Kate’s Review: “The Mean Ones”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Mean Ones” by Tatiana Schlote-Bonne

Publishing Info: Creature Publishing, September 2025

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publisher at ALAAC25

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: So what if Sadie hears talking dead animals and a strange, comforting male voice in her head? The therapist insists these are just symptoms of PTSD. It makes sense considering that she hid under the bed and watched as her best friends were slaughtered.

But the murders were seventeen years ago, back when her name was Sabrina. Now, she’s Sadie: a perfectly normal 29-year-old. She works as a physical therapist assistant and lifts weights with her boyfriend, Lucas, who’s the sweetest, most considerate man—as long as he’s not angry. But when Lucas spontaneously agrees to join a couples trip to a cabin in the woods, the visions get worse, a strange figure stalks her during the night, and that male voice in Sadie’s head keeps calling, asking her to do things she’s never fathomed.

Sadie’s not sure if it’s her paranoia or something else entirely . . . But she is sure of one thing—this time, she’s not going to sit idly by as everything starts to unravel.

Review: Thank you to Creature Publishing for giving me an ARC of this novel at ALAAC25!

Back in June when Serena and I were in Philadelphia for the ALA Annual Conference I found myself circling and flagrantly stalking the Creature Publishing table, as they only had the table for a limited time, and I was DETERMINED to seek them out. Specifically for the book “The Mean Ones” by Tatiana Schlote-Bonne, as not only had it been getting some pretty solid hype, it also promised to have “Midsommar” and “Yellowjackets” vibes. True, I didn’t really like “Midsommar”, and I haven’t watched “Yellowjackets”, but the vibes of both? I’m INTO THOSE VIBES! It took a few awkward circles (as well as a few polite ‘no, I’m looking for this specific publisher, thanks’ to a few well meaning reps at tables surrounding the area) but I finally got my hands on a copy, and had high, HIGH hopes that it would be as awesome as I was hoping it would be. And whaddaya know? It was even MORE awesome!

Oh I just loved this. I’m appreciating folk horror more and more as time goes by, and weird entities in the woods and cult horror really tick off so many boxes for me. “The Mean Ones” definitely has both at hand, and I thought that Schlote-Bonne was great at building up a slow suspense both in the present with Sadie (though when she was a child her name was Sabrina) as an adult on a camping trip with her dodgy boyfriend Lucas and his friends, and also in the past with Sadie/Sabrina as a tween at camp with her best girl friends who are also not terribly kind to her. But both in the past and present she has been hearing things and seeing things, and while she tries to ignore it and just be normal it just keeps building up until something horrifying happens. Like friends Allie and Blakely being brutally murdered in front of Sadie/Sabrina by something sinister. The mysteriousness of what is going on in the woods, what Sadie/Sabrina is seeing and hearing, and what really happened to her friends and herself at camp is so well done and so well paced, and some of the moments of horror really unnerved me. There’s just something about a oh so wrong looking deer in the distant brush that just FREAKS me out in the best way. I’m trying to be vague because this is so good and it’s best to go in with as little info as possible, but at the end of the day if you like folk horror, this will surely be up your alley.

But it’s also the very real, relatable human aspects of Sadie/Sabrina and the way that she is pushed and mistreated by the people who are supposed to care about her that will probably resonate with readers. I really liked her as a protagonist, finding her to be relatable in a lot of ways as lord knows I’d been the odd girl out or picked on in my adolescent female friendships, and Sadie/Sabrina was REALLY familiar in her choices, anger, and pain. She has suffered from so much trauma that she has tried to mold herself into someone normal, but in doing so has become a people pleaser not unlike her time as a third wheel in her friendship with only friends Allie and Blakely, who treated her pretty poorly in ways that tween and teenage girls can sadly fall into when it comes to clique behavior. It makes for a protagonist you want to root for, and as we learn more about her and how she has been coping and twisting herself up, we also see a woman that could be so much more… though perhaps in a ‘good for her’ kind of way that we have seen in films like “The Witch” and “Midsommar”. Feminine rage has its moment along with the folk and cult horror aspects, and Schlote-Bonne pulls it off handily. I loved every bit of Sadie/Sabrina’s character arc.

“The Mean Ones” is one of the best horror novels I’ve read this year. I am so glad I stalked the publisher’s table at ALAAC, and I will absolutely be checking out Tatiana Schlote-Bonne’s other books.

Rating 10: Spectacular folk and cult horror with shades of feminine rage, “The Mean Ones” is a knock out.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Mean Ones” is included on the Goodreads list “God Forbid Women Do Anything”.