This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “Dark Sisters” by Kristi DeMeester
Publishing Info: St. Martin’s Press, December 2025
Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from NetGalley
Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound
Book Description: Three women. Three centuries. One legacy of fury, love, and a power that refuses to die
In this fiercely captivating novel, horror meets historical fiction when a curse bridges generations, binding the fates of three women. Anne Bolton, a healer facing persecution for witchcraft, bargains with a dark entity for protection—but the fire she unleashes will reverberate for centuries. Mary Shephard, a picture perfect wife in a suffocating community, falls for Sharon and begins a forbidden affair that could destroy them both. And Camilla Burson, the rebellious daughter of a preacher, defies conformist expectations to uncover an ancient power as her father’s flock spirals into crisis.
Review: Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eARC of this novel!
Every year around the holidays when I’m doing my shopping, I try to grab some goodies from the Etsy shop Scent from Hell. It’s a candle store that is inspired by horror movies. I have a few of the candles that have been available over the years, with scents inspired by such wonderful things as “The Witch”, “Dracula”, “The Blair Witch Project”, and more. And to make things even better, the owner, Kristi DeMeester, is a horror author that I really enjoy! And her newest novel “Dark Sisters” is out, and I was VERY excited to read it! I love stories with dark magic, witches, and horror as a metaphor for generational trauma already, and when you add in a critique of a zealous religious fervor? Oh gosh yes I am all about it.
This story is told through three different perspectives in three different time periods, all within the community of Hawthorne Springs, a deeply Christian, deeply prosperous town with a devout church culture. In 2007, pastor’s daughter Camille is gearing up to finally attend her first Purity Ball, as much as her mother is reluctant to let her do so. But people in town, specifically women, are getting sick, with an illness that is thought to be due to a witches curse that is known as The Dark Sisters. In 1953, Mary Shepherd is trying to do her best to be a doting wife and loving mother as a housewife, but she falls in love with a pagan woman who makes her feel like herself. And in the 1750s, a healer woman named Anne is hoping to keep herself and her daughter Florence, who is deeply Christian and longs for her own path, safe, bargaining in a way that goes wrong and has deadly consequences. I really liked all of the stories, and enjoyed how DeMeester slowly unfolds all of these women’s paths, connecting them in ways that could be obvious, but feel fresh and interesting. I thought that the witch and magical aspects of this book were appropriately creepy while also feeling powerful and awe inspiring, and as we see the unfortunate consequences start to unravel the tension and scares go faster and faster, with the stakes high not only because of a dark magic that is dangerous and deadly, but also because of a patriarchal religious culture that does its own damage, and takes advantage of the women within it to gain more power and influence whilst causing harm to said women.
And let’s talk about those themes, because they were the most compelling part of this book. The feminine rage in this book is tied to the way that Hawthorne Springs credits its success and wealth to a good Christian devotion, so much so that those that stray (mostly women) are shunned, rebuked, sent away for reprogramming, and in some cases fall ill with an affliction that may or may not kill them. DeMeester isn’t shy when portraying such things as religious abuse, misogyny, and high control tactics used by men to control the women they wish to be subservient, but she is also very good at pointing out the differences of experience between the women, which can make them pit themselves against each other in hopes of being spared or seen as an exception. She makes sure to show it in all of the timelines, whether it’s Florence hoping that choosing a Christian path (and betraying her mother) will keep her safe, or gossip setting off a domino effect that sets Mary’s life towards ruin, or Camille being willing to be the perfect pastor’s daughter to reap the benefits whilst rebelling flagrantly when others are sent off for re-education for much less. I really found that to be upsetting, while also fully recognizing how on point it is, especially these days.
“Dark Sisters” is a creepy and angry horror novel that I really enjoyed. If you’ve been experiencing some feminine rage as of late, I highly suggest checking it out.
Rating 9: A dark and angry tale about control, men who take advantage of women’s power, and feminine rage at the breaking point, “Dark Sisters” feels unfortunately timely and brings a lot of witchy scares.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Dark Sisters” is included on the Goodreads lists “Witches, Goddesses, or Nuns”, and “Feral Women”.
The Library Ladies 