Kate’s Review: “The Brood”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Brood” by Rebecca Baum

Publishing Info: Thomas & Mercer, October 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the author

Where You Can Get This Book: Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: A fascinating blend of horror and magical realism, this spine-tingling thriller explores the complex relationship between women, their bodies, and the natural world.

Cutthroat NYC lawyer Mary Whelton just buried her problematic old mentor. But as she leaves the mourners and protesters behind, the press stays hot on her heels. Desperate to escape, she unwittingly barrels deep into a remote forest in upstate New York. Until a collision—with a buzzing, oozing throng of cicadas—stops her dead in her tracks.

She awakens in a crude cabin, held captive by Girl, a simple, hulking woman who mistakes Mary for her derelict mother and obsesses over a mysterious Brood. While tortured echoes from Mary’s past feed her growing sense of fear, it becomes clear that she’s destined to bear an unthinkable role in the cicadas’ cyclical reemergence. But when Girl’s grisly past comes back to haunt them both, Mary is thrust into a violent battle of wills.

Confoundingly creepy and atmospheric, The Brood peels back the hurt and pain of the female experience, laying bare the messy necessity for transformation and growth.

Review: Thank you to Rebecca Baum for sending me an ARC of this novel!

We are starting to wind down our Horrorpalooza celebration, as Halloween is on Friday and October is almost at its end. I’m always sad when it comes time to wrap up this fun review theme, but don’t worry. We still have two more horror focused reviews for the celebration (and obviously there will be more horror reviews from me because that’s my jam all year round). And I am coming in hot with the second to last entry for Horrorpalooza 2025! Rebecca Baum asked me if I’d be interested in reading her body horror novel “The Brood”, and I was admittedly a bit squeamish at the premise. Body horror freaks me out, and parasitic body horror REALLY freaks me out. But the premise caught my attention, and I wanted to take a chance on it because it sounded quite promising. And I’m glad that I did, because I found “The Brood” to be a well done body horror tale. And VERY disgusting.

The atmosphere and building dread in this book is top notch. Mary is a high powered attorney who has become a bit of a ruthless ‘fixer’, and after a car crash while leaving a funeral in the remote backwoods she is taken captive by a hulking, strange woman who is only known as ‘Girl’. Girl is convinced that Mary is her long lost mother, and keeps her hostage so a cicada swarm she calls ‘The Brood’ can lay eggs and gestate in Mary’s body. SO, first I want to talk about the backwoods horror, as that is a sub-genre I really like. The isolation, the inability to escape, the lurking cave that may or may not have some kind of greater horror that won’t let Mary leave, it’s all creepy and strange and suffocating. Girl is both foreboding but also sympathetic for a litany of reasons, and as she and Mary (more on her in a bit) interact they spar, butt heads, but also kind of learn to understand each other. She’s more than the stereotypes of your typical ‘backwoods malevolent hillbilly’ trope, and I found her to be a scary AND sympathetic foil for Mary.

Okay. The body horror. With parasitic themes. I will come out and say first and foremost that I have a REALLY hard time with this kind of horror sub-genre, and always have. I full we knew going into this book that this was the kind of thing I was signing up for, and I knew that I was going to have a hard time with it. And I did. SO MUCH PUSS!! But I want to talk about why I still enjoyed(?) it, or at least appreciated it, as a person who has such a huge case of the willies with this kind of thing, and that is that this kind of horror story is always going to be reminiscent of losing bodily autonomy, which especially these days is a real life horror that many face (even if it isn’t cicadas taking over the body) and is terribly relevant. The way that Girl prioritizes the cicada clutch growing in Mary’s body and how that in turn leads to some pretty horrifying moments even beyond the body horror bits (case in point with few spoilers, a hunger strike Mary implements that Girl is QUICK to snuff out. I had to pause my reading for a little bit because man, force feeding is SO brutal and Baum really captures it). It’s scary enough thinking about insects growing under your skin. It’s even worse when it mirrors the way that pregnant people who don’t want to be pregnant are sometimes forced to carry a pregnancy no matter the cost to their bodies and minds. Be warned: this book goes hard. It did for me anyway.

But there was also a surprising undercurrent of ache and sorrow when it comes to Mary’s backstory that slowly bubbles up, and concludes in a way that had me crying for the last couple chapters of the book. Mary is a very cold and damaged woman when we meet her, and she doesn’t REALLY soften at all, at least not in expected ways, as the story goes on and she has to endure her kidnapping, torture, and being a reluctant vessel for an insect clutch in her body. She’s done some terrible things in her frenzy to become successful. But at the same time, we learn that she has a deep, deep trauma due to being abandoned to an orphanage as a five year old, and being abused for a lot of her life, and shows how these things affect her path. Baum is sure not to make excuses for the terrible harm she caused at one point. But she does help the reader understand why she did what she did, and it makes it a nuanced take that has a very emotional resolution.

“The Brood” is probably not for the squeamish, but for those who love some disgusting body horror that doesn’t hold back (and does lean way into the metaphors in an effective way), it will be a gross and enjoyable read.

Rating 8: Disgusting and visceral body horror combined with feminist themes of bodily autonomy make for a nasty but relevant read. It also made me cry unexpectedly!

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Brood” isn’t on any Goodreads lists as of yet, but it would fit in on “Books with Creepy Crawlers”!