible explanation: Gretchen, her favorite person in the world, has a demon living inside her. And Abby is not about to let anyone or anything come between her and her best friend. With help from some unlikely allies, Abby embarks on a quest to save Gretchen. But is their friendship powerful enough to beat the devil?

Kate’s Thoughts

This was a re-read for me, and I was VERY curious to see how book club would like it given that I’m one of the few people who likes horror in our group. Well, it wasn’t a favorite, but it gave me an excuse to go on long diatribes about possession horror and demon horror and how its heydays line up with times of religious anxiety in this country, whether it’s Satanic Panic or the implementation of Vatican II or countless other examples. So, I had a fun time re-reading it and going into a TED talk for all of my oh so patient friends.

Me going on about Vatican II, the Warrens, and how the book version of “The Exorcist” was basically saying Reagan was taken over by a demon because Blatty wanted the world to know her Mom was a WHORE BECAUSE SHE WAS DIVORCED! (source)

This was a re-read for me, as I originally read it back in 2016 when it first came out, and it was fun to go back to it for a few reasons. For one, I still enjoy the story, and think that it’s a really enjoyable deconstruction of the possession trope by making the hero of the day not a religious authority, but a teenage girl who loves her best friend and wants to help her. I also still enjoy how Hendrix can capture the voice of teen girl characters, and how he made interesting comparisons between demons being cruel and teenage girls doing the same. And the 80s aesthetic is still fun (these days it may be a bit more played out than it was nine years ago). But it’s also interesting because after a re-read I realized that “My Best Friend’s Exorcism” probably isn’t my favorite Hendrix novel anymore even though up until my re-read I thought that it was. It’s still fun! It’s also very much a Gen X white guy fumbling some themes, but it’s also interesting because I noticed this because of the growth we’ve seen in his stories when it comes to these things. And it still has some truly scary beats while also being a bit bubblegum and joyful. It’s still a fun read.

“My Best Friend’s Exorcism” was a fun choice for book club that fostered a fair amount of conversation in our group.

Kate’s Rating 8: A fun re-read that still does a solid deconstruction of the possession trope with the power of female friendship at the forefront.

Book Club Questions

  1. How does this book compare to other demonic possession stories you have read or seen?
  2. What did you think of Gretchen and Abby’s friendship in the way it was written? Did it feel like a realistic teen girl relationship?
  3. Did the time period of the 1980s and the references bolster the story up, or did you find it to be a hindrance to the story overall?
  4. Hendrix has said that he rooted this story in the time of his youth. What do you think this story would look like if it had been set in a different time period?
  5. This book was picked because of the prompts horror and humor. What parts stood out as scariest to you? What parts did you find funny?
  6. Who would you recommend this book to?

Reader’s Advisory

“My Best Friend’s Exorcism” is included on the Goodreads lists “80s Flashback (Current Books with 1980s Settings)”, and “Horror With Retro Vibes”.

Next Book Club Pick: “The Bletchley Riddle” by Ruta Sepetys & Steven Sheinkin

Kate’s Review: “The Mad Wife”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Mad Wife” by Meagan Church

Publishing Info: S0urcebooks Landmark, September 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publisher

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: They called it hysteria. She called it survival.

Lulu Mayfield has spent the last five years molding herself into the perfect 1950s housewife. Despite the tragic memories that haunt her and the weight of exhausting expectations, she keeps her husband happy, her household running, and her gelatin salads the talk of the neighborhood. But after she gives birth to her second child, Lulu’s carefully crafted life begins to unravel.

When a new neighbor, Bitsy, moves in, Lulu suspects that something darker lurks behind the woman’s constant smile. As her fixation on Bitsy deepens, Lulu is drawn into a web of unsettling truths that threaten to expose the cracks in her own life. The more she uncovers about Bitsy, the more she questions everything she thought she knew―and soon, others begin questioning her sanity. But is Lulu truly losing her mind? Or is she on the verge of discovering a reality too terrifying to accept?

In the vein of The Bell Jar and The Hours, The Mad Wife weaves domestic drama with psychological suspense, so poignant and immersive, you won’t want to put it down.

Review: Thank you to Sourcebooks Landmark for sending me an ARC of this novel!

I have watched “Mad Men” a couple of times with my husband (I haven’t seen the full series like he has but I’ve seen plenty), and one of my favorite characters is Betty Draper. I like her so much I named one of our kittens after her. I love how messy she is, I love how complex she is, I don’t love how she treats her kids but it fits with her characterization, and I ultimately feel super, super bad for her. Because the great tragedy of her is that she is a person who was forced into a lifestyle she didn’t want as a homemaker with little to no agency (plus all the trauma from her childhood. Cycles keep on cycling!). Which wasn’t uncommon for many of the women in those positions during that time period. I kept thinking about Betty Draper as I read “The Mad Wife” by Meagan Church, which is also about a homemaker being forced to put on a pleasant face and a perfect facade, until it starts to break her.

There is a bit of a mystery here in this historical fiction thriller. Lulu is a 1950s housewife living in an idyllic suburban community, and while her outer veneer is perfection, she feels incredible pressure to keep a tidy house, keep a high standing in the social circle, and to keep her husband and son happy with her support, love, and care. Right around the time she gives birth to her second child, new neighbors move into the neighborhood, and Lulu thinks that something strange is going on with them, especially the wife, Bitsy. It’s a plot ripe for the picking when it comes to domestic thriller, and Lulu is a great protagonist because while we are inside her head and are seeing the strange things she is seeing, she is also more and more unreliable as the story goes on as all of the pressures of idealized 1950s femininity and homemaking start to catch up with her. It makes for some well done suspense and tension, and getting further into Lulu’s unraveling also ups the unease to make it all the more unnerving.

But it’s Lulu’s plight trying to be the perfect wife in a suburban nuclear family that really made this work for me, as we are constantly reminded and shown how little agency she has as a wife, as a mother, and even as a woman just trying to live her life. So much of her identity is wrapped up in perfection that she can just barely achieve (or not achieve, as no one is perfect even when society wants them to be with threat of judgement and shunning if they are not) that when things do start to come undone, not only is she worried about losing her friends, or her marriage, she also has to worry about other horrifying consequences as a ‘hysterical’ woman. There are talks about pills with no real explanation as to what to expect, involuntary psych holds, and even lobotomies for women who are deemed mentally unfit, as well as women who feel so trapped that they end up killing themselves to escape it all. I found myself fearing for Lulu, especially as more details are slowly revealed (one bit which I KIND of saw coming, but still absolutely gutted me). It’s a start reminder that these supposed ‘good old days’ that so many people want to force us back were really not so good for so many people.

“The Mad Wife” is harrowing and a well done thriller tale about a woman who is treading towards the end of her rope. I quite enjoyed it.

Rating 8: A slow burn of unease and a commentary on the housewife ideal from decades ago (as it makes an insidious comeback in modern times), “The Mad Wife” is haunting and suspenseful and a well done domestic thriller.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Mad Wife” is included on the Goodreads lists “Uncanny 1950s Ladies”, and “Novels about Motherhood”.