Kate’s Review: “Midnight Is The Darkest Hour”

This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend.  Read the full disclosure here.

Book: “Midnight is the Darkest Hour” by Ashley Winstead

Publishing Info: Sourcebooks, October 2023

Where Did I Get This Book: I received an ARC from the publisher.

Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound

Book Description: From the critically acclaimed author of In My Dreams I Hold A Knife and The Last Housewife comes a gothic Southern thriller about a killer haunting a small Louisiana town, where two outcasts—the preacher’s daughter and the boy from the wrong side of the tracks—hold the key to uncovering the truth.

For fans of Verity and A Flicker in the Dark, this is a twisted tale of murder, obsessive love, and the beastly urges that lie dormant within us all…even the God-fearing folk of Bottom Springs, Louisiana. In her small hometown, librarian Ruth Cornier has always felt like an outsider, even as her beloved father rains fire-and-brimstone warnings from the pulpit at Holy Fire Baptist.

Unfortunately for Ruth, the only things the townspeople fear more than the God and the Devil are the myths that haunt the area, like the story of the Low Man, a vampiric figure said to steal into sinners’ bedrooms and kill them on moonless nights. When a skull is found deep in the swamp next to mysterious carved symbols, Bottom Springs is thrown into uproar—and Ruth realizes only she and Everett, an old friend with a dark past, have the power to comb the town’s secret underbelly in search of true evil.

A dark and powerful novel like fans have come to expect from Ashley Winstead, Midnight is the Darkest Hour is an examination of the ways we’ve come to expect love, religion, and stories to save us, the lengths we have to go to in order to take back power, and the monstrous work of being a girl in this world.

Review: Thank you to Sourcebooks for sending me an ARC of this novel!

Halloween is over but there is still a bit of Autumn left before things go full Winter over here (I mean, kind of…. it’s been VERY cold here, lately, so it feels more like Winter), and that means I’m still reveling in stories that just feel like the season. When “Midnight is the Darkest Hour” by Ashley Winstead ended up in my mailbox, the description made me think of dark nights and leaves and autumnal creepiness. It also caught my attention when the description made comparisons to “Thelma and Louise” and “Twilight”, because THAT is a combination that hadn’t crossed my mind before. So with my interest piqued and the seasonal aesthetic being perfect, I jumped in with high expectations, and I’m happy to say that they were pretty well met!

With the “Twilight” references, not only in the description but also in the book itself, I went into “Midnight is the Darkest Hour” with certain expectations about how the story was going to go, but Winstead kept me on my toes and subverted them in many ways. I think that the biggest surprise for me was how much I really loved the relationship between our protagonist Ruth and her best friend Everett, and how that relationship defined not only themselves, but also in a way how the community saw them. While our story is from Ruth’s perspective, told through what’s happening in the present and also what happened in the past, I felt like I not only got a good sense of who she was, I also got a good sense of who Everett was, and how complicated they both are due to their various traumas and experiences of growing up in a hyper-zealous small town that sees them as threats (though their various social standings, her being the powerful preacher’s daughter and him being the son of a notorious criminal, makes the town approach them in very different ways). I really enjoyed how Winstead, instead of merely making them star crossed lovers, made Ruth and Everett have a connection that started as trauma bonding in a way as they try to hide a terrible secret, and then turns into a relationship that transcends both romantic and platonic into something that just feels correct. You know that a bond between characters really gets me in the feels when I don’t even need them to be together romantically, I just need them to be together in whatever way is going to work for them, relationship definitions be damned (Buffy and Spike are another of these, looping back to more vampire lore). True, there are some shades of “Twilight” here, whether it’s parallels or straight up references, but they are done in a way that I really liked even if I have no nostalgia for that story.

And as for the mystery, Winstead creates a sense of place and a slow burn urgency in Bottom Springs that puts both Ruth and Everett in danger and makes the stakes high from the jump. What starts as a skull found in the swamp, and an introduction to two characters who may know how it got there, soon turns into a mystery involving small town secrets, religious zealotry that infects and rots a community, corruption, and the superstitions of an urban legend known as the Low Man, and how they all tie together. Winstead throws a out there, but it never feels overwhelming or that she loses control over all of the threads that go into making a dark and eerie tapestry. She reveals pertinent details when she wants to and keeps the secrets close, and while I figured out some things, it was rarely too much earlier than she was intending. And I am always going to be a fan of thrillers and mysteries that take on the dangers of fundamentalism and the hypocrisies of many who pretend to be righteous within systems of oppressive power, and there were many a moment that my blood was somehow both boiling AND running cold as Ruth and Everett cross those at Holy Fire Baptist. Especially since Ruth is the daughter of the man who influences all of it. So many things in this book just click for me on a personal level.

“Midnight is the Darkest Hour” is an eerie and propulsive thriller that kept me on the edge of my seat, and made me swoon over its two main characters. I definitely recommend it for the fleeting Autumn season.

Rating 9: An addictive and otherworldly thriller about small town secrets, religious trauma, and unbreakable bonds between misfits.

Reader’s Advisory:

“Midnight is the Darkest Hour” is included on the Goodreads lists “R.I.P. Book Challenge”, and “Reads for Fall/Autumn”.