Kate’s Review: “My Vampire Plus One”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “My Vampire Plus One” by Jenna Levine

Publishing Info: Berkley, September 2024

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from NetGalley

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: Nothing sucks more than fake dating a vampire in this paranormal romantic comedy from the USA Today bestselling author of My Roommate Is a Vampire.

Amelia Collins is by definition successful. She would even go so far as to say successfully single. But not according to her family, and she’s tired of the constant questions about her nonexistent dating life. When an invitation to yet another family wedding arrives, she decides to get everyone off her back once and for all by finding someone–anyone–to pose as her date.

After a chance encounter with Reginald Cleaves, Amelia decides he’s perfect for her purposes. He’s a bit strange, but that’s fine; it’ll discourage tough questions from her family. (And it certainly doesn’t hurt that he’s very handsome.) For centuries-old vampire Reggie, posing as her plus-one sounds like the ultimate fun. And if it helps his ruse of pretending to be human, so much the better.

As Amelia and Reggie practice their fauxmance, it becomes clear that Reggie is as loyal to her as the day is long, and that Amelia’s first impressions could not have been more wrong. Suddenly, being in a real relationship with Reggie sounds pretty fang-tastic.

Review: Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eARC of this novel!

Last year I read and reviewed the romance novel “My Roommate Is A Vampire” by Jenna Levine, which introduced us to Cassie and her vampire roommate turned lover Frederick. I found it to be very sweet and very fun (and very steamy), and quite enjoyed it. One of the standouts, however, was Frederick’s sarcastic fellow vampire friend (frenemy?) Reginald, whose wit and snide remarks consistently made me laugh. So when I saw the cover for the sequel “My Vampire Plus One”, I immediately thought ‘oh my GOD REGGIE IS GETTING A BOOK!’, and requested it post haste. I needed to see what Levine was going to do with his character and a love interest that would surely be able to stand toe to toe with him. And folks, this didn’t disappoint. A fake dating romance is already a trope I love, and when you make a high strung accountant meet a vampire bad boy, I am even MORE desperate to read it.

Since it is Halloween Season and this is in my Horrorpalooza celebration, I will first talk about the general vampire mythos that Levine is continuing here. I am still quite enjoying the way that she is tackling vampires and how they are functioning in this version of our world, as they don’t feel shoe horned in, nor does the world feel very different from our own. Vampires like Reggie have vampiric traits that are familiar, though there are also some twists on them to make them feel unique (sunlight doesn’t kill them but it does cause some pain, different vampires have differing abilities, etc). I also liked the descriptions of “The Collective”, a long functioning vampire cult that is hunting down Reggie for a crime they think he committed centuries ago, but who all feel a bit bumbling and very “What We Do in the Shadows” in their silliness. To make things even more entertaining, one of the many epistolary devices used in this book is them communicating with each other on their hunt, and how their hunt isn’t going super well. There were many laugh out loud moments involving these kinds of chapter breaks (another of note: records from a bullet journaling chat room that Reggie frequents to ask for romantic advice. SO CHARMING). But even MORE intriguing? Levine has introduced the concept of witches in this world now, and boy I hope that if she does do a follow up we get a story centered around Reggie’s old potential lover Zelda, who is now running a hot yoga studio on the west coast.

And I also just loved Reggie and Amelia, and all of the delicious chemistry they have together. For Amelia, it’s her slightly neurotic and incredibly ambitious personality that makes her a little tightly wound, though very endearing all the same. I enjoyed how she is competent and incredibly clever, and loved that by getting entangled with Reggie she starts to learn to loosen up a bit, but not in a way that criticizes her personality or her character. And Reggie? Well. It’s a been pretty common to see two kinds of male vampire potential love interest archetypes in modern vampire literature. There’s the serious, broody, kind of sullen one, and there’s the sarcastic, mischievous, kind of bad boy one. Louis, Bill Compton, and Angel are all the former, while Lestat, Eric Northman, and Spike are all the latter. I have ALWAYS preferred the latter. And if Frederick in “My Roommate is a Vampire” is a Louis/Bill/Angle type, Reggie is DEFINITELY a Lestat/Eric/Spike type. And readers, this means I automatically ADORE HIM. Reggie is funny, he’s a bit mysterious, he’s a BIT of a dope, and he is so endearing in his terribly suppressed sappy/emotional side (he has a scrapbooked bullet journal and if THAT isn’t Spike coded I don’t know WHAT is!!). When you combine that kind of personality with Amelia’s kind of personality it is an instant win, and my gosh do these two have fantastic chemistry. Which, of course, means that the slow burn romance is VERY satisfying as they banter, pine, and eventually consummate. I really loved these two and was so on board with their love story.

I loved “My Vampire Plus One”! Even more so than its predecessor, which is saying something because I also really enjoyed that one too. Jenna Levine continues to be a go to for paranormal romance with a goofy edge!

Rating 9: A delightful and incredibly humorous follow up to a stand out read from last year, “My Vampire Plus One” is sexy and witty and everything I was hoping it would be!

Reader’s Advisory:

“My Vampire Plus One” is included on the Goodreads lists “Spooky Season Reads”, and “Vampires!”.