Joint Review: “What Feasts At Night”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “What Feasts At Night” by T. Kingfisher

Publishing Info: Tor Nightfire, February 2024

Where Did We Get This Book: Kate received an eARC from NetGalley,

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: After their terrifying ordeal at the Usher manor, Alex Easton feels as if they just survived another war. All they crave is rest, routine, and sunshine, but instead, as a favor to Angus and Miss Potter, they find themself heading to their family hunting lodge, deep in the cold, damp forests of their home country, Gallacia.

In theory, one can find relaxation in even the coldest and dampest of Gallacian autumns, but when Easton arrives, they find the caretaker dead, the lodge in disarray, and the grounds troubled by a strange, uncanny silence. The villagers whisper that a breath-stealing monster from folklore has taken up residence in Easton’s home. Easton knows better than to put too much stock in local superstitions, but they can tell that something is not quite right in their home. . . or in their dreams.

Kate’s Thoughts

When Serena told me there was going to be a new “Sworn Soldier” story, I knew that I was already game to read it because of how much I enjoyed “What Moves the Dead”. I wasn’t sure of what to expect, as while the first book in the series was a retelling of Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Fall of the House of Usher”, I didn’t know if Kingfisher intended to do more Poe, or another classic horror author/story. But when I saw the description and saw that it had a ‘breath stealing monster’, and that the title implied that it was happening at night, I FLIPPED because I KNEW IT WAS GOING TO BE A NIGHT HAG!!!

Quick folklore lesson: a Night Hag, also known as a Boo Hag, a Mare, Karabasan, Witch Riding, and many other things, is almost certainly sleep paralysis, in which someone wakes in the middle of the night, unable to move, with a feeling of something pressing on your chest making it hard to breathe. I have been obsessed with Night Hag mythology ever since I went to Savannah for the first time and was fully terrified by the idea of a demonic force sitting on your chest and sucking your essence out of you while you slept. So “What Feasts at Night” is one HUNDRED percent up my alley, and I loved what Kingfisher did with it within her fictional setting of Gallacia. The slow build up of Alex slowly realizing that the people in the community they have recently returned to are falling ill by something mysterious and unknown, and starting to realize that perhaps it isn’t just superstition, was a great slow burn of eeriness and the exact kind of unsettling atmosphere I would want and expect from a Night Hag story. But Kingfisher always knows how to balance out the scares with some humorous moments as well, and there were PLENTY of moments that I was laughing out loud as well as reveling in the creepiness of the plot. And finally, I liked getting to know Alex a little bit more, whether it’s through flashbacks to their time in combat and how they are still coping with that, or with seeing them interact with familiar faces as well as new ones as they try to figure out what killed their old friend, and what may be targeting others as well.

“What Feasts at Night” was another spooky and spirited horror lite story from T. Kingfisher! Love seeing Night Hags in any story, and this one was pretty well done!

Serena’s Thoughts

Unlike Kate, I had no idea what type of horror story this was drawing from when reading the description. I’ve read other horror stories about beings that come in dreams or at night and sit on one’s chest (and the connection to sleep paralysis) but I didn’t know anything about the history of this type of being or any of its names. That’s all to say, even without any background knowledge, man, Kingfisher nailed the creepiness of this creature! I’ve never had sleep paralysis, but I do have “exploding head syndrome” fairly regularly, so I have a visceral reaction to this sort of story about some nefarious being/thing taking advantage of the vulnerability of sleep. While the horror stuff was definitely a slow burn affair, when it arrived, it was truly creepy. There was one scene in particular with the horses that really stuck with me, both because it was so viscerally horrifying, but also because…never mess with the horses!!

As for the rest of it, like Kate, I wasn’t sure what to expect from a return to this world. The first book was so successful on its own, perfectly introducing this character and world and neatly wrapping up that tale by the end in a way that felt complete. But I was pleasantly surprised by what we got here. Alex remains an excellent lead character with a distinct, often hilarious, POV. I also really enjoyed that the story took place in their homeland of Gallacia. We heard a decent amount about this fictional country in the first book, but we got even more here. I loved the whole “lovingly exasperated” take that Alex and the locals seem to have about their own country and its culture and history. Again, lots of laugh-out-loud lines to be found here.

Overall, I loved this book just as much as the first! Sign me up for a return to this world and character at any time! Can’t wait to find what other normal life event (like sleep) Kingfisher will manage to make terrifying for me…

Serena’s Rating 8: Leave it to Kingfisher to write a book that left me terrified to go to sleep but also cackling my way through the night.

Kate’s Rating 8: A fun take on Night Hag mythology and folklore, “What Feasts at Night” is scary, entertaining, and another enjoyable horror lite tale from T. Kingfisher!

Reader’s Advisory

“What Feasts At Night” is included on the Goodreads list “Can’t Wait Sci-Fi/Fantasty of 2024”, and “Horror to Look Forward to in 2024”.