Category: Serena’s Reviews

Serena’s Review: “A Secret in the Garden”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Secret in the Garden” by Jeneane O’Riley

Publishing Info: Bloom Books, February 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Some secrets were never meant to be unearthed.

Perched on a windswept cliff, Blackwood Manor looms like a dark monument to a mysterious family. Behind its grand iron gates, one part of the estate has been left to rot since the tragic death of Hester Blackwood: the once-glorious conservatory, now choked by vines and shattered glass. The rest of the family is gone—only her brooding son, Jasper, remains, the heir to a weapons empire.

Desperate to save her job and out of options, botanist Eliza Arnold makes a bold gamble—drive to the manor and beg the elusive millionaire for a donation. Jasper agrees…on one chilling condition: restore the conservatory. Alone. No help. No leaving.

But the manor is not empty.

As Eliza battles thorns and secrets, a magnetic tension builds between her and Jasper—dark, dangerous, and impossible to ignore. And something else stirs among the roots and ruins…whispers in the walls, confusing disturbances, and a presence watching her every move.

The deeper Eliza digs, the more she uncovers a garden of grief, longing…and desire. Because in Blackwood Manor, even buried things can bloom again.

Review: I’ve had a lot of luck with gothic fantasy novels recently, so I guess I was due for one to not hit for me eventually. And, perhaps not surprisingly, it was the contemporary one that did it. To be fair, there are plenty of contemporary romances that I do really enjoy; this one just didn’t hold up.

Much of this book didn’t work for me, so I’m struggling a bit with the positives. I’ll say that the overall concept was appealing. Gothic fantasy/romances often have a similar premise: some call to action brings in the protagonist to a mysterious manor/castle/what-have-you where they discover much is not as it seems, including, often, the truth regarding some sort of brooding caretaker. So this one set up in a similar way, and the book took no time in getting our main character on location. The story moves quickly, so I was well into it before really settling into why it wasn’t working.

I think my problems with this book come down to two factors: structure of the plot and characterization. To start with the plot, quite quickly the book settles into a pattern of every day: Eliza gardens and Jasper broods. For all that we’re meant to believe there is a great mystery brewing here, the story itself does very little to move this plot forward. Honestly, it all became very tiresome, very quickly. Gothic novels are usually a bit on the slower pace, devoting a lot of time to the development of atmosphere and tension before the inevitable payoff, often late in the story. But here, nothing that was going on contributed to this atmosphere. Instead, it all felt tedious, and I was left frustrated that Eliza was so passive with regards to the mysteries surrounding her circumstances.

And this leads into my primary issue with the book: the characters and the romance itself. First, Eliza. Like I said, she’s an incredibly passive character, and even if you try to make the case that this is part of her emotional arc, I don’t think it makes her a particularly compelling or sympathetic character to follow. While the story sets up a deeper backstory for her, one that includes past traumas that would reflect her behaviors today, I don’t think enough was done to really address these things. Eliza’s thoughts and choices, particularly with regards to the romantic interest, remained deeply unhealthy throughout.

And look, I’m not a dark romance fan for a reason. I get that it works for others, but it very much doesn’t for me. And I think this book strayed a bit too far in this direction for my particular taste. See, there is a very important distinction to be found between fantasy romance and contemporary romance, for me. In a fantasy world, life is often violent, dangerous, and cruel. In this way, the characters that people these worlds have very different views of life and the ways in which death plays a role in their everyday life. In a romantasy, for example, if a romantic lead is slightly murderous, this is often completely reasonable, even necessary, for survival in this world; an attractive trait, to boot, for the heroine in these books. But here, we have a contemporary setting, a romantic interest who seems quite murderous at times, and a passive heroine who seems not only not warned off by these toxic traits, but actively turned on by it all. And combined with her other traumas, I was left feeling like Eliza needed therapy more than a boyfriend. And if she did find love, Jasper is the last person she should be turning to.

Beyond this, the romance itself was very insta-lust-y. Jasper has been a recluse, but for some reason, he’s immediately into Eliza. And like I said, Eliza’s interest in him is portrayed as quite unhealthy, the speed of which it occurs only solidifying this point.

Now, much of what I described above is probably quite tame as far as contemporary dark romance goes, so it’s all quite subjective. If you enjoy this style of romance, all of these complaints may actually be points in its favor.

That said, I also think the writing itself was quite juvenile at times, too often spiraling into repetitive thoughts spinning through our heroine’s head again and again. At best, I felt distanced from the story itself, and at worst, downright bored. Even for dark romance readers, I have to imagine there are better options out there.

Rating 6: Unfortunately, even the gothic setting couldn’t save this one for me. The characters were unlikable in different ways, and the romance relied too heavily on insta-lust.

Serena’s Review: “Agnes Aubert’s Mystical Cat Shelter”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Agnes Aubert’s Mystical Cat Shelter” by Heather Fawcett

Publishing Info: Del Rey, February 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Agnes Aubert leads a meticulously organized life—and she likes it that way. As the proudly type-A manager of a much-needed cat rescue charity, she has devoted her life to finding forever homes for lost cats.

But after she is forced to move the cat shelter, Agnes learns that her new landlord is using her charity as a front—for an internationally renowned and thoroughly disreputable magic shop. Owned by the disorganized—not to mention self-absorbed, irritating, but also decidedly handsome—Havelock Renard, magician and failed Dark Lord, the shop draws magical clientele from around the world, partly due to the quality of Havelock’s illicit goods as well as their curiosity about his shadowy past and rumors of his incredible powers. Agnes’s charity offers the perfect cover for illegal magics.

Agnes couldn’t care less about the shop—magical intrigue or not, there are cats to be rescued. But when an enemy from Havelock’s past surfaces, the magic shop—and more importantly, the cat shelter—are suddenly in jeopardy. To save the shelter, will Agnes have to set aside her social conscience and protect the man who once tried to bring about the apocalypse—and is now trying to steal her heart?

Review: The ways this book immediately landed on the top of my TBR list are numerous and probably obvious. Heather Fawcett, author of the awesome Emily Wilde trilogy? Yes. Title/cover/subject matter having to do with cats? Hell yes! The only factor holding me back a bit, however, was the cozy factor, as too often I find myself bouncing off that subgenre, especially when it strays into the “day in the life” type of coziness. Ultimately, this book was a bit more of a mixed bag than I had hoped, but I also enjoyed it for the most part.

To start, I think I have to acknowledge the basic fact that this book’s subject matter carried me through a lot of complaints that I may have had with it had it been focused on some other topics. Per my usual preferences, I struggled with the day-in-the-life moments of this book. However, as here these moments focused on cats and the quirky personalities of the various cats in residence, I found myself smiling and nodding along much of the time. What can I say? Cats are charming, and what could have been slow-moving scenes were helped by my inclination to identify the various cats with my own real-world companions. That said, if I was less interested in cats, I do think some of these cozy moments were a bit lackluster. The book had a lot of charm, but I’m not sure it had an equal amount of heart.

This extended to our main character and the love interest. Perhaps it isn’t fair to compare these two to Emily and Wendell from the Emily Wilde series, but it’s unfortunately a reality that must be dealt with by all authors who find great success with a trilogy. Comparisons are inevitable. Unfortunately, neither of these two characters quite lived up to the previous two. There were clear, defining traits about them both, but, again, it felt like there was no true depth to be found or connection to these characters to be made.

Agnes is a very different person than Emily, and once I realized that and I was better able to settle in to the sort of character I was following. I particularly enjoyed the way the book grappled with her grief over the loss of her husband years prior. I just recently read a book (The Trident and the Pearl) where this same topic was handled and, in my opinion, bungled badly. But here, Fawcett devotes just the right amount of time and depth of feeling to give this prior relationship its due without undercutting the development of Agnes’s new relationship.

What I liked the most about this book, however, was the magic and setting of this world. In many ways it reminded me of Howl’s Moving Castle in the best of ways. Of course, much of this was also tied closely to the actual plot of the book and thus more disconnected from the day-in-the-life portions that I didn’t connect with as well. Here, the book established a nice balance between whimsy and dark menace and even took a few wild turns towards the end that I didn’t expect at all!

I also liked the romance, for the most part. It felt very familiar, but in a good way. Again, the Howl vibes are clear, and as long as readers clearly disconnect these new characters from Emily/Wendell, I think the romance works well. That said, I do think the book would have benefited from a bit more page time devoted to these two interacting with one another. While their love story was slow and sweet, looking back on how much page time they actually have with one another, it’s fairly limited.

So, I liked this book, but didn’t love it. It wasn’t nearly the high of the Emily Wilde books, unfortunately. Everything was just slightly…less. Part of this may come down to my own preferences with cozy fantasy, but I also think the character work simply wasn’t as strong here. And for books like these, they really live and die on the strength of the leads. That said, it was by no means a bad time, and I definitely think fans of Fawcett’s other books should check this out, as well as any/all cozy fantasy readers!

Rating 8: The cats definitely carried a decent portion of this book! However, I don’t think the characters were quite as strong as I would have liked.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Agnes Aubert’s Mystical Cat Shelter” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Clowders, Glarings: Cat Hoarding, etc. in Fiction and Best Cozy Fantasy Books.

Serena’s Review: “A Rose of Blood and Binding”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Rose of Blood and Binding” by Claire Legrand

Publishing Info: Sourcebooks Casablanca, February 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: The battered Middlemist can barely hold itself together. Olden monsters terrorize the land. The gods are awakening from their ancient slumber, but if the vengeful Kilraith destroys them, all will be lost. And it’s up to the Ashbourne sisters—demigods, daughters of the goddess Kerezen—to stop him.

But the sisters are spread thin. Gemma and Talan travel the world in a desperate search for the gods. In the capital, Farrin and Ryder shelter countless refugees amid roiling unrest. And Mara Ashbourne, bound to the Middlemist and longing for a home she can never return to, is just trying to survive.

Every day is chaos as Mara battles invaders and fights to protect her fellow Roses. The presence of librarian Gareth Fontaine—assigned to aid the Roses’ war efforts—doesn’t help. Charming, brilliant, far too confident, and annoyingly reverent of the Roses—Mara most of all—he’s a distraction Mara can’t avoid or afford. Especially since she can see the shadows of Mhorghast brimming underneath his dazzling smile. Shadows of violence and shame that she knows all too well. Shadows that terrify her more than any monster.

As Mara and Gareth search the Old Country for Kilraith’s final three curse-anchors, a slow-burning passion born of sorrow and solace sparks between them, one that could finally bring Mara to the very home she longs for…or drive her toward the dark fate she secretly craves, and bring both worlds crashing down alongside her.

Previously Reviewed: “A Crown of Ivy and Glass” and “A Song of Ash and Moonlight”

Review: I’ve had a bit of a bumpy ride with this trilogy. Overall, I kept wanting to really love it, but finding myself struggling more often than not. My biggest stumbling block was the main characters in both of the first two books, each seeming to merge into the same self-loathing, fairly whiny person when all was said and done. And here, in the last book, we finally got to follow Mara, the brave warrior daughter who has been an absolute hit during her cameos in the other books. The thought of her getting the same treatment…oof.

But before I get into all of my feelings there, let’s go over other parts of this book and how it holds up as a novel itself and as a conclusion to this trilogy. First of all, I want to again go back to the often-visited trough of writing quality with regards to this trilogy. Like the first two books, this one was tightly written, balancing both detailed world-building and some truly poetic quieter moments of inner reflection. For a series that has dealt so strongly with mental health issues, I want to commend the author for exploring some truly complicated subjects without getting caught up in purple prose or simply telling readers about these struggles, rather than showing them on the page.

Further, I enjoyed the epic nature of much of the plot. As the trilogy has progressed, the world and lore have greatly expanded, so much so that by this book, we are dealing with gods and their fallout so often that it makes the political dramas of the first book seem a bit trite in comparison. Just remember, the first book was likened to “Bridgerton”…. And then here, by the end, we’re fully in epic fantasy with massive, galactic conflict taking up the majority of the plot. It’s truly a wild swing, but one that I think Legrand pulls off well. I’d definitely read more epic fantasy from her!

Unfortunately, I once again struggled with the main character and the romance. At this point, I think these books just aren’t for me as far as my own preferences go with character reading and romance. Critically, however, I do think that the manner in which Legrand explored important mental themes ultimately resulted in her writing three characters who not only sounded very similar, but all dealt with (or didn’t deal with) their individual mental health struggles in exactly the same way. All three: pushing away those they love, incredible levels of self-loathing, an unfortunate tendency to come across as whiny in their own narratives. It was incredibly frustrating each and every time, and all the more so here.

Mara’s story is clearly tragic, being taken away from her family so young and the scars this would leave on her psyche. Further, I loved the exploration of her relationship with the Warden, a deeply unhealthy bond of manipulation and dependence. But for all of these unique factors, and the fact that we’ve had two other books in which to see Mara presented as a strong, brave warrior character, Mara’s narration sounded almost exactly the same as the previous two characters. I can’t speak to every aspect of mental health that has been covered in these books, but from a writing level, it’s frustrating to see these topics covered in a way that now only seems repetitive. Mara’s experiences of her struggles are almost identical to her sisters’, and her arc through the story thus feels incredibly familiar and tired. What’s more, people are more than their mental health struggles, and I have to imagine that different people will respond differently to different challenges. But here we had essentially a bait-and-switch where everything we saw about Mara before was wiped away beneath the burdens of yet more self-loathing and self-isolation, just like the other two.

As for the romance, I was a bit lukewarm on this as well. There was nothing wrong with this relationship, but I do think it suffered a bit in comparison to the more deep and intricately complicated relationship we saw between Mara and the Warden.

Overall, this book was only fine, and I’m truly sad to say it. I was very nervous going in and, unfortunately, that now feels well warranted. Like I said, I do think Legrand is a strong writer, and I enjoyed her character work with pretty much any character whose head we were NOT in at the moment. I’ll definitely consider giving her books another chance, but if there is another strong focus on mental health (for all that it’s a worthy topic!), I might have to pass. I’ve already read that book three times now.

Rating 7: As an epic fantasy, I think this succeeds. But on a character level, I struggled in the same way I did with the first two.

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Rose of Blood and Binding” can be found on these Goodreads lists: All the New Romantasy Books Arriving in February 2026 and “Bind” Titles.

Serena’s Review: “Crown of War and Shadow”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Crown of War and Shadow” by J.R. Ward

Publishing Info: Bramble, February 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: The Fulcrum is failing, and demons are slipping into the mortal world, stalking the night. No one is safe. Especially not Sorrel. An orphan and an outcast, she’s spent her whole life within the walls of her small village, ostracized for her mystical abilities. She wants to survive…and maybe find somewhere she can call her true home. But Fate has other plans.

Sorrel has been chosen. Cursed. She must cross the Badlands to return the Queen’s crown and convince the fearsome female to save their world from destruction. Well aware she’s no brave hero, Sorrel makes a dangerous deal with Merc, a brooding, commanding mercenary known only by his unscrupulous profession. The deal? A night in his bed that she will never forget, in exchange for her safe passage. But Merc has secrets of his own, and even though passion runs hot between them, enemies are around every corner, and danger and betrayal threaten at every turn.

Review: One of my fellow book club librarians is a big fan of this author, so I’ve been wanting to check out her books for a while. That said, her primary series is, uh, long. So I was excited to see she was releasing the first book in a brand new series this spring, an excellent place to jump in!

Overall, this book didn’t quite live up to my expectations. That said, I can definitely see the author’s strengths, so without having read her other books, I can’t say whether this was a diversion from quality or not. But to start, her writing is incredibly “readable” right from the start. Readers are quickly brought into this world and given enough information about it, its history, and our main character to quickly become invested in what was going on. So much so that there was one side character who, I believe, only appears in one brief scene who later brought me to tears, all in the first quarter of the book!

I also liked the broad strokes of Sorrel’s character. Unlike many romantasy heroines, she didn’t actively annoy me much of the time. That said, she also fell into a few too many silly tropes. We have her repeatedly denying her own beauty, impulsively throwing herself into dangerous situations where she is actively unskilled, and then miraculously discovering previously unknown abilities, etc., etc. You get the gist. It was all quite familiar and predictable, if still well executed overall.

I did enjoy the slow reveals of her history, even if it felt like these were too easily telegraphed at times. Naturally, it doesn’t make sense for Sorrel to put things together as quickly as the reader, but it was still frustrating to watch her stumble around for as long as she did. Part of this speaks to the pacing issues I had, however. This is a long book, and by the middle portion, I was definitely feeling it. The mysteries that had been hinted at were still only the barest brushes, even if the reader was already a mile ahead of things. And instead of making progress, the book became bogged down in tedious traveling adventures. Sure, there were action-packed scenes happening on the page, but the actual plot itself felt mired in tedium.

This was then contrasted by the breakneck speed of the romance, which jumped immediately into insta-lust on both sides. I liked the general idea of the MMC; he even had some interesting backstory that I enjoyed learning about. But the story opened with a truly ridiculous misunderstanding between these two characters and proceeded to just…go with it. The entire thing could have been cleared up so easily, and it was just such a stupid element that was thrown in as a wrench between these two understanding each other. Honestly, I rolled my eyes so many times at both of these characters.

Overall, I didn’t love this book. The author is clearly talented, and I think there are the bones of a good story to be found here. Unfortunately, this was badly in need of an editor to trim down the fat and focus the story on the plot that actually mattered. With some adjustments to pacing, both of the romance and the actual plot, this could have been a much more fun read. That said, I’d guess that this will still hit well for fans of this author, so if you’ve enjoyed her other books, this is probably for you!

Rating 7: At least a hundred pages longer than it needed to be, this book is a key example of failing to follow the mantra “sometimes you get more with less.”

Reader’s Advisory:

“Crown of War and Shadow” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Epic High Fantasy/Romance/Mythology in 2026 and 2026 Most Anticipated Romance Releases.

Serena’s Review: “Weavingshaw”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Weavingshaw” by Heba Al-Wasity

Publishing Info: Del Rey, February

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: Three years ago, Leena Al-Sayer awoke with a terrible power.She can see the dead.Since then, she has hidden herself from the world, knowing that if she ever reveals her curse she will be locked away in an asylum.

When her beloved brother, Rami, falls fatally ill, Leena is faced with a terrible CHOICE: Let him die or buy the expensive medicine that will save his life by bartering the only valuable thing she has—her secret.

The Saint of Silence, a ruthless merchant who trades in confessions and is shrouded in unearthly rumors of cruelty and power, accepts her bargain, for a deadly price. Leena must find the ghost of Percival Avon, the last lord of Weavingshaw—or lose her freedom to the Saint forever.

As Leena’s search takes her and the Saint to Weavingshaw, she finds the estate and the surrounding moors to be living things—hungry for blood and sacrifice. Fighting against Weavingshaw’s might, Leena must also fight her growing pull toward the enigmatic Saint himself, whose connection to Percival Avon remains a mystery.

As the house begins to entomb them, time is running out on their desperate hunt for answers. For Leena has come to see that here in Weavingshaw, the dead are not hushed—and some secrets are better left buried with them.

Review: Gothic fantasy/horror has to be one of the more reliable subgenres for my own particular reading preferences. As long as the correct atmosphere is struck, the story will always start out a mile ahead of others. And here, that note was struck right away. This world is one of grim realities where the average person is caught between corporations trying to drain every last ounce from them and political forces in various countries working to subdue rebellions. Further, their history is one made up of demons and dark magic. And their only salvation? A mysterious trader of secrets for wealth, bargains that can turn deadly more often than not. And that’s not even getting into the location of Weavingshaw itself (to be fair, and to set expectations, the book doesn’t even move to this location until about halfway through) or the greater world-building/magical reveals that come later in the story.

And, of course, both of the main characters have their own ties to dark magic. The book takes place entirely from Leena’s perspective (again and always: well done for avoiding the trap of dual POVs that seem to always lead to a “telling” style of writing as far as relationship development!), so we learn a lot about her abilities to see ghosts. I really liked the various ways that her abilities were used, not only to move the plot along, but to bring together story elements and important pieces of characters’ histories. She was also a great character beyond her magic, determined to save her family and unwilling to fall under the thumb of her powerful employer. The slow-burn relationship between her and the Saint was so well done. These two have no reason to trust one another, especially Leena. It’s only slowly, as the story progresses, that she begins to understand the deeper, more tragic layers hidden beneath the Saint’s icy exterior.

I also really liked the Saint himself. It would have been so easy for him to come across as yet another shadow daddy love interest. There are definitely a few familiar notes of that even now. However, the book does a great job of including various other POV chapters sprinkled throughout that further develop his story, giving us greater insights into his past and motivations. While he and Leena grow slowly closer to one another, neither gives up their own goals. I can’t say too much about this character, as much of his story is a mystery that is only slowly revealed, but I loved what we got from him and the set up for the next book.

While the book starts out with a fairly straightforward setup (Leena indebted and working for the mysterious Saint of Silence), I was honestly surprised by the direction the story took. Given the title and cover, I went in expecting a gothic, haunted house story. But, like I said above, we don’t even get to Weavingshaw until about halfway through the story. And even then, it was much more of a setting for the plot than an integral part itself (usually in gothic stories, houses are a character in and of themselves, to some degree). Again, I don’t want to spoil the reveals, but this is much more a developed fantasy world than I had expected initially.

I really enjoyed this one! While it wasn’t quite what I was expecting, in many ways, it was even better for these changes! The slow-burn romance was well done, and the character work remained solid throughout. The story definitely ends in a setup for the next book, so readers should be aware of that going in. However, for me, this just made me all the more eager to get to the sequel as soon as possible!

Rating 9: Not what I was expecting in the best way possible! Gothic fantasy, but with a more developed fantasy world and swoon-worthy slow-burn romance!

Reader’s Advisory:

“Weavingshaw” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Gothic Fantasy and 2026 Most Anticipated Romantasy & Fantasy Romance Releases.

Serena’s Review: “Nightshade and Oak”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Nightshade and Oak” by Molly O’Neill

Publishing Info: Orbit, February 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: When Malt, the goddess of death, is accidentally turned into a human by a wayward spell, she finds she’s ill-equipped to deal with the trials of a mortal life.

After all, why would a goddess need to know how to gather food or light a fire?

Trapped in a body that’s frustratingly feeble, she’s forced to team up with Bellis, warrior daughter of Boudicca on a perilous journey across Roman-occupied Britain to the afterlife to try to restore her powers. As animosity turns to attraction, these two very different women must learn to work together if they are to have any hope of surviving their quest.

Review:I had read and enjoyed (for the most part) the first book I read from this author. But I’ll be honest, it was the mention of Boudicca and the promise of more Welsh/British folklore that really drew me in. And while I did struggle with some tone, pacing, and character work, I was very pleased with this aspect of the story! In many ways, the story reads as historical fantasy, with the author drawing from a real-world person (Boudicca) but then extrapolating from that into a wholly imagined story revolving around her daughter.

Of course, given that Boudicca’s story is one of rebellion and warfare, the themes of this book heavily focus on the violence, loss, and tragedy of war. One of the strongest scenes in the book was actually the first chapter, where we see the remains of a battlefield through the eyes of the goddess. This was a very poignant scene and definitely set up the story well.

That said, it did lead into one of my struggle points for this read: inconsistency with regards to tone and themes. After this amazing first scene, the book takes a sharp turn towards a more cozy, travelogue sort of story, following our two characters as they traverse the land. Much of this next forty percent or so of the story was made up of these smaller, more “slice of life”-like scenes. Don’t get me wrong, I really enjoyed the version of the book we had here. Much of this time was devoted to Mallt’s struggles to understand the ins and outs of existing as a mortal.

But then, about halfway through the book, the story took a massive shift back to the darker, more grim tones that the first chapter established. And again, I did not enjoy this portion of the book. Indeed, I think it had a lot of good things to say with these themes. However, the end result was that the pacing and tone of the story shifted entirely halfway through, which made for an awkward reading experience. Further, the very last portion of the book was made up of chapters that bounced back and forth between these cozy and darker tones, with the story feeling like it never really settled into what it wanted.

I also struggled a bit with the characters. For the most part, I really enjoyed Mallt. I thought her struggles with mortality were interesting and provided her with an excellent arc for the story. However, she also could be frustrating and annoying as she dealt with the limitations put upon her. I was also disappointed by Belis. Mostly this was because she was the sort of character I really enjoy! I love warrior woman characters, and Belis had a lot of potential. But as the story progressed, she was kind of just…there. Especially in comparison to Mallt’s more complicated character arc, Belis was unchanged and unchallenged throughout most of the book.

Overall, this was a mixed bag. I really wanted to like it more than I did. The uneven pacing and tone really threw me off, and I often found myself wanting more from the characters. However, fans of historical fantasy might still really enjoy this one!

Rating 7: While I enjoyed both the more serious historical fantasy elements as well as the cozy quest, I wasn’t sure that these two mixed particularly well here.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Nightshade and Oak” can be found on this Goodreads list: Adult Queer Romantasy 2026.

Serena’s Review: “Silver & Bloood”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Silver & Blood” by Jessie Mihalik

Publishing Info: Avon, January 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: Netgalley!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: There’s something in the woods…

Untrained and barely armed, Riela reluctantly agrees to enter the forest and kill the deadly beast that has been attacking her fellow villagers as she’s the only mage available—or so she thought. When one beast turns into two, she fears her death is at hand, but unexpected aid from a scarred, strikingly handsome man with dangerous moonlit magic means a second chance at life—and an opportunity to learn more about her own fickle power.

After being rescued and healed from her fight in the forest, Riela awakens in a magical castle complete with a gorgeous library, a strange wolf, and the surly man who saved her life. Riela soon learns Garrick is not a mortal mage at all—he’s a powerful Etheri sovereign who has been locked out of his kingdom in Lohka for nearly a century, and his powers are weakening.

Trapped in his castle and surrounded by the treacherous woods, the spark of attraction between Riela and Garrick slowly ignites into fiery desire. But the more they discover about Riela’s magic, the more suspicious Garrick grows of her identity. As they unravel the secrets connecting Riela’s past to Lohka, the tenuous threads of trust between them begin to fray because Riela’s life—or her death—might be the key to regaining everything Garrick has lost.

Review: I’ll be honest, I was sucked in on this one by the cover art. I don’t often love character art on covers, but something about this one was working for me! The book itself, while not terrible, didn’t hit quite as strongly.

I will say, it started off well. The plot takes off as if its life depends upon it, leaving the reader feeling swept along in a story that has already begun. There were numerous action scenes in the first few pages, and Riela’s POV added an intriguing element. She came across as competent, while also not slotting into the played-out “snarky badass” category. Indeed, I was pleased to see that she recognized that she was out of her depth several times early on.

Unfortunately, after the blistering pace of the first few chapters, once Riela reaches the enchanted castle and meets the MMC, the book seems to run smack-dab into a brick wall. Any pacing or tension that was built up immediately drained away, and the plot began circling the same few beats, chapter after chapter. Riela would explore the castle, look for food, have a brief interaction with the overly mysterious and withdrawn MMC, and then rinse and repeat. This took up the majority of the book, ultimately, with things only picking up again towards the final quarter of the story.

Further, once the pace slowed down and the plot became repetitive, I was left with too much time to think through the ins and outs of this world. And very quickly, much of it began to feel slightly derivative and unimaginative. I enjoyed the “Beauty and the Beast” vibes that made up the basic premise, but I was left wanting a bit more from almost every part of the book by the time we got to the end.

That said, I think the writing itself was fairly strong. Like I said, the book starts off strong, and the main character was written in a compelling manner. I didn’t hate my reading experience by any means, and I’ll definitely check out another book by this author. This just missed the mark a bit, unfortunately. That said, if you’re looking for a romantasy book that checks some familiar fairytale boxes and includes solid writing, this one might be for you!

Rating 7: While the writing and characterization were strong, there simply wasn’t enough plot or pacing to hold the story together through the lagging middle portion.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Silver & Blood” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Romantasy TBR 2026 and 2026 Fantasy Romance Releases.

Serena’s Review: “The Shattered King”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Shattered King” by Charlie N. Holmberg

Publishing Info: 47North, September 2025

Where Did I Get this Book: bought it!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: The kingdom of Cansere is on the brink of war. Young men are conscripted from their homes, and a royal decree from the queen has made healing the only legal form of craftlock. Nym, a healer and beekeeper, is the sole provider for her family of seven now that her younger brother has been sent to the warfront. But when a letter comes from the queen, summoning Nym to the palace to heal Prince Renn, the kingdom’s ailing shut-in, Nym finds herself making the tumultuous journey from her family’s apiary to the capital city. Nym is determined to fail the queen’s mission and return to her younger siblings as soon as she can.

But escaping the castle’s hold isn’t as easy as failing a simple test. Prince Renn is cold and distant, and his illness is nothing like Nym has ever seen before, nothing she could ever imagine treating. In a moment of connection with Prince Renn, Nym manages to remedy the faintest symptom of his ailment―only to discover that no healer before has made such progress. Forced to become the prince’s official healer and a ward of the castle, and with her only hope of returning to her family hinging on the prince’s recovery, Nym must navigate the castle’s cruel and twisted court and uncover the haunting truth behind Prince Renn’s illness―even as she finds herself irrevocably drawn to him.

Review: I read and reviewed a book by this author back in 2017, The Paper Magician, but I’ll be honest, as much as I enjoyed that read at the time, I fell off on tracking the author further. This book only ended up on my radar because it was mentioned by a fellow reviewer who has similar taste as I do with regards to fantasy romance.

I absolutely adored this book! It’s rare that I turn the last page on a book and want to then turn around and re-read it immediately, but that was the case here. There were simply so many great things about it! But I think, looking back, one of the things I appreciated the most was the fact that books like this are proof positive that you can write a compelling romance without compromising on other important elements, notably world-building, magic systems, and complicated supporting characters. So, while the romance was one of my favorites as well, it was the strength of these three foundational elements that really raised it above the rest!

The world-building and magic in this book were fantastic. The basic concepts were familiar: magic users who fall into three categories (healing, mind-reading, compelling), who are feared and persecuted to some extent by the nations that house them. But the ways in which this magic was explored, particularly the healing abilities of our main character, were so interesting. Indeed, the author commits a fairly significant amount of page time to exploring how exactly this magic system works, with numerous scenes going into the strengths and limitations of Nym’s abilities. This devotion to detail is then paid off by incredible twists and turns that only come into play late in the book and wouldn’t have worked had the reader not been given a good understanding beforehand.

Further, I really enjoyed the political elements. Much of this was built up in this book and looks to be coming to the forefront in the sequel. But even here, what made much of these political scenes work was the fact that the author took the time to develop these secondary characters in a way that readers were given plenty of time to form opinions and theories about them and their motivations. So then when added layers are revealed or complicating factors introduced, the reader is invested enough to care what happens to them, even if they are not the main characters. Even characters that I thoroughly despised had me on the edge of my seat towards the end!

But, of course, the story really lives and dies on the strength of the romance and the two characters involved. The story is told fully from Nym’s perspective, something that I prefer! Too often I feel like the inclusion of both POVs is used as a crutch by authors to simply tell readers how both parties are feeling, rather than taking the time to show us, as is necessary when the reader only has access to one character’s inner thoughts. Beyond that, the book takes its time revealing Nym’s full history. There are many references to major events in her past, but this information is carefully doled out throughout the book. I love this approach! The author trusts that readers will be invested enough to want to get to know this character further, rather than being spoon-fed her entire history and character motivation right from the get-go.

And Renn was everything I love in a romantic lead! The story is a true slow-burn, with Renn only gradually coming to understand his own shortcomings and the reality of Nym’s experiences. But once he does, boy, is he great! This is solidly a “he falls first” romance, and the author takes full advantage of all the tension and longing that this setup allows. It’s so refreshing to read a romantic lead who is not brooding or overly secretive, but instead is direct about what he wants. And the limitations holding the relationship back are solidly grounded in the realities of the characters and the world, not clearly orchestrated angst that could be solved with a quick conversation.

I will say, the book does end on a fairly major cliffhanger! But never fear, the second book is coming out in a few short months, and I already have my e-ARC in hand! We’ll see how long I can hold out, but if things continue in this direction, I think this duology will easily earn a spot on my Top 10 for next year! If you enjoy fantasy romance with solid character work that doesn’t skimp on the actual fantasy elements, then this is definitely one to check out!

Rating 10: Absolutely brilliant! A perfect melding of the best of both worlds in the fantasy and romance genres!

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Shattered King” can be found on these Goodreads lists: My favorite Medieval Fantasy novels and All the New Fantasy Books Arriving in September 2025.

Serena’s Review: “A Heart So Green”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Heart So Green” by Lyra Selene

Publishing Info: Orbit, January 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: After the explosive finale of the Tournament of Kings, Fia and Irian manage to escape to the wildlands, dodging pursuit by her cunning sister Eala. With Fia locked in her own mind, battling a powerful celestial entity, Irian must form new alliances to come up with a plan to defeat Eala’s terrifying magic.

With both the human and fae realm under threat, Eala’s rampage must be stopped, no matter the cost. On Bealtain Eve, when the veil between worlds is at its thinnest, Fia and Irian will finally face off against the swan princess and forge the ending to their love story that was written in the stars.

Previously Reviewed: “A Feather So Black” and “A Crown So Silver”

Review: Surprise! I’m back with another review for this trilogy! After my…less than enthusiastic response to book two, I was really wavering on finishing off the series. But Orbit was kind enough to send me a copy, so I thought, why the heck not. Better to be a completionist in this instance and finish up the series.

And while I still didn’t love this one, I was at least better prepared for what I could now expect and ended up enjoying it a bit more. I’ll preface the entire review by saying that I think the first book was by far the strongest and that had the trilogy lived up to that initial potential, this could have been excellent. Unfortunately, many of the choices with regards to the romance and the main character’s arc were very much not to my preference, both in the second book and this one.

This book added perspectives to the story, ending up with a total of four. On one hand, this, blessedly, meant less time spent in Fia’s mind (frustrating) or Irian’s mind (boring). However, on the other hand, neither of these added POVs felt truly necessary to the plot. Like the second book, throughout the entire reading experience I was left asking, “why?” Again, it felt like the author was padding out this book with drawn-out side quests, meandering thought spirals, and heaping piles of angst.

What it didn’t have, however, was a compelling or tied-together plot. Many of the characters and world-building points that were established in the first book were still left hanging with very little resolution here. The pacing, especially in the first half, was glacial, waiting for Fia to solve her particular quandary and being stuck in Irian’s head as he moped over her loss. Things picked up a bit after that, but even then, the plot quickly devolved into seemingly disconnected side quests. And then it ended in a surprisingly tragic and unfulfilling manner, the likes of which I think will frustrate many readers, even those who may have enjoyed book two more than me.

By the end of this one, I’m not sure if the author was pushed to extend a shorter book into a trilogy or whether she simply never had a good handle on what this story was truly meant to be about. The solid characterization and interesting world-building that were established in the first book seemed to fall off a cliff in the second book and never recovered. It almost felt like two different authors wrote the first book and then book two and three. I did bump this one up a notch from my rating for book two, mostly because I think Fia was at least somewhat improved by the end of this book. But I still found this entire trilogy to be incredibly disappointing given how much I loved the first book.

Rating 6: A truly baffling trilogy where the first book stands miles above the second two, and we are left with a tragic, confused ending to the story here in the final chapter.

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Heart So Green” can be found on this Goodreads list: Can’t Wait Sci-Fi/Fantasy of 2026.

Serena’s Review: “The Elsewhere Express”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Elsewhere Express” by Samantha Sotto Yambao

Publishing Info: Del Rey, January 2026

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: You can’t buy a ticket for the Elsewhere Express. Appearing only to those whose lives are adrift, it’s a magical train carrying very rare and special cargo: a sense of purpose, peace, and belonging.

Raya is one of those lost souls. She had dreamed of being a songwriter, but when her brother died, she gave up on her dream and started living his instead. One day on the subway, as her thoughts wander, she’s swept off to the Elsewhere Express. There she meets Q, a charming, handsome artist who, like her, has lost his place in the world.

Together they find a train full of wonders, from a boarding car that’s also a meadow to a dining car where passengers can picnic on lily pads to a bar where jellyfish and whales swim through pink clouds. But they also discover that the train harbors secrets—and danger: A mysterious stranger has stowed away and brought with him a dark, malignant magic that threatens to destroy the train.

But in investigating the stowaway’s identity, Raya also finds herself drawing closer to the ultimate question: What is her life’s true purpose—and might Q be connected to it?

Review: For the most part, I enjoyed this author’s debut book, Water Moon. It was written in a gorgeous, lyrical style, and the sheer scope of creativity on display was truly impressive. The characters were also largely enjoyable. What held me back was the very loose trappings of a plot that held together the inventive scenes that took place throughout the book. All of this being the case, I was excited to see another book coming out from this author, as I thought she had a lot of potential. I will admit, however, that I was a bit concerned by the synopsis: in many ways, it sounded like it was leaning into the exact problem points that I had with the first book. And now, having completed it, I have to say that that impression was correct.

That’s not to say that I didn’t enjoy this read! Like the first book, there was a lot to enjoy here, and many of the author’s strengths were once again on display. There’s no overstating how impressive the author’s range for creativity truly is. The book moves from train car to train car, each more fantastical and whimsical than the last. These descriptive elements also continue to be written using a lovely, flowing style that perfectly aligns with the dream-like quality of these worlds. The author also made an attempt to tie some of these fantastical scenes into deeper themes of loss and life. There were a few moments here that really stood out. However, others felt like they were either too on the nose or too obscure to be fully realized.

However, once again, the story fell apart a bit with the plot itself. Our main characters were interesting enough (though I will say that the friendship between them developed quite quickly, all things considered). But the premise of the train itself did start to feel very tired very quickly, with our characters simply moving from one section to another, again and again. Our primary main character, Raya, seems to early on realize that this is more than it seems and wishes to leave the confines of the train, and, unfortunately, this sentiment transfers to the reader all too easily.

Beyond that, I was a bit disappointed with the whole “train” thing of it all. I love trains. I grew up traveling across the country on them every summer, and there is truly an old-fashioned sort of “romanticism” to be found there. However, as far as the structure of this story is concerned, our characters could have been traveling through any series of interconnected places. They could be in a hotel just as easily as a train, for all that it mattered. The train itself was just a vehicle (no pun intended) for these fantasy scenes to be strung along, rather than a feature itself.

Ultimately, my experience was very similar to that of Water Moon. I was initially pulled in by the beautiful whimsy of it all. But as the book continued, the formula quickly became tired, and I needed more depth from our characters and more “plot” from the plot to really become invested in what was going on. I’m starting to think that this author might do better going the novella route, similar to Seanan McGuire and her Wayward Children series. In a shorter format, I think the author’s true genius for wildly creative fantasy worlds could be better highlighted while not getting tangled up in weaker plotting. Overall, I’ll say that your experience with this book will likely be similar to your experience with Water Moon. If you loved that book, I highly recommend this one. If you’re a bit on the fence, just make sure to expect a similar experience here.

Rating 7: High marks for imagination and whimsy, but sadly lackluster as far as plot and characterization.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Elsewhere Express” can be found on these Goodreads lists: The Most Beautiful Covers of 2026 and All the New Fantasy Books Arriving in January 2026.