Serena’s Review: “A Feather So Black”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “A Feather So Black” by Lyra Selene

Publishing Info: Orbit, March 2024

Where Did I Get this Book: ARC from the publisher!

Where Can You Get this Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | IndieBound

Book Description: In a kingdom where magic has been lost, Fia is a rare changeling, left behind by the wicked Fair Folk when they stole the High Queen’s daughter and retreated behind the locked gates of Tír na nÓg.

Most despise Fia’s fae blood. But the queen raises her as a daughter and trains her to be a spy. Meanwhile, the real princess Eala is bound to Tír na nÓg, cursed to become a swan by day and only returning to her true form at night.

When a hidden gate to the realm is discovered, Fia is tasked by the queen to retrieve the princess and break her curse. But she doesn’t go with her is prince Rogan, Fia’s dearest childhood friend—and Eala’s betrothed.

As they journey through the forests of the Folk, where magic winds through the roots of the trees and beauty can be a deadly illusion, Fia’s mission is complicated by her feelings for the prince…and her unexpected attraction to the dark-hearted fae lord holding Eala captive. Irian might be more monster than man, but he seems to understand Fia in a way no one ever has.

Soon, Fia begins to question the truth of her mission. But time is running out to break her sister’s curse. And unraveling the secrets of the past might destroy everything she has come to love.

Review: While Disney reigns supreme as far as fairytale movies go, for my sister and I, the collection of favorites wasn’t complete without including “Anastasia” and “The Swan Princess.” And, as far as the latter goes, the original fairytale itself has flown under the radar as far as fiction re-tellings go. I’m not sure I can even think of one off the top of my head? I feel like Mercedes Lackey might have done one at one point, but it’s definitely a lesser told story. All of that to say, I was incredibly excited when I discovered this book coming out this spring. Now, did it live up to admittedly high expectations?

Short answer, yes, yes it did! I loved almost everything about this book in fact! From the main character and her fierce, broken story, to the whimsical but dangerous Fae world that she explores, to the manner in which the story unfolds over an entire year, to the exemplary manner in which the author deals with the love triangle (proof that it’s possible!). On top of this all, the writing was confident and sure throughout, nicely balancing the vicious but beautiful nature of fairytales alongside the intricacies of depicting the complicated familial dynamics at play in Fia’s life. Telling a story that takes place over an entire year, with month-long breaks between trips to the Fae world is a complicated technique. It would be easy for the pace to languish between these trips or to feel as if time is not passing in a natural way. Instead, I was very impressed with the way the author balanced her more obviously exciting trips to the other world alongside the much greater period of time that Fia spends waiting back in the “real world.”

But this decision to draw out the story in this way over an entire year worked in more ways than just form. By giving the story this amount of time to breathe, Fia’s slow understanding about the truths regarding the people around her played out in a believable way. It’s always frustrating when main characters have grown up being told certain things their entire lives, trusting close family members or whomever, and then are told some alternate story by a relatively new source and easily throw off everything they knew before and all other feelings of loyalty or love that would be challenged. It’s just not believable. Instead, here, Fia’s journey is one of excruciating realizations about how she has been used by those around her and how her views of herself have been poisoned from the start.

On top of this, the use of this year-long approach to the story also allowed for the love triangle to play out in a believable way. Again, she didn’t just “get over” her feelings for the prince when she met some dark Fae guy in the other world. I feel like I’ve read that story a million times. No, instead a good chunk of the story is devoted to exploring the relationship between Fia and the prince, thoroughly exploring their complicated history, their wishes for the future, and the realities of their situation. On top of that, the reader can always look forward to the incredibly compelling and increasingly romantic scenes in the Fae world with the Fae lord. Here, too, Fia’s trust and understanding of this character grows naturally. No insta-love here! I will say, my one critique comes towards the end where Fia makes a few fairly questionable decisions and put her relationships with those around her at risk. But, while I was partly frustrated by this, it also was believable that Fia, with her complicated history of trust and deception, would be make some of these decisions. And even here, I really enjoyed the way this particular arc was resolved.

I also really liked the overall plot of the story. Yes, there are definite bits from the original “Swan Princess”/”Swan Lake” story. But this is also a wholly unique story. It was appropriately grim and dark, like all good fairytales are, had confusing curses at its heart all driven by a ticking clock by which they needed to be solved, and explored a complicated world and history between the humans and the Fae world. I was also incredibly surprised by some of the turns it took towards the end. I had a few ideas about a certain things that did play out the way I expected, but others were a complete shock! I can’t wait to read the next book in this series (though this one also concludes in a way that feels satisfying). Readers who enjoy fairytale fantasies should definitely check this one out!

Rating 9: A breath of fresh air in a crowded room of Fae fantasy stories! Dark, whimsical, and romantic, this book has it all!

Reader’s Advisory:

“A Feather So Black” isn’t on any relevant Goodreads lists yet, but it should be on Swan Lake Retellings.