Kate’s Review: “The Drowning House”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “The Drowning House” by Cherie Priest

Publication Info: Poisoned Pen Press, July 2024

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publisher.

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Review: A violent storm washes a mysterious house onto a rural Pacific Northwest beach, stopping the heart of the only woman who knows what it means. Her grandson, Simon Culpepper, vanishes in the aftermath, leaving two of his childhood friends to comb the small, isolated island for answers―but decades have passed since Melissa and Leo were close, if they were ever close at all.

Now they’ll have to put aside old rivalries and grudges if they want to find or save the man who brought them together in the first place―and on the way they’ll learn a great deal about the sinister house on the beach, the man who built it, and the evil he’s bringing back to Marrowstone Island.

From award-winning author Cherie Priest comes a deeply haunting and atmospheric horror-thriller that explores the lengths we’ll go to protect those we love.

Review: Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press for sending me an ARC of this novel!

The description of “The Drowning House” by Cherie Priest made me do a double take the first time I read it. Surely I had read it wrong! A house, a full on HOUSE, washes up on a beach after a crazy storm? Obviously it has to be supernatural or something like that, but still, the very CONCEPT was SO interesting to me that I knew that I HAD to read the book. And not only do we have a weird house washing up on shore, we also have a missing man, his grandmother who died the night he vanished, which also happens to be the night the house washed ashore, and his childhood friends coming back to the small island community to try and find him, only to find something supernatural and menacing. All of these things come together to make a very odd read. In a good way, mostly.

There are lots of very creative aspects of this book, from the idea of an abandoned house washing up on shore, to some of the ancient magical and ritualistic elements that Priest creates for this book, to the concepts of communicating between dimensions and the way that this is achieved (mild spoiler but I HAVE to talk about it: a deranged otherworldly switchboard with some rather gruesome elements showed up at one point and I was completely horrified but also enthralled). I also did like some of the horror imagery, from figures materializing in the mist, to small town tragedies of missing boys whose spirits are seen crying the corners of Mrs. Culpepper’s home. So many of these things really worked for me, and it had this seaside atmosphere that was always tinted with some ominous undertones. It’s weird and dreamy and somewhat unnerving. I think that I would more categorize this as dark fantasy with horror elements as opposed to straight up horror, but trust me, the horror elements are on point.

The one critique I do have of this book is that I wasn’t as interested in our main characters Melissa and Leo, and their personal journey of having to team up in spite of their uneasy history in hopes of saving Simon, their childhood friend they are both deeply enamored with. I thought that they both had interesting back stories and understandable and believable motivations, but their tension never really resolved itself to create a genuine partnership that I was rooting for. Even getting flashbacks to their childhood and their friendship with Simon and some insight into Mrs. Culpepper’s background and her home (as well as some reveals about her connection to the washed up house and certain other things) didn’t really bring as much out of them as I would have liked.

Overall I think that “The Drowning House” has some really creepy beats and some really creative world building. But boy do I wish that the characterization had a little more oomph.

Rating 7: An atmospheric and at times creepy read, though I would say that “The Drowning House”‘s main characters weren’t as engaging as I had hoped they would be.

Reader’s Advisory:

“The Drowning House” isn’t on any Goodreads lists yet, but it would fit in on “Gothic Vibes (Modern Books)”.