This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “The Nightshade God” by Hannah Whitten
Publishing Info: Orbit, July 2025
Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher
Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound
Book Description: Lore has failed. She couldn’t save King Bastian from the rotten god speaking voices in his mind. She couldn’t save her allies from being scattered across the continent—their own lesser gods whispering to them in their dreams. She couldn’t save her beautiful, corrupt city from the dark power beneath the catacombs. And she couldn’t save herself.
Banished to the Burnt Isles, Lore must use every skill she earned on the streets of Dellaire to survive the prison colony and figure out a way to defeat the power that’s captured everything and everyone she holds dear. When a surprise ally joins her on the Burnt Isles she realizes the way forward may lie on the island itself. Somehow, her friends must help her collect the far-scattered pieces of the broken Fount—the source of all the god’s powers—and bring them back together on the Burnt Isles, returning all magic to its source and destroying, once and for all, the gods corrupting the land.
But as Lore gets closer to her goal, her magic grows stronger… and to a woman who’s always had to fight for survival, that kind of power may be hard to give up.
Previously Reviewed: “The Foxglove King” and “The Hemlock Queen”
Review: Well, this was a bit of a let down. It’s always disappointing to see a series take a downward trend, especially when you look back at a high point at the start. The first book introduced a compelling cast of characters, a well-thought out, complex world, and a hidden history with promises of many exciting reveals to come. The second book languished a bit with “middle book syndrome,” little plot actually took place and several of the characters seemed to stall out in their progression (I also began to see the writing on the wall of a romantic arc I was less interested in). And here we are with the third.
To start with what I did like. I continue to enjoy Whitten’s style of writing. She has a way of drawing me in, even when I’m struggling to enjoy the relationships being portrayed or there isn’t necessarily a lot of plot to speak of. In less capable hands, that second book could have really gone another direction. Here, too, she takes the risky choice of swinging the focus away from our main three characters and back towards the gods they have come to embody. Now, I didn’t love this choice, but her writing is of such a high quality that I still pushed through what might otherwise have been a DNF from me.
But that urge to DNF was there, especially when I got to the middle section of the book and realized that I was halfway through the conclusion to a trilogy about three main characters and I had spent most of my time focusing on three OTHER characters (the gods in the past) and my main trio weren’t even together on page. Bizarrely, this book read almost like another middle book, where the author introduces a bunch of new characters and keeps the main group apart, with the expectation that this will all pay off in the end.
But this is the end! I get that the three gods are reflections of Lore, Bastian and Gabe. But no matter how closely they resemble those characters or their relationships mirror those of our main trio, they are still, demonstratively, not those characters. That being the case, I was frustrated with how much of the story focused on the interplay between these gods and their histories. Further, unlike an actual middle book, this one was our last chance to see our main trio together, so to spend so much of the story with them separated was truly unfortunate. For her part, Lore remains a good character on her own. But the dynamics between the characters is really what helps Bastian and Gabe to shine, so by distancing them all from one another, there was a decline in overall character quality to be found.
Lastly, I didn’t enjoy the romance. This is a completely subjective take, and I know many readers’ primary interest was in the throuple at the heart of the story. And, stepping back from my own preferences, I think all of those readers will be completely satisfied with this book. However, romance is a genre/topic that is incredibly subjective. Of all the genres, I think it is the one best served with tropes/hashtags assigned from the very start. A reader who enjoys dark romance is going to be into very different scenes and topics than a cozy romance reader. And the latter is best served by knowing right from the start that its a dark romance that they are picking up. So, too, with various pairings. Some readers enjoy reverse harems and throuples, while others are solidly monogamous/fated mates/etc. readers. I’m definitely the latter, and that being the case, this love story wasn’t for me.
This is one of those exact situations where I wish the book had been properly tagged from the start. Now! Don’t get me wrong, I probably still would have read this trilogy and been pleased I had, because I enjoy this author’s work and it’s not like throuples/polyamory are dealbreakers in any way. However, my expectations would have been properly aligned from the start. As it stands, the first book set up a love triangle, but I finished it still with the expectation that the trilogy would conclude with Lore ending up with one or the other, not both. So I was ultimately disappointed when I saw the direction the love story took, as throuples aren’t really my thing
All of this to say, this was just a fine read. As a whole, I don’t think the trilogy was properly paced, with the last two books both floundering a bit after the tightly plotted first book. That said, I think readers who are heavily invested in Lore/Bastian/Gabe will be incredibly happy with the way this book wraps up! I’ll definitely check out what Whitten writes next, but this trilogy won’t go down as one of my favorites from her.
Rating 7: This will definitely work for some, but I think it suffers from losing its focus on the main three characters at the heart of the story.
Reader’s Advisory:
“The Nightshade God” can be found on these Goodreads lists: Romantasy TBR 2025 and Baroque Fantasy.
The Library Ladies 