This post may contain affiliate links for books we recommend. Read the full disclosure here.
Book: “Black Sheep” by Rachel Harrison
Publishing Info: Berkley, September 2023
Where Did I Get This Book: I received an eARC from NetGalley.
Where You Can Get This Book: WorldCat.org | Amazon | Indiebound
Book Description: A cynical twentysomething must confront her unconventional family’s dark secrets in this fiery, irreverent horror novel from the author of Such Sharp Teeth and Cackle.
Nobody has a “normal” family, but Vesper Wright’s is truly…something else. Vesper left home at eighteen and never looked back—mostly because she was told that leaving the staunchly religious community she grew up in meant she couldn’t return. But then an envelope arrives on her doorstep.
Inside is an invitation to the wedding of Vesper’s beloved cousin Rosie. It’s to be hosted at the family farm. Have they made an exception to the rule? It wouldn’t be the first time Vesper’s been given special treatment. Is the invite a sweet gesture? An olive branch? A trap? Doesn’t matter. Something inside her insists she go to the wedding. Even if it means returning to the toxic environment she escaped. Even if it means reuniting with her mother, Constance, a former horror film star and forever ice queen.
When Vesper’s homecoming exhumes a terrifying secret, she’s forced to reckon with her family’s beliefs and her own crisis of faith in this deliciously sinister novel that explores the way family ties can bind us as we struggle to find our place in the world.
Review: Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eARC of this novel!
There have been many online discourse controversies that have left me scratching my head over the years that I have been online, and one of the more recent ones was when people in the horror community got fully up in arms about the idea of ‘cozy horror’. There were some who thought that labeling some aspects of the horror genre as cozy was infantilizing, there were some who thought that horror can not have cozy or comforting aesthetics to it by definition, and there were some who were REALLY, REALLY angry from both sides. I myself don’t really use the phrase cozy horror (and I guess I sure won’t now!), but I do think that there are stories and authors that can be described as ‘horror lite’ (in that it’s still VERY valid but I may recommend her to friends who want a read for Halloween but don’t like being super freaked out or disturbed). One of the authors who comes to mind with that is Rachel Harrison, who has written books like “Cackle” and “What Sharp Teeth”, that are definitely horror at heart but have a, shall we say, lighter touch than bloodier or more twisted authors. I happen to really love her books and always recommend them to people from all genre backgrounds, and her newest one, “Black Sheep”, is another to add to the rec list! She’s done witches, she’s done werewolves, and now she’s taking on fundamentalist families and those who dare leave! With a bit of a twist.
I love Harrison’s deft touch in making these horror stories have charming and not as scary elements to them, while still making them feel very solidly in the horror genre. “Black Sheep” has some lighter moments and some nicely drawn pathos to go along with the creepier themes of fundamentalism and toxic family dynamics. Vesper is our main character, who has left her rural tight knit family behind due to their fundamentalist beliefs and how cagey they always made her feel, but decides to return when she receives a wedding invite from her teenage boyfriend and her cousin Rosie, and she wants to maybe throw in some petty drama out of past hurts. Even though she escaped the group, she is a bit of a hot mess (I mean, going to stir up shit at a wedding between an ex boyfriend and a friend, whom you left in the lurch? It’s a choice), and you wonder if that’s due to the fundamentalist sect she was raised in, or if there are other aspects at play that may be more supernatural. But she’s an endearing mess, and you definitely want her to be able to extricate herself from this toxic family dynamic while also finding her own identity that isn’t predicated on the group and their perceptions of her. She makes bad decisions, but she is also clearly dealing with a bit of trauma because of the hot and cold relationship she has with her family and her daring to leave the group and its core belief set. Like many of Harrison’s protagonists, she’s complex and sometimes frustrating, but I liked following her on her journey as the tries to reconcile her background and her future.
I also liked the way that Harrison approaches the group and family on the farm, as while they are definitely true believing fundamentalists who see anyone outside of themselves as less than, she also brings out the more enjoyable traits and aspects. It’s easy to paint groups like this in fiction as cartoon villain-y, or over the top, but Vesper’s family, while being obviously damaging and sanctimonious to a vicious degree, also have glimmers of humanity. Whether it’s a loving aunt who loves to dote on Vesper, or her cousin and childhood friend Rosie who is nervous and also elated for her wedding day, or even the few and far between moments where Vesper’s mother Constance has moments of true affection or sadness regarding the gulf between them, we see how groups like this can have these moments of humanity that are familiar and relatable. Fundamentalists scare me precisely because of the way that can be relatable, and then you may not realize you are being sucked into something until it’s too late.
And as for the horror elements, they are definitely there! Whether it’s some bits of body horror or moments of bloody violence, Harrison, while being more on the lighter side of the horror scale still can get under your skin and have scenes where you are reminded that oh yes, you are indeed reading a horror novel. There are other things that I might have otherwise gone into in this review, but I’m trying very hard to be vague because there is a bit of an element of surprise that is needed in this book.
“Black Sheep” is a fun mix of family drama, existential rumination, and affable horror tale. I so enjoy Rachel Harrison and what she is doing with her ideas within the genre, and it’s always a treat to see what she comes up with next.
Rating 8: A fun and subversive tale that examines family dynamics, destiny, and dysfunction, “Black Sheep” is a surprising horror lite novel from Rachel Harrison.
Reader’s Advisory:
“Black Sheep” isn’t included on any Goodreads lists yet, but it would fit in on the Goodreads shelf “Domestic Horror”.
The Library Ladies 