This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “Bald-Faced Liar” by Victoria Helen Stone
Publishing Info: Lake Union Publishing, June 2025
Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publicist.
Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound
Book Description: Living a lie becomes a matter of life and death for a woman hiding from her past in a novel of mounting psychological suspense by the bestselling author of Jane Doe and The Hook.
Traveling nurse Elizabeth May has a promising new home in Santa Cruz. And another new identity. It’s a pattern of reinvention for a woman escaping her traumatic childhood—and hiding from the decades of notoriety and destruction that followed. Invisibility has kept Elizabeth safe. Until now. After all these years, someone sees her for who she is.
Threat by threat, a vengeful stalker is dismantling Elizabeth’s carefully constructed lifetime of lies. And no one in her temporary circle can be trusted—not her fleeting new love interest, not the supportive friend she knows only from online forums, and certainly not the police. They’ve never been there for her.
As fear sharpens to terror, Elizabeth soon discovers something about her past that even she didn’t know. The revelation could finally set her on a path of healing and redemption. Or, now alone in the dark, it could be Elizabeth’s worst nightmare.
Review: Thank you to Kaye Publicity for sending me an ARC of this novel!
Perhaps, if you have been following our blog for awhile now, you will see that I have picked up a thriller with a pretty significant Satanic Panic theme, and are now asking yourself ‘hey, doesn’t Kate get absolutely incandescent with rage when it comes to this topic?’ And you would be correct. The Satanic Panic really gets me steamed, so much so that I have been known to skip episodes of favorite podcasts if they are focusing on it. FAVORITE PODCASTS, GUYS. But when I was sent information about “Bald-Faced Liar” by Victoria Helen Stone, even though it was Satanic Panic themed, I had a feeling that I really wanted to give it a chance. The description of a traveling nurse named Elizabeth being stalked, possibly due to her long ago involvement in a false accusation of Satanism at her daycare, just tantalized me. I had to give it a go, even if it was going to set me off. And I’m happy to say that not only did it NOT set me off, I also really liked this book!
The mystery at hand about who is stalking Elizabeth is well crafted and well executed. Triggering for me or not, using The Satanic Panic as a backdrop means that there could be PLENTY of people with motives to get revenge on Elizabeth, and Stone has so many threads here that she pulls together. The clues are there but not too easily deciphered, and Stone takes her time to lay them out and build the suspense of Elizabeth’s past as well as the stalking incidents that start to plague her. I also liked the slow burn mystery of Elizabeth’s history of being a five year old ‘witness’ to Satanic Panic charges that she was coached to say, with a timeline being put forth in a measured way that filled me with frustration but NOT with blinding rage as I have experienced with other Satanic Panic themed thrillers. Some reveals I kind of predicted, but for the most part I was pretty well surprised, and was VERY surprised by an element of the climax that I don’t want to spoil here. But I will say that it went in a direction that I wasn’t expecting, and it added a new level of stakes, AND some genuine humor that didn’t feel out of place even though things were a bit, shall we say, hectic.
I also really liked our protagonist Elizabeth. I am always cagey when I read thrillers with hot mess female protagonists, but Elizabeth doesn’t really fall into any well worn traps or tropes of the genre. She has her problems, but her background with the Satanic Panic and the trauma involved with being a false whistleblower was unique enough made her very sympathetic and her actions completely believable. I also really appreciated the grace that was given to Elizabeth by other characters in spite of her notoriety, because at the end of the day she was a child when she did those monumental and damaging things. I’ve seen other Satanic Panic based stories that try to demonize this kind of character, but Stone makes it VERY clear that no, a five year old being manipulated and coerced by adults around her for their OWN motives should not be held accountable for her actions. I was rooting for her basically from the jump. Honestly, I thought that all of the characters were fun! Be it librarian Violet, who wants to help Elizabeth in any way she can, to landlord Grigore, who is a bit shady but who has a soft spot for Elizabeth, I thought that our cast was stellar.
I really enjoyed “Bald-Faced Liar”. The twists were good, the characters were enjoyable, and I think it will make a great read for thriller fans this summer!
Rating 8: A taut and suspenseful thriller about lies, trauma, and running from all of it, “Bald-Faced Liar” kept me on the edge of my seat.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Bald-Faced Liar” isn’t included on any super specific Goodreads lists as of yet, but similar titles include Clay McLeod Chapman’s “Whisper Down the Lane” and Gillian Flynn’s “Dark Places”.
The Library Ladies 